
UNSOLVED
G
glasskuter1
1 Rookie
•
9 Posts
0
2663
October 28th, 2021 13:00
Warning to XPS and Optiplex Users considering upgrading your cooling to Noctua
Searching through these forums I have seen many XPS and G5 users have great success in upgrading their cooling, but others (usually those with non-K CPUs) have run into this issue. I hope my experience might keep someone from going through what I have.
I'm posting this as an FYI to XPS and Optiplex users who use Noctua cooling solutions to upgrade their systems. For many (depending on your motherboard) Noctua is the BEST solution for fixing your overheating issues. However, depending on your motherboard, using Noctua fans in some systems can cause CPU fan failures at boot even though the fans work as they are supposed to.
After the fact and too late for me, I found this statement on Noctua's site: Noctua PWM fans feature a minimum speed of 300rpm to allow for ultra quiet operation when your CPU is at idle state and doesn’t require higher cooling performance. Some mainboards display error messages such as “CPU fan error” during the booting process when the fan speed is below a certain level. If you get such error messages using your Noctua PWM fan and if such options are available in your BIOS, please either adjust the minimum fan speed monitoring limit to 200rpm or increase the minimum PWM duty cycle. If your BIOS doesn’t offer these options, please disable CPU fan errors. For detailed information on BIOS fan settings, please consult your motherboard's manual or contact your motherboard manufacturer."
You may be one of the lucky ones where this Noctua upgrade will "just work" or if your motherboard's bios gives you control over your fan speeds, you should be fine. But in my case, my Dell Optiplex 7080 i9-10900 Motherboard 0J37VM bios 1.5.1 gives me absolutely no control so you either deal with the error at every boot and bypass it or go to a Dell premium cooler as I have which in turn made me have to install a VR heatsink because the Dell cooler blows hot air directly over the voltage components.
Noctua gave me this response to an email:
Greetings from Noctua!
Thanks for contacting us and for your interest in our products.
Unfortunately systems from Dell, HP, Lenovo and other big OEMs are often diverting from standards set by Intel or AMD by subtle details, thus none of our coolers or fans are compatible with such systems.
Kind regards,
Your Noctua Support-Team
Responses (1)
Solutions (0)

Mike D777
1 Rookie
•
3 Posts
0
1
Posted December 13th, 2024 00:26
Two options to try: 1) Use Noctua fan pins to connect the original Dell fan to the newly installed Noctua radiator. This way you avoid the RPM error by Dell's Bios. Noise levels will not be as low as engineered by Noctua and its fan, but you're taking advantage of its radiator. 2) With an extension cord, place the Dell CPU fan somewhere else in the tower as an additional fan and using a Y connector, connect the Noctua fan to the exhaust fan connector. The Noctua fan will still spin harder when the CPU is warm, but generally, even under 100% load, Noctua radiators keep CPUs so cool that the fans will never spin too hard. You can enjoy better cooling this way and avoid Dell's gremlin.