UNSOLVED

sunrisepmm

updated

23 years ago

S

sunrisepmm

10 Posts

0

7250

March 15th, 2004 05:00

TEAC DV-W58E - The Truth about 8x burning

Here are the results of my tests/experiences with the TEAC DV-W58E drive:

A) General results

The TEAC DV-58E is (!!) capable to write in 8x speed, but only with correctly certified 8x media!

But…(!!) as many other DVD or CD writers it does not constantly burn with it´s highest speed (see item D below)

B) Test Conditions

My results are only based on the VERBATIM Data Life plus 8x media with the media code (MMC-003-000); please take in mind, that even disk from the same manufacturer may have been produced in different locations around the world and even may have different media codes so make your own experiences!
I used the „DVD Identifier" from „http://DVD.Identifier.CDfreaks.com"

For example I had a 4x Verbatim with white ink-jet surface, that only burned with 2,4 x (30 Minutes) and the same brand with clear surface, that burned with 4x.
(~14 Minutes)

C) Detailled description

C1) Test with DVD Identifier downloaded from – "http://DVD.Identifier.CDfreaks.com"

With an 8x DVD R+ empty media you get two more speeds available ( 6x and 8x) than with a 4x media;

Verbatim DATA Life Plus 8 x:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Unique Disc Identifier : [DVD+R:MCC-003-000]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Disc Type : [DVD+R]

Manufacturer ID : [MCC]

Media Type ID : [003]

Product Revision : [Not Specified]

Disc Application Code : [General Purpose]

Recording Speeds : [2.4x - 4x - 8x]

Blank Disc Capacity : [Not Supported By Method 2]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

[DVD Identifier - http://DVD.Identifier.CDfreaks.com]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

** INFO : An Empty Writable Disc Is Recommended For Accurate Results

** INFO : TEAC DVD+RW DV-W58E [FW D.0C]

** INFO : [DVD+R:MCC-003-000]

** INFO : Write Speeds (Supported By This Drive On This Disc) Listed Below

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

** INFO : GET PERFORMANCE Write Speed Descriptor(s)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Descriptor #1 = 11080 KBPS (8.00x) - [CLV/Non-Pure CAV]

Descriptor #2 = 8310 KBPS (6.00x) - [CLV/Non-Pure CAV]

Descriptor #3 = 5540 KBPS (4.00x) - [CLV/Non-Pure CAV]

Descriptor #4 = 2770 KBPS (2.00x) - [CLV/Non-Pure CAV] - [Invalid Entry]

** WARNING : Drive May Have Returned Incorrect Descriptors

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

** INFO : MODE SENSE Write Speed Descriptor(s) [Legacy Command]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Descriptor #1 = 11077 KBPS (8.00x) - [CLV/Non-Pure CAV]

Descriptor #2 = 8310 KBPS (6.00x) - [CLV/Non-Pure CAV]

Descriptor #3 = 5540 KBPS (4.00x) - [CLV/Non-Pure CAV]

Descriptor #4 = 2770 KBPS (2.00x) - [CLV/Non-Pure CAV] - [Invalid Entry]

** WARNING : Drive May Have Returned Incorrect Descriptors

C2) Test with Nero 6.3.0.3 (Info tool and Burn)

With 4 x media you only get 2,4x and 4x to choose from; with an 8x empty media inserted you get additional 6x and 8x write capabilities.

C3) Conclusion

It seems that when you insert a disk, its media code is read out by the firmware, stored and this result

is returned to any programm asking the drive about it´s maximum speed.

Maybe some DVD +R disks have problems with a correct media code or the drive lacks to read them out correctly (see above the invalid entry for 2.00 x speed).

D) Speed

I burned a data disk with ~4,5 GB - it took a 9:58 Minutes, that means the drive must have an average burn-speed of around 6 x - even if the Nero Log file stated: „burn process completed successfully at 8x (11.040 KB/s)"

Very Interesting to look at the burned surface of the DVD: There were 3 different shaded rings of about the same thickness --> 3 differents speeds ?? (begin with 8x, then 6x and end with 4x at the outer ring ??) this could lead to the average of 6x….

E) Readability

No problems to read the disk either in the TEAC itself or in the DVD-ROM (LG-Type in my Dimension 8300)

F) Retrospective

The TEAC DV-W58E burns with 8x,.. but not over the complete disk (!)– if you look at some CD-RW burners with e.g. 52x, even here the average speed is mostly around 32 to 40x. Same on other DVD +RW drives – they burn with a max. average up to 7,4 (e.g. Plextor 708A, ~ 7:25 minutes). So we have to admit, that the TEAC is a 8x drive, but one of the slowest in the market.

Seems that the firmware prefers secure burning results rather than high-speed, therefore it reduces speed on the critical outer sectors of the disk.

Perhaps at the end of all days, when the sun has shrinked from a red giant to a white dwarf, DELL will provide us with an firmware upgrade…;-))

SUNRISEPMM from Germany

  • Urlik

    208 Posts

    712

    0

    Posted March 15th, 2004 13:00

    Nice review. I'll add this tidbit for those that don't know how writing to media works. Stated burning speeds on CD/DVD media writers are always the fastest possible speed.  Here's a nice faq on why speeds will vary while writing: http://www.cdrfaq.org/faq05.html#S5-22

    Message Edited by Urlik on 03-15-2004 09:39 AM

  • zzyzx6986

    73 Posts

    712

    0

    Posted March 15th, 2004 15:00

    Dear sunrisepmm,

     

    Danke for your hard work and excellent report, which illustrates the truth:  that ALL burners burn at different speeds at different parts of the discs....and that different media act differently.  Very thorough testing, I think!

    Zzyzx

  • 712

    0

    Posted March 15th, 2004 16:00

    Thanks for the great report!  I have read that the 8X speed is a maximum also and that the recording speed will vary.  I have some 8X DVD+R media coming in the mail to try out (Ritek).  I will let you know how it works out.  I also agree that a firmware update would be nice to speed up this drive.

     

    Mike

  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    712

    0

    Posted March 15th, 2004 19:00

    10 minutes for a full DVD ain't too shabby, though. I've recently ordered a Pioneer DVR-107, so I'm going to try the same thing and report back.

    By the way, I don't think the "bands" you see are different speeds. All drives start slower than the rated speed, then max out within a couple minutes, then slow at the very end, so an average burn will always be a bit slower. But 6X doesn't sound too bad at all.
  • Robert Moyer

    2 Intern

    •

    933 Posts

    712

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2004 07:00

    Recently I purchased A Plextor 708a And I was burning a 4.5 g fuji dvd+r. no where on the bulk pack did it display speed. But using them it would burn at 2.4x no selection to burn higher. It was taking 23 minutes and 34 seconds. ( I was using Nero 5.5) I went to Bestbuy and puchased a ten pack of Fuji  ,stated on the box burn speed 1X to 4x.Well I put in 4.5 g and tried to select the speed at 4x but when I hit burn it went to 8x, it had the selection of all the speeds but the plextor choose 8x and burned in 9.32 minutes. That was strange. I was under the impression that it would burn no higher than what was stated on the box. .

    Message Edited by Robert Moyer on 03-16-2004 04:58 AM

  • 712

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2004 13:00

    The Plextor 708a will burn at 8x using 4x media according to what I have read.  I am  not sure what brands of media will work.  There are several other burners that will also burn at 8x with 4x media (DVD+R).

     

    Mike

  • Robert Moyer

    2 Intern

    •

    933 Posts

    712

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2004 17:00

    The ones that I got from Bestbuy came  in a package of six(Individual boxes). The name on the box says Fujifilm DVD+R MOVIE DISCS  4.7gb down at the bottom it says up to 4x write speed. i have made two 4.5gig disc's and they came out just as clear as the ones i did @2.4x" Fantastic" I read some where that the faster you go the quality goes down , But I promise you from what I have experienced that is not so with my equipment.I am using these for Video.

                                Bob Moyer

  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    712

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2004 17:00

    Robert Moyer, which Fuji. They sell a few under the Fuji label? How does the compatibility seem? Are you using these for video DVDs?
  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    712

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2004 21:00

    Ok, thanks for the tip.

    http://www.dvdrhelp.com is a great site for checking media compatibility, and also for adding your comments regarding the media and burner you use. The front page looks a little busy but there's a wealth of great information there.

  • Popeofsteel

    14 Posts

    475

    0

    Posted March 18th, 2004 14:00

    Disc Type : DVD+R

    Manufacturer ID : RITEK

    Media Type ID : R03

    Product Revision : 002

    Disc Application Code : General Purpose

    Recording Speeds : 2.4x - 4x - 8x

    Blank Disc Capacity : Not Supported By Method 2

    Status:

    19:32:39 DVD Identifier V3.2

    19:32:39 Initializing ASPI/SPTI Drive Interface

    19:32:39 SPTI Drive Interface Successfully Initialized

    19:32:39 1 Supported Drive Found (Out Of 2 Available Drives)

    19:32:50 This Version Of 'DVD Identifier' Is Up-To-Date

    19:34:10 DVD+R/+RW Medium Detected. Starting Identification...

    19:34:10 ** Initiating ADIP Retrieval Method 1 (Original ADIP)

    19:34:10 ADIP Read M1 Failed : Illegal request - Invalid field in CDB [05/24/00]

    19:34:10 ADIP Read Method 1 Not Supported ; A Firmware Upgrade Is Recommended

    19:34:10 ** Initiating ADIP Retrieval Method 2 (Copy Of ADIP)

    19:34:10 ADIP Read Method 2 Completed Without Errors

    19:34:10 Disc Identification Completed Successfully

    Drive Capabilities:

    ** INFO : An Empty Writable Disc Is Recommended For Accurate Results

    ** INFO : TEAC DVD+RW DV-W58E FW D.0C

    ** INFO : DVD+R:RITEK-R03-002

    ** INFO : Write Speeds (Supported By This Drive On This Disc) Listed Below

    ** INFO : GET PERFORMANCE Write Speed Descriptor(s)

    Descriptor #1 = 5540 KBPS (4.00x) - CLV/Non-Pure CAV

    Descriptor #2 = 2770 KBPS (2.00x) - CLV/Non-Pure CAV -Invalid Entry

    ** WARNING : Drive May Have Returned Incorrect Descriptors

    ** INFO : MODE SENSE Write Speed Descriptor(s) Legacy Command

    Descriptor #1 = 5540 KBPS (4.00x) - CLV/Non-Pure CAV

    Descriptor #2 = 2770 KBPS (2.00x) - CLV/Non-Pure CAV - Invalid Entry

    ** WARNING : Drive May Have Returned Incorrect Descriptors

     

    ’Media Code" Block

    ** WARNING : Format 11h (Method 1) Is Recommended ADIP Retrieval Method

    ** WARNING : Format 00h (Method 2) Data May Contain Drive Modified Values

    ** INFO : Hex Dump Of 'Media Code'-Block Listed Below

    ** INFO : 4-Byte Header Preceding 'Media Code'-Block Discarded

    ** INFO : Format 00h (Method 2) - Physical Information (Copy Of ADIP)