UNSOLVED

martincr

updated

22 years ago

M

martincr

2 Posts

0

4185

March 8th, 2005 21:00

NEC ND5100A / Inspiron 9100 - drive won't play (audio) CDs and DVD+Rs

Hi,
 
Just a last resort before performing a Windows XP reinstall, I wonder if anyone has come across the above problem with the drive refusing to audio CDs - makes 3 clicks and then gives up - and DVD+R/Ws - just don't respond.
 
Any help appreciated!
 
Best,
 
Martin
  • Frazell

    307 Posts

    564

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2005 04:00

    I say look for a firmware update or warrenty replacement...

    Reinstalling windows wont be much help as it seems like a hardware problem (as you indicated hearing clicks for instance)...

  • martincr

    2 Posts

    564

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2005 09:00

    The Dell email support are very insistant that I reinstall the entire OS from scratch. This will take me hours and hours.

    How can I get around this?

    I've tried everything else possible.

  • 564

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2005 19:00

    Dell support always tell you to reinstall Windows. I can understand the logic behind this, it helps them solve configuration/drivers problems, but in your case, seems like clicking noise should be enough to call for a hardware problem.

    Simply tell them that you did reinstall Windows and that the problem remains, and that you need a new drive. They will send you a refurbished NEC 5100A drive.

    Your new drive will work fine for a couple of days, even weeks if you're lucky, and then will fail. I'm on my 3rd NEC 5100A drive and going on 4th right now. Every single one of them has failed. I've tried the 5100A on another computer and it eventually failed also, and a Sony CD-RW/DVD drive on my machine will work perfectly fine for months, so I rule-out my Inspiron 5160 as being the problem and blame the drive...

  • 564

    0

    Posted March 15th, 2005 13:00

    Sounds like not a Drive problem, but perhaps a voltage problem that's damaging your drive (could be mobo, or power regulators internal to your inspiron).  The Sony drive might have more tolerance for the high/lower voltage going to your drive, but the NEC is perhaps more sensitive.  I am surprised flag's haven't been raised at Del yet for sending out a 3rd drive, granted you do get lemon's out of the box occaisionally, but still, three validated drives going bad.    I've got the same drive in my XPS, and it's worked for exactly a year now without any problems.  I don't go overboard on making DVD's on a daily business, but I archive a lot of data on a weekly basis to DVD. 
     
    Also, there was a recent firmware update for this drive.  I applied it the other night and didn't have any problems afterwoods.
     
    Good Luck Richard.
    ~SC
  • 564

    0

    Posted March 15th, 2005 14:00

    sufferingcorpse,

    thanks for wishing me luck. I am examining the possibility of applying the firmware to my drive, do you know if it voids warranty on the drive?

     

    martincr,

    try running the Dell diagnostics, if that fails and you can give them an error code number, it will be enough to warrant a drive replacement and they won't tell you to reinstall windows...

    Regards

    Rick

  • 564

    0

    Posted March 22nd, 2005 23:00

    Richard, no applying the firmware will NOT void the warranty.  It's a special update issued from Dell, to do "on your routine update interval", meaning, whenever you want to do it.  Dell supports this device, and a way you can figure it out is because if you call Dell for support on the drive, and they see a firmware version has been released, they'll ask you to update the firmware prior to ever sending back a device for warranty. 
     
    Besides, i always recommend seeking updates from your manufacturer, if not the apply them, just to check out and see if any of the fixes (see readme involved with the appropriate update) apply to your typical user experience.  Perhaps there's something wrong and you grew acustom to it over the multi-months of operating your system. 
     
    ~SC