UNSOLVED

KathiMR

updated

22 years ago

K

KathiMR

282 Posts

0

2491

March 12th, 2005 08:00

Advice needed for external backup drive and software

After my 5160 lost its HD on Monday with loss of all data on it except the little that I had backed up, it was a wake up call that I need a better back up system.

I'm leaning toward an external HD and using software such as Ghost for back up and also for at least temporary archive of things I may not want to leave on the internal HD.

I'd like comments and suggestions for specific things I should look for, as well as any specific recommendations on brands for both hardware and software. And also any referrals to other sites that might have reliable ratings. I know Circuit City allows customers to rate and review products including HDs and I saw some mentioned there with high failure rates.

How important is speed? Size? (Internal is 60 GB) Is LaCie still a good brand? I'm thinking of firewire since this has an unused firewire port and my USB ports are all in use including those on my hub. But I saw some reports of copy problems with firewire that I didn't totally understand. Is that relevant to my type of use?

Use is mainly Office, Email, Quicken, Palm desktop, as well as proprietary business financial software which includes mutual fund data (although that I can download again) and client data. I don't do heavy graphics or anything like that.

As I understand it, some drives may have a better reliability record than others. I do recall working at a place that dealt with imported components They inspected them and the ones that passed their standards were then sold to manufacturers, and I seem to recall a comment years ago from a representative of one company that found some of their rejected chips or other components installed in someone else's equipment. So I don't know how much this still happens, but reliability is very high on my list of priorities.

Thanks for any help. I'd used search and read many posts but some were quite old and most didn't have alot of specifics.
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    403

    0

    Posted March 12th, 2005 09:00

    USB2 or firewire external drives will both work fine. I'd go with Acronis True Image rather than Ghost - it's easier to use and has a better feature set.

    LaCie doesn't make hard drives - they assemble external drives from parts made by others. Hitachi, Seagate, Western Digital and Samsung all make good hard drives; look for an externa drive made by one of these companies, or an external drive containing one of them.
  • flyprivate

    21 Posts

    403

    0

    Posted March 12th, 2005 11:00

    Message Edited by flyprivate on 03-12-2005 09:31 PM

  • KathiMR

    282 Posts

    403

    0

    Posted March 12th, 2005 21:00

    Thanks to both for the input.

    As far as speed, I notice some also come in 7200. I guess they may be more expensive. Would I need that?

    As far as size, I think I'll get bigger. Since I tend to keep computers for longer than many and I know stuff just keeps getting more complex and bigger programs, that would give more room for expansion since I notice that twice the capacity isn't any where near twice the price.

    Is there a place to check ratings on drives. Like I said, I looked on Circuit City and one of the major brand drives was reviewed as having a lot of failures, including someone who had 10 I guess in a work environment and 4-5 failed I think it was within a year. Don't want one like that.

    Now I've got another problem maybe.

    When I turned the computer on today, I'm hearing some clicking sounds that seem to be coming from the HD area. I guess I'll do a separate post about this brand new HD that I'm still getting my stuff transferred to. I seem to remember reading other posts about clicking sounds being a bad symptom.

    I guess this is just more reason to get the backup system in place quickly. I guess it would be helpful to backup what I've already installed, even though its not everything. I've already spent quite a few hours installing and many more to go and I sure don't want to repeat it any time soon.

    Thanks again.
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    403

    0

    Posted March 12th, 2005 21:00

    If you're talking about getting a 2.5" drive, 60G is as large as they come at 7200 rpm.

    If you're talking about a desktop drive, 7200s have all but replaced 5400 rpm units. By all means, get a 7200 rpm drive.

    Seagate has the best warranty on its drives - 5 years. The others are either 3 or 1 year (though WD has a 5-year on its high performance Raptor). Seagate, WD, Hitachi and Samsung all make at least reasonably reliable drives.

    You can find quite a bit of (anecdotal) evidence on drives at www.storagereview.com. The other major drive manufacturer seems to be having major issues producing reliable drives at the moment - Dell, in fact, dropped one of their models from its systems because it was so unreliable.
  • jankerson

    2843 Posts

    403

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2005 01:00

    At this time you really can't go wrong with Seagate as they seem to be the best right now.

    Your best bet is to get a desktop drive like a 100gb or more depending on how much space you need and an external USB or firewire case.

    The Laptop 2.5" drives are expensive when compared to the standard 3.5" desktop drives.