UNSOLVED

ruthdec

updated

23 years ago

R

ruthdec

3 Posts

0

22272

March 24th, 2004 14:00

Centrino Mobile vs Dell TrueMobile

I am trying to decide which wireless networking card to have in the laptop I am getting ready to purchase. I was looking online at a hotel with wireless internet access and it said it was compatible with Centrino Wireless. I would like to have 801.11g speed, but I am concerned about compatibility on a broad level. Would I be better off to stick with the Centrino Mobile card for better compatibilty as I travel?
  • mattcowger

    2582 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2004 15:00

    The PRO/Wireless card (which is the Centrino card) is no more compatible than Dell's 1300 802.11g card. Get whiever you prefer.
  • ofelas

    649 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2004 17:00

    Oh, they're making 54MBPs Intel 2100 cards available now?

    I use a TM 1400 (a/b/g) as the only Centrino cards I had an option to order were the 11MBPs...

  • jmwills

    2 Intern

    •

    11984 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2004 21:00

    There is really no such thing as a "Centrino Wirless Card"  The phrase Centrino is based around a marketing campaign that uses Centrino technology which has to do with a combination of wireless technology and battery life, which is a good thing, don't get me wrong, but Intel is making a fortune off this.

    Stick with the trusted names of Linksys, Netgear, and D-Link for your hardware choices.

  • gadgetgirl

    62 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2004 22:00

    FYI --  802.11g = 54mbps...

  • Minot

    2 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2004 12:00

    The others are absolutely correct. Centrino is a marketing solution from Intel that links their Pentium-M processor, the 855 series chipset and their own wireless network card solution. The hotel you checked out is doing some wonderful advertising for Intel.

    All you would need to access their wireless LAN is an 802.11b or 802.11g wireless card. You could also use a USB wireless adapter. It can be made by any manufacturer, not just Intel. All it needs is the 802.11b or 802.11g specification.

    If you need to add this sort of card to your Inspiron, I would check out some of the PC Card add-ins at your local Best Buy. I'm personally using a Dell Truemobile 1300 that came in my system and it's wonderful. I also have a Netgear USB MA111 wireless plug-in (looks like a pen drive) that I used with my old laptop. It works great as a $50 802.11b solution. I often travel and stay (smart) at Holiday Inn Expresses. That USB device has always given me great connectivity, not to mention I can move it from computer to computer easily.

    Good luck!

    -MINOT-
  • jdquickland

    30 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted April 30th, 2004 20:00

    I've read, not exctally sure where I think http://www.theregister.co.uk/ that Centrino actually is a slower wireless technology. Non centrino is faster. Go figure.
  • Ed C

    2 Intern

    •

    3247 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted May 1st, 2004 14:00

    Centrino is JUST A NAME it is NOT A TECHNOLOGY and has nothing to do with a technology.

    As other poster have said you can use any 802.11 B or G cards to connect to the hotel wireless signal.

    As to the Centrino being slower than G. NO NO NO Centrino is a NAME. The so called Centrino card is a 802.11b standard, 11Mbs. It is the same standard used by Dell, Linksys, NetGear, DLink, Zyxel, and all the other manufactures/sellers of wireless cards in this standard. As is the newer 802.11G standard.

  • jdquickland

    30 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted May 1st, 2004 20:00

    Centrino is more than a name. It is technology between 3 Intel products. The Pentium 4-M processor, the Intel 855 chipset and an Intel wireless card make up Centrino. It is designed to save power on your laptop. Centrino is not a wireless technology, but a laptop technology that is supposed to help with giving you more life from your batteries.
    Read more about it.

    http://www.intel.com/products/mobiletechnology/centrino/index.htm?iid=ipp_battery+centrino&

    By using Centrino enabled wireless devices you can see a performance drop because Centrino can cut down the power to your wireless card. Therefore: giving you less wireless performance.

    More information:
    http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=10833

    Read and learn before you reply.
  • Minot

    2 Posts

    843

    0

    Posted May 1st, 2004 20:00

    Well, you're both right. But I agree, the Centrino wireless technology is still 802.11b (at least the orginal specification). You will get the same performance from another 802.11b solution, no matter who the manufacturer might be. I'm not going to avoid Centrino technology, but I'm not going to seek it out either. All I want is the Pentium-M processor on a laptop these days.

    -MINOT-
  • Ed C

    2 Intern

    •

    3247 Posts

    111

    0

    Posted May 1st, 2004 21:00



    jdquickland wrote:
    Centrino is more than a name. It is technology between 3 Intel products. The Pentium 4-M processor, the Intel 855 chipset and an Intel wireless card make up Centrino.

    http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=10833

    Read and learn before you reply.


    No it isn't, the Intel 802.11b Pro2100 wireless MiniPCI card does not interface any differently  with a P "M" CPU and the chipset that goes with the P "M" CPU (855 chipset) than any other wireless MiniPCI card made by any other manufacture. It adds no feature or compatibility to a notebook the with a P "M" CPU and 855 chipset than any other wireless MiniPCI card does. It is just a name Intel allows notebook makers to use if all  the parts, CPU-chipset-wireless MiniPCI card, are made by Intel. Both the Intell card and any other wireless MiniPCI card connect to the MiniPCI slot on the motherboard.  The CPU and chipset have no more control over the Intel card than it does with any other card installed in the same slot.

    It's people like you that make a lie believable. Tell a lie, Centrino is a technology, enough times and most of the people will believe it.

    I'll read your link but I think it will point to the fact Centrino is not a technology.