UNSOLVED

coryjs

updated

1 year ago

C

coryjs

1 Rookie

•

3 Posts

0

8161

April 17th, 2020 16:00

U3219Q, Surface Pro 7, WD19 / WD19TB 4k at 60hz issue

Hello!

I have an interesting problem. My job sent me a WD19TB dock and a Precision 5540 to use at home a while back. Using those two together is great. I can achieve 4k 60hz no problem. However, personally, I have a Surface Pro 7 that I would also like to use with the dock. It mostly works. The only issue is that, whether the dock is connected to the monitor with DisplayPort or DisplayPort over USB-C, I can only squeeze out 4k at 30hz. If I connect my SP7 to the monitor directly over USB-C, I can get 4k at 60hz.

So I thought, "Okay, this dock is really meant for interfacing with laptops through Thunderbolt, which the SP7 doesn't support, so that may be the reason." The other day I found a good deal on a WD19 dock, which does do its interfacing through USB-C. I decided to try it. The same issue happened, I can only get 4k at 30hz.

But, while messing with the dock, I stumbled onto something really interesting. If I do the following, I can get 4k at 60hz on the WD19:


1. Unplug the USB-C and DisplayPort cords from the dock.
2. Start the SP7 without it being plugged into the dock.
3. Plug the SP7 into the dock. (Whenever I try to start the SP7 while being plugged into the dock, I can't get any video output, I always have to unplug/replug).
4. Connect the USB-C and DisplayPort cables into the monitor, but not the dock.
5. Connect the DisplayPort cable into the dock.
6. Let the monitor detect and use the DisplayPort input. This gives 4k at 30hz.
7. Connect the USB-C cable into the dock.
8. Let the monitor detect and use the USB-C input. This gives 4k at 60hz.

I can then unplug the DisplayPort input and still have 4k at 60hz. I tried the same steps on the WD19TB, and sure enough, I could get 4k at 60hz.

Anyone have any ideas on why any of this is happening? It's going to be a bit of a hassle to do this every time. If there's a way to not do these steps and still get 4k at 60hz, that'd be awesome.

  • coryjs

    1 Rookie

    •

    3 Posts

    6699

    0

    Posted April 17th, 2020 16:00

    My bad, I meant WD19TB. I updated the post to reflect that.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    6705

    0

    Posted April 17th, 2020 16:00

    @coryjs  there's no such thing as a WD19TC.  There's a WD19TB and a WD19DC.  Which are you using?  The difference matters because the TB is capable of Thunderbolt 3 but will operate as a regular USB-C dock with non-Thunderbolt systems (at functionality equivalent to the regular WD19), whereas the WD19DC is actually a "dual channel USB-C" dock.  It doesn't use Thunderbolt at all, but instead uses two USB-C connectors to transmit video when paired with Dell systems that have two USB-C/TB3 ports and support this -- but if you only connect one, then once again it operates like a regular WD19.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    6691

    0

    Posted April 17th, 2020 17:00

    @coryjs  ok, in that case I'm not sure why you have to jump through the hoops that you do in order to get 4K 60 Hz out of your Surface, but I can explain what's going on in terms of dock capabilities, since there's a key difference between the two systems you're using beyond Thunderbolt.

    First of all, if you already have a WD19TB, there's no real point in having a WD19, because the WD19TB operates exactly like a regular WD19 when used with a non-Thunderbolt system.  Or at least it's supposed to.  I suppose weird interoperability issues can arise in certain system pairings.

    Anyhow, there are actually TWO relevant factors here in determining what display setups a given system can run through either of these docks.  The first that applies only using the WD19TB is Thunderbolt vs. non-Thunderbolt.  The second factor that applies with both the WD19TB and the regular WD19 is whether your system supports DisplayPort 1.2 (HBR2) or DisplayPort 1.3/1.4 (HBR3) over USB-C/TB3.  Your Precision 5540 supports Thunderbolt and DisplayPort 1.2.  Your Surface Pro 7 supports regular USB-C with DisplayPort 1.4 (HBR3).  DisplayPort HBR3 can push more bandwidth than DisplayPort HBR2 on a per lane basis.  A simple USB-C to DP cable (no dock) can use four DisplayPort lanes.  A regular USB-C dock like the WD19 can use two DisplayPort lanes, since the other two USB-C lanes are allocated to carrying USB 3.x data.  A Thunderbolt connection can carry either 8 lanes of HBR2 or 5 lanes of HBR3.  The latter is actually slightly more total bandwidth, and the reason you're limited to 5 on HBR3 is because 6 lanes of DisplayPort HBR3 would exceed the 40 Gbps max of Thunderbolt 3 itself.

    So if you're trying to run a single 4K 60 Hz display, there are a few different ways to achieve it:

    • Regular USB-C system that supports HBR3, paired with either the WD19 or WD19TB
    • Thunderbolt system that supports HBR2, paired with the WD19TB.  A TB3+HBR3 system would also work but isn't necessary, since even TB3+HBR2 is actually enough bandwidth for dual 4K 60 Hz displays.

    So for example your Precision 5540 can run 4K 60 Hz through a WD19TB since it can use Thunderbolt in that setup, but it would NOT be able to do that with a regular WD19 because it's an HBR2 system, even though the Surface Pro 7 would (or should) be able to do that through the WD19 since it supports HBR3, even though it does NOT support Thunderbolt.

    Possible display setups are spelled out in a lot more detail in the manuals for these docks, which are available on support.dell.com.  Look in the "Display Resolution Table" section.

    All that said, I can't account for why you have to jump through those hoops to get Surface Pro 7 to run 4K 60 Hz from a WD19 or why it doesn't work with the WD19TB at all, because it should be able to run a single 4K 60 Hz display through each of those docks without any fuss.  Again, there's absolutely no reason you should need a regular WD19 if you already had a WD19TB, unless of course you wanted two docking stations.

    Are you current on all of your driver and firmware on the Surface Pro 7?  I would normally also suggest updating the firmware for the dock, but as of this writing there aren't any firmware updates for the WD19 family of docks yet.

  • coryjs

    1 Rookie

    •

    3 Posts

    6671

    0

    Posted April 17th, 2020 18:00

    Thanks for getting back to me @jphughan ! I really appreciate it. It's nice to have confirmation that this should work. I'm hoping at some point another SP7 owner can chime in and confirm whether or not they experience this issue.

    And if it wasn't clear, I can get 4k at 60hz on the WD19TB if I follow the same steps as the WD19. I'm probably going to return the WD19 since, like you said, it's unnecessary.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    6668

    0

    Posted April 17th, 2020 18:00

    @coryjs  happy to help!  And good clarification that the same steps work on the WD19TB.  I'm going to guess this is a firmware issue, although I'm not sure which side of this equation will require the update.  Microsoft only just started offering USB-C ports on its Surface systems, so that could be part of it, but DisplayPort HBR3 over USB-C overall is still relatively new because it only very recently became supported by Intel GPUs, and even then only on the "Ice Lake" variants of their Core 10th Gen CPUs, which isn't even ALL Core 10th Gen CPUs.  The only other way to get DisplayPort HBR3 over USB-C has been to have a laptop with a discrete GPU that supported that capability and had direct control of the USB-C display output -- but that second condition is relatively rare even among laptops that have discrete GPUs.  The more common design is for the Intel CPU to have control of all display outputs and for the discrete GPU to be a "render-only" device.

    So at the moment, if you're already current drivers and firmware on the Surface side, I don't have any other suggestions beyond keeping an eye out for future firmware updates.  Here is a direct link to the Drivers & Downloads section of the WD19TB support page, where any firmware updates that get released will appear.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    6409

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2020 11:00

    Hey@uberJ ,

    Two DisplayPort lanes is enough to run a single 4K 60 Hz display when the devices on each end of the link support DispayPort 1.4/HBR3 over USB-C.  The WD19 does, which is why Page 17 of its manual here indicates that with an HBR3 system, a single 4K 60 Hz display is possible from the indicated outputs (which is all of them).  The WD19 still runs USB 3.x in this scenario, so it would be running 4K 60 Hz from two lanes of DisplayPort.

    As for the Surface Pro 7, that supports DisplayPort HBR3 as well because it uses Intel's "Ice lake" CPUs that incorporate their new Gen 11 GPU, which adds support for that.  This is true even for the i5-1005G1 CPU, which is the lowest-end offering available on the SP7.  With that system, two lanes is enough for single 4K 60 Hz because four lanes is enough for dual 4K 60 Hz displays, which the SP7 is also confirmed to support from its USB-C port when using a hardware setup results in all four USB-C lanes being allocated to DisplayPort -- as described here.

    So in terms of your issue, what display are you using, and how are you connecting that display to your WD19?  If you're connecting that display to the dock using DisplayPort and your display has DisplayPort MST capability, make sure MST is disabled.  The reason is that on some displays, enabling MST even without actually using it will cause the display to limit itself to 4K 30 Hz on its DisplayPort input, in order to keep enough bandwidth available to pass over MST to another display.  This behavior is the result of bandwidth limitations on DisplayPort HBR2, where running a 4K 60 Hz display wouldn't leave enough bandwidth left to create a daisy chain.  But since HDMI can't be used for a daisy chain, I'm wondering if your display might be fine accepting 4K 60 Hz over HDMI using your USB-C to HDMI 2.0 cable, while not accepting it on DisplayPort, assuming again that you're using DisplayPort to connect to the dock.

    If that's not it, have you tried other cables and display outputs between the dock and display just in case there might be some strange behavior with the specific combination of the WD19 and your display?  Obviously those problems shouldn't exist, but the tech world is full of problems that shouldn't exist but do nonetheless.

    Good luck, and please report back!

  • uberJ

    3 Posts

    6412

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2020 11:00

    Thanks for starting the discussion on this issue.

    @coryjs  Im also unable to get 4k60hz from my SP7 using the WD19.  Only 4k30hz.  Unfortunately, the trick you found didnt work for me.

    I am able to get 4k60hz though if I connect directly through the SP7 using usb-c to HDMI2.0 adapters.

     

    @jphughan You mentioned "A simple USB-C to DP cable (no dock) can use four DisplayPort lanes.  A regular USB-C dock like the WD19 can use two DisplayPort lanes, since the other two USB-C lanes are allocated to carrying USB 3.x data."  

    Could the issue be that two DP lanes, which the WD19 uses, are not enough to carry 4k60hz?  Perhaps coryjs's method is able to get the WD19 to use all 4 lanes instead if only 2? 

  • uberJ

    3 Posts

    6402

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2020 12:00

    Hi @jphughan , thanks for the detailed explanation.

     

    I am using a Roku TV (2019) as my monitor, and I have been able to get 4k 60hz HDR when it is connected directly with the SP7.  It has only HDMI2.0 ports, so I dont think it has DP MSP. 

    I have tried all the ports on the WD19: HDMI, USB-C, and DP (using a DP1.4-HDMI2.0 adapter), as well as a different HDMI2.0 cable.  I have also checked the display drivers to make sure they are up to date.  

    Looking at pg 17 of the manual, could a plausible explanation be that the SP7's USB-C port is reverting back to HBR2 when connected to the WD19?

  • uberJ

    3 Posts

    1021

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2020 13:00

    Unfortunately, even when I turn off HDR, the max refresh rate is still 30hz at 4k.  Looking at the advanced display settings in Windows, it says 8 bit dithering.  So that means the TV isnt capable of true 10-bit HDR color, as I understand it, but rather it is simulating 10-bit HDR, which would mean that it is not using 10-bit bandwidth, right?

    Yes, the same HDMI input was used in my tests, and it was indeed set to enhanced mode.

    In Intel Iris Graphics Control Panel, if I select 1080P, I can indeed get 60hz HDR.  I dont see options for playing around with chroma, though.

    I will keep an eye out on firmware updates and further discussions on this issue.  Thanks for your suggestions! 

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    6400

    0

    Posted May 19th, 2020 13:00

    @uberJ  Ok, the fact that you're connecting to an HDR-capable TV might be the key here.  There are 4 "elements" of a display signal that are relevant here, all of which affect the amount of bandwidth required to send the signal:

    • Resolution
    • Refresh rate
    • Color depth (SDR is 8-bit, HDR is 10-bit)
    • Chroma Subsampling (4:4:4 is best; other options include 4:2:2 and 4:2:0)

    When using HDMI 2.0, if you want 4K resolution, there's only enough bandwidth to carry TWO of the remaining 3 bullet points from the list above in their best form.  So for example you can have 4K 60 Hz HDR, but only with reduced chroma -- or 4K 60 Hz with full chroma, but only SDR.  If you're trying to run 4K 60 Hz HDR, then it's possible that the problem is trying to run reduced chroma through the docking station, even though it seems to work through the USB-C to HDMI 2.0 cable.  You might be able to create a custom resolution setup to force that, but I'm not sure.  Out of curiosity, have you tried to get just 4K 60 Hz SDR through the dock?  And are you using the same HDMI input on the TV for all tests?  The reason I ask is that some TVs need to have their HDMI ports put into "Enhanced Mode" or similar in order to enable HDMI 2.0 operation and therefore 4K 60 Hz, apparently because running those inputs that way all the time would break compatibility with some older HDMI sources.

    If even that doesn't work, then a reversion to HBR2 is certainly possible, although unfortunately I'm not aware of any utilities that would even be able to confirm that that's the case, though I've had other cases where I wished I had that sort of tool that would provide technical info about the display link such as this.  If creating and forcing a custom resolution in Intel HD Graphics Control Panel (or Command Center, depending on your driver version) doesn't get this working properly and your Intel GPU drivers are all current, at this point the only suggestion that comes to mind would be to keep an eye out for firmware updates to the SP7 and the dock, although I realize that doesn't help you today.