UNSOLVED

webdtc

updated

18 years ago

Closed

W

webdtc

8 Posts

0

34206

January 30th, 2008 17:00

XPS M1530 WSXGA+ (1680x1050) screen

Has Dell made any type of statement regarding the quality of screens they are placing in the XPS line? By many accounts there are 3 types of screens being used and the Samsung apparently is very low quality (grainy, dim, bad viewing angles) to the point of being defective. LG has had very little complaints and another screen which is sometimes used is not good or bad either way. I received an xps 1530 and the screen was unacceptable. Next to other screens of the same resolution and size it looked a few levels less bright, was darker on the edges and was significantly more grainy. The colors were actually nice aside from being grey-tinted. Based on other's experience and my own experience it sounds like Dell support is becoming more aware of the issue. Recently I have heard that the Samsung has been discontinued in favor of the LG. Is this true? The 1530 is a great machine but Dell is ruining it by using sub standard screens.
  • 1170

    0

    Posted January 30th, 2008 23:00

    How do you know the brand of the screen? I have just received my XPS M1530 with the WSXGA 1680x1050 upgraded screen. Any help would be appreciated as I would like to know if I received the lower quality Samsung screen. Thank you.
  • 1170

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 01:00

    I called Dell today after reading about the screen issues.  They told me that the screen is now a Dell manufactored version.  I hope it is a good quality.  I am excited about getting my new computer and if its garbage, my idea of a Dell being a good company will be severly diminished.
     
    Let me know what you find out when you get your machines.
  • dieu

    53 Posts

    1170

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 13:00

    I am not sure about that statement. Dell does not manufacture their own LCD displays. Perhaps the salesperson meant to state that Dell has a new vendor for their 15.4" LCD displays...
     
    I did a bit of research (Google) and the majority concur that the M1530 1680x1050 screen is pretty poor. As I purchased the (top-of-the-line) M1530 (second one), I will not hesitate to send this back. 
     
    I know that Dell haS the 15.4" Backlit LCD display and should be released within the next two weeks. However, I would like "Dell-Jimmy P" to make himself useful and respond to this controversial issue.


    Message Edited by dieu on 01-31-2008 10:32 AM
  • webdtc

    8 Posts

    1170

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 15:00

    Some sort of statement from Dell about this would help a lot of people decide whether or not they want to purchase this machine.  As it is now I know a lot of people who are not even considering Dell because of the issue.
  • RPomygal

    15 Posts

    1170

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 17:00

    Unfortunately, it will never happen. Dell has had screen issues, more so on their hi-res LCD's for years. These same discussions having been going around and around with many models... 9200, 9300, The D820, M1710, even the new M1730 as well as many others. Nothing will ever be done about it on a large scale. Having been in Corporate IT for over 16 years, I've seen notebook computers come in by the hundreds... it's amazing the variation of screen quality in many of these machines...even with all being the same model, same specs. The bottom line is simple... the mass majority of users will never notice or even care. I can give out 1000 notebooks and perhaps 3 or 4 employees would come back to me or my staff and actually complain about the "screen". Same thing here. Dell, like any big corporate entity will never admit to anything unless it effects a huge number of people, or causes harm... for example the problem with the lithium batteries. In that case, the company responsible had no choice but to bite the bullet.. it cost them and others a fortune! For these screen problems it's better for them just to deal with the few... even though it may appear by all these posts that there are many, we're the very infinite minority. Dell will just fix them, replace them, or refund them... and it goes away. If they came out and said a particular screen is defective it would open a can of worms where huge numbers of people would want replacements even if, in their own minds, they don't see anything wrong... they would want it replaced because the company said it was defective. It would cost Dell a small fortune, bad publicity, and hurt their bottom line. 
     
    Trust me, they know about it...they may play dumb and say nothing is wrong, but the bottom line is... they will never publicly admit that they have a problem. This will continue to be going on with the M1550, M1570, or whatever future models, because millions will be sold and thousands will be returned, and those thousands will just be resold on the Outlet, etc. etc. In the end a few picky folks like us will be upset, but  Dell and the shareholders will be happy.
     
    On a positive note, overall, I've been very pleased with Dell. When combined with company orders, I've bought over 50 workstations and notebooks from Dell. Only a D820 had a lousy screen (also WSXGA+), but not bad enough to warrant a replacement. I've been lucky and never had to return a single computer. On the corporate level, for notebooks, I deal mostly with HP and Lenovo. Those  companies have their issues too. So, to be fair, Dell has been quite good for me so far. I have a new M1530 with the WSXGA+ on order and coming soon. If it comes with a sub-par Samsung screen I will do whatever I need to do to have it resolved. For now however, I'll keep my fingers crossed that they send me one with an LG or similar! Anyway, I hope this helps some of you.
  • RPomygal

    15 Posts

    1170

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 18:00

    Go to Device Manager, Generic Pnp Montior, Details,
    on the details screen click the property tab and select hardware ids
    An example of what you may see if you have the SAMSUNG:
     
    DISPLAY\ SEC3350\5&207E0375&0&UID280
     
    The two most used WSXGA+ LCD panels in the M1530 are:
     
    LG Philips LPLF300 - Dell P/N: XK309 - Size: 15.4" - Experience: Not Grainy
    Samsung SEC3350 - Dell P/N: RW985 - Size: 15.4" - Experience: Grainy
     
    You can make all the adjustments you want but it won't help. The LCD is just plain poor.
  • 1170

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 18:00

    I called Dell today and they could not tell me if my computer with the 1680X1050 WSXGA+ Screen came with an LG or Samsung manufactured screen. Does anybody know how to figure out the manufacturer? My screen is really dull and dark, lacks brightness. I have played with the color settings and this did not solve the problem either. Thanks.
  • 1170

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 19:00

    Okay, I just confirmed that I have the Samsung LCD 1680 grainy screen. What you recommend doing?
  • RPomygal

    15 Posts

    1170

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 20:00

    Well, I guess that depends. I would suggest you read this thread...
     
     
    It's about 35 pages and has many examples of M1530 owners that have been fighting with the poor screens and what they've done to resolve the issues.. some successfully, some not.
     
    You really have three options:
     
    1. Make the best of it. (I saw one person that was offered $200 just to keep what they have vs. a refund)
     
    2. Ask them to replace the screen (Odds are pretty high you'll just get another Samsung...and some of the idiots they use for repair guys have been destroying the laptops when they do the replacement - beware!)
     
    3. Ask for a refund and wait for the LED screens which are rumoured to be coming out soon for the M1530.
  • 373

    0

    Posted February 1st, 2008 22:00

    So after reading a few other posts, is it correct that Dell will be discontinuing use of the Samsung manufactured LCD screen and only using the LG Phillips?