
UNSOLVED
Closed
JC
Jim Coates
6 Operator
•
13582 Posts
0
22709
January 23rd, 2008 12:00
reply to "Stereo Mix and Vista Update"
Chris B wrote
"Dell is currently working with the vendor to investigate providing Stereo Mix support for Vista. There are, however, some significant challenges (e.g. DRM security restrictions) resulting from the design of Vista that need to be addressed, so this will not be a quick or easy task, and frankly may not be possible."
Chris, thank you for providing the update; it is much appreciated.
What is mystifying is how this might not be possible when there are already 3 workaround solutions that are known on this board. If the general public can figure this out then it seems like the wizards who write the drivers should be able to also. The 3 workaround solutions are as follows:
1. Some models can load and use the Vista Sigmatel driver from the LG company. That driver supports stereo mix.
2. Some people are using the new Sigmatel XP driver that supports stereo mix, but loading it into Vista by using the XP compatibility mode, as explained here:
How to install Sigmatel R171789 XP driver in Vista
So far this is reported to work on
Inspiron E1505/6400 and 1720
Latitude D620
Vostro 1400 and 1500
XPS M1530 and M2010
3. Finally, there is the notebookforums hack that has been discussed many times on this board. The hack alters the inf files of the Sigmatel R122161 XP driver. The alteration unlocks stereo mix, equalization, and other features, and it works on Vista on these models
E1705/9400
E1505/6400
E1405/640m
Inspiron 1501
Latitude D520, D620, D820, D830
Precision M90
Here is a thread with the instructions for the stereo mix solutions:
A thread with all of the stereo mix solutions
Because there are many, many folks who are using the above workarounds to enable stereo mix in Vista, if the final verdict from the Sigmatel vendor (the last time I checked it was the IDT company) is that it is not possible for them to unlock stereo mix, that would be very difficult to believe.
Jim
"Dell is currently working with the vendor to investigate providing Stereo Mix support for Vista. There are, however, some significant challenges (e.g. DRM security restrictions) resulting from the design of Vista that need to be addressed, so this will not be a quick or easy task, and frankly may not be possible."
Chris, thank you for providing the update; it is much appreciated.
What is mystifying is how this might not be possible when there are already 3 workaround solutions that are known on this board. If the general public can figure this out then it seems like the wizards who write the drivers should be able to also. The 3 workaround solutions are as follows:
1. Some models can load and use the Vista Sigmatel driver from the LG company. That driver supports stereo mix.
2. Some people are using the new Sigmatel XP driver that supports stereo mix, but loading it into Vista by using the XP compatibility mode, as explained here:
How to install Sigmatel R171789 XP driver in Vista
So far this is reported to work on
Inspiron E1505/6400 and 1720
Latitude D620
Vostro 1400 and 1500
XPS M1530 and M2010
3. Finally, there is the notebookforums hack that has been discussed many times on this board. The hack alters the inf files of the Sigmatel R122161 XP driver. The alteration unlocks stereo mix, equalization, and other features, and it works on Vista on these models
E1705/9400
E1505/6400
E1405/640m
Inspiron 1501
Latitude D520, D620, D820, D830
Precision M90
Here is a thread with the instructions for the stereo mix solutions:
A thread with all of the stereo mix solutions
Because there are many, many folks who are using the above workarounds to enable stereo mix in Vista, if the final verdict from the Sigmatel vendor (the last time I checked it was the IDT company) is that it is not possible for them to unlock stereo mix, that would be very difficult to believe.
Jim
Responses (10)
Solutions (0)
- Dell's major competitor brand supports Stereo Mix on their laptop computers; it's no problem at all on the desktop computers...all running Vista, so I'm a little puzzled about the DRM comment under Vista.
I do know that the RealTek onboard card (on several brands of laptops) supports Stereo Mix (it's off by default, but takes about 2 seconds to turn it on). Also, add-in sound cards on desktops support it just fine.
So I'm glad that Dell is working on it (very good news indeed), but mystified about the reason why it may not work.
Now, stereo input monitoring (which is also not currently supported), is another thing that should be addressed as well. If Dell supported both those things (because I am a musician, composer, and arranger), I would buy a Dell laptop as a desktop replacement in a heartbeat. Otherwise, those two items are showstoppers. Jim Coates
6 Operator
•
13582 Posts
895
0
Posted January 23rd, 2008 18:00
"it's no problem at all on the desktop computers..."
Not sure if you mean the "major competitor"'s desktops or Dell's, because over on the Desktop Audio board there are plenty of posts about this same problem. The solution I most often see there is to get an inexpensive pci Soundblaster card, but that solution doesn't apply to the notebook computers.
Actually the notebook computers had stereo mix as long as the Sigmatel STAC '97 chip was being used. That was through the Inspiron 9300 model. Starting with the 9400 model Dell implemented the Intel HD audio codec (Sigmatel 92xxHD) and at that time started locking out stereo mix.
Jimjehooverjr
25 Posts
895
0
Posted January 23rd, 2008 22:00
Cheers go out to Chris-B for pushing the issue and getting it noticed by Dell,Not so much thanks to Dell who seem to be inventing issues to delay, as a programmer I can quite safely say that while there has been DRM changes in Vista, it is not too hard to implement a stereomix, only real problem is all other recording end points have to be disabled to enable it.Futhermore to back up my statement, you only have to look to the fact other vendors using the same chip do have a vista stereomix,Ahh well progress of any kind is good progess I guess.JH
@jimco wrote:
"it's no problem at all on the desktop computers..."
Not sure if you mean the "major competitor's desktops or Dell's,
Jim
Well, I do know when I went to several stores and checked out the sound configuration on several High Performance notebook systems, if you get my meaning, they all had stereo mix. Likewise on their desktops (which I ultimately bought). Of course, they are using the RealTek HD soundcard, whereas Dell is using the SigmaTel. But if the High Performance systems can do it in Vista, then you would think that Dell can do it also.
I don't think their laptops supported input monitoring, though; however, the desktops do. I can't speak for the Dell desktops, because I haven't had a chance to look at them closely, so your comment over on the desktop forum is probably right on target.- ...and I would like to add I did the same thing and found the other also did not have the crackling and popping audio problems like we have on the Dell systems. I had also commented on another thread that if Dell had stuck with the Realtek flavor (which I think is also sigmatel) the problems would not be here.
- How can you say "this might not be possible"?What rot!
I have a desktop PC (NOT Dell) with a Creative Labs Audigy 2 soundcard in it.OK, so Creative have not been the best at providing Vista driver support, and this is the only driver so far released (Mar-2007, v2.12) BUT IT HAS A STEREO MIX FUNCTION in the basic driver and it works very well.So clearly the "technical" problems are not that difficult, and there are obvious no DRM issues involved.Let me just warn Dell that my next PC / Laptop will not be a Dell brand unless this fiasco is fixed.....NigelS Amberlodge1
14 Posts
895
0
Posted April 6th, 2008 00:00
I tried the R17189 driver update that is reported as the wrong audio driver in Vista but you can load it in XP compatability mode.
The trouble for me is that the original statement is correct. Just because I can load it and select Stereo Mix does not mean it will actually work.
I have tried Vista Sound Recorder and it does not register the source. I also tried other Audio programs that do not list the source options such as Line In or Stereo Mix.
What a shambles for a brand new system only a few days old. Should I return it for refund or does anyone have any further suggestions please.
Can the sound coard be updated or is it part of the motherboard.
I am so disappointed
Paul.
Jim Coates
6 Operator
•
13582 Posts
158
0
Posted April 6th, 2008 01:00
Paul,
if you are unhappy with it then yes you should return it. That is the purpose of the return policy.
The Sigmatel chip is on the motherboard. Even if it could be upgraded there is no other Dell driver that will supply stereo mix. If you keeps the computer the solution would be to go to XP. If you exchange it for another Dell model it should be one with XP preinstalled.
I cannot recommend another brand with Vista because I just don't know how they function re wave out. Any brand with XP should work. Apple should work too because it doesn't have Vista.
Jim

Jim Coates
6 Operator
•
13582 Posts
895
0
Posted January 23rd, 2008 12:00
I doubt that that this is something that just spontaneously happened. I think we all owe Chris B thanks for pushing this and for being an advocate for this board at Dell.
Jim