
UNSOLVED
Closed
K
klick_on_me
70 Posts
0
42762
December 27th, 2003 22:00
Is the 9600Pro available from spare parts yet?
And if it is, has anyone ordered it for their i8500? What is the expected arrival date? Thanks for any input... I am deperately awaiting it for my own i8500.
Responses (29)
Solutions (0)
caboosemoose
240 Posts
543
0
Posted December 28th, 2003 02:00
I don't know why, it won't be much faster, if any at all faster than your 4200go - if it works, that is.Although in some things the 9600Pro is no quicker than the 4200go.... the people whom are hanging out fo it (myself included) are likely more interested in its better handling of AA & AF, and its DX9 features... particularly as some DX9 games are starting to emerge now.... its nice to have the better features on offer for these games if we can.
stu
caboosemoose
240 Posts
543
0
Posted December 28th, 2003 11:00
AA and aniso performance isn't really relavant - the 9600 isnt fast enough to have frame rates to spare to hand over for running those features - you're going to need every bit of power available to get playable frame rates without those featrues turned on. Plus, you'll probabaly be playing most of these new DX9 games at interpolated resolutions.
There's also no proof that the 9600 will be faster for dx9 games. It's no faster on current DX9 games like Halo. Maybe it will be faster for some and it will obviously run more effects, but we simply don't know yet. My guess is that it will only be faster for a smallish minority - especially at the relatively low core clock of Dell's 9600. It's also very possible that the 4200go will be faster for Doom3 engined games.
caboosemoose,
I don't understand where you want to go, seriously. What's the point on defending the GF4 4200 with nails and teeth now that it is impossible to setup a system with that GPU? What alternative GPU do you propose? I don't think the M10 is that bad. I was impressed with the M9 when it came out, it put new standards in mobile graphics performance (as the Geforce2 GO did before). I'm totally convinced that in 128Mb video cards for I8600, the M10 is the one that less heat produces, and that is my main concern when choosing one... So the only point you would be making people avoid M10 is that is more expensive that GF FX series, but it is only a bit more.
Sorry for my english ;)
Message Edited by syrou on 12-28-2003 07:16 PM
Andrew WOT
194 Posts
543
0
Posted December 28th, 2003 17:00
@caboosemoose wrote:
I don't know why, it won't be much faster, if any at all faster than your 4200go - if it works, that is.
At least in UT2003 it is slower by a big margin. Proven. IMHO GeForce 4200 Go is the best mobile GPU available today, it was badmouthed being desktop architecture and runing too hot. Yeah, right, tests showed that it is the coolest card available from Dell even when overclocked.And for DX9 wanna be, check that my post. Very educative reading.
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_video&message.id=101353
Message Edited by Andrew WOT on 12-28-2003 01:13 PM
Why does Dell charge so much for the M10? If you configure an I8600, Dell wants $199 just to upgrade up to the M10. DSP charges $145 for the M10 aftermarket. You would be better off configuring the I8600 with the basic Go5200 NoGo then ordering the M10 from DSP. You would then have two GPU's for less than the price of cofiguring the I8600 w/M10.
caboosemoose
240 Posts
501
0
Posted December 28th, 2003 19:00
@syrou wrote:
caboosemoose,
I don't understand where you want to go, seriously. What's the point on defending the GF4 4200 with nails and teeth now that it is impossible to setup a system with that GPU? What alternative GPU do you propose? I don't think the M10 is that bad. I was impressed with the M9 when it came out, it put new standards in mobile graphics performance (as the Geforce2 GO did before). I'm totally convinced that in 128Mb video cards for I8600, the M10 is the one that less heat produces, and that is my main concern when choosing one... So the only point you would be making people avoid M10 is that is more expensive that GF FX series, but it is only a bit more.
Sorry for my english ;)
Message Edited by syrou on 12-28-2003 07:16 PM
The point I'm trying to make and that you are missing is that the M10 is not much of an upgrade for people who already have the 4200go. If you are buying an 8600 then the M10 is the obvious choice, but if you already have the 4200go there's very little, if any, point in going to the trouble and expense of replacing it with the M10.Actually, the M9 was not very impressive when it came out - it was hardly any faster than the 4go 440. The only mobile video cards that have really moved the game forward at the time when they were launched as as follows:
M3/4 - often overlooked and a very good performer in it's day - closer to the top desktop cards in its day than current mobile cards.
Geforce2go - first T&L mobile card. that said, it was very unstable and over underdeveloped, but still was a catalyst for cards that followed.
Radeon 7500 / M7 - twice as fast as the 2go and a really remarkable performer, the closest a mobile card has come to the desktop cards of the day - it really wasn't that much slower for many games than the top of the line desktop 8500 and performed more or less identiacally to a desktop 7500.
4go 4200 - I expected it to blow, but it was a big surprise. Generally underated (especially as a mobile part, in which capacity is actualy very very good) and still as good as the best on offer now.
I think both the fx5600/5650 and the 9600 mobile cards are pretty disappointing.

somms
623 Posts
543
0
Posted December 28th, 2003 02:00
http://delltalk.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_video&message.id=99132
Dell Order Information
----------------------
Order Number:
Customer Number:
Sales Point of Contact: John A.
Email Address: US_DHS_SPARE_PARTS_SALES@DELL.COM
Phone: 1800-274-0696 ext: 43725
Order was placed on: 12/22/2003
Estimated Shipping Date: 12/31/2003
Shipped To:
*Sales Tax: $0.00
Shipping and/or Handling: $8.00
Total Order Amount: $153.10