UNSOLVED

penny1015

updated

22 years ago

Closed

P

penny1015

5 Posts

0

5164

July 14th, 2004 01:00

Help! I purchased a 5150 yesterday before reading this forum about the overheating problenm! Should I cancel?

Hi,
I just discovered this forum today and was surprised to hear all the problems associated with the 5150. I thought I did all my homework- PC magazine, Znet, Consumer Reports and other reviews rated this laptop as high.I almost ordered an e-machine 6805 until I discovered their broken hinges problem.
It seems as soon as I make up my mind on a computer, I hear something distressing about it. I feel that if I choose another computer, I will go on another forum, and hear something wrong about that computer also. I have to stop researching sometime.
Now I do not know what to do. I am buying this computer for my daughter in college, and, after all my research, it is definitely the right price for us- the major issue- along with the great 4 year complete care package. It sounded perfect.If my d is aware of the overheating issue, and sprays it every week, would I be a fool to keep the order? It would certainly be the easier thing to do. They can replace the fan if it gets to be a real problem, right?
The 8600 and the 600m is a little too much money for us - we were stretching it with the 5150, but the 20% coupon brought it down to the right price.
What do you think we should do- stop here and take our chances on what appears to be a perfect computer barring the overheating problem? Would you buy a 5150 again, knowing what you know now?
Is anyone happy with it? Anyone not have this problem? It is hard to tell how many people have this problem, and how widespread the problem is. It has been out for around 2 years, and it seems that it has only recently been discovered, but I did not read every past post.Opinions please while there is still time to cancel.
Thanks,
Penny
  • cobra_2004

    2 Intern

    •

    217 Posts

    579

    0

    Posted July 14th, 2004 02:00

    I bought my 5150 about 4 months ago. Yes, I love it. Have no problems with it, as long as you spray it every couple of weeks right from the day you get it, then you should be fine. Remember, every piece of manchinary is going to have its flaws. In any event, I am very pleased with my machine.
  • TDunn

    379 Posts

    579

    0

    Posted July 14th, 2004 04:00

    The idea being.......you need to keep the main fan clean.  It gets clogged easily and causes the lack of air flow that leads to the higher temps.

    ................TD

  • NemesisDB

    2 Intern

    •

    7944 Posts

    579

    0

    Posted July 14th, 2004 05:00

    I have the 5100 which has tons more heat issues than the 5150 and it's never been that big of a deal for me.  I notice the problem most during heavy gaming and the like -- if you don't do stuff like that it may never be a concern.

    Also, if you're getting the accidents (complete care) warranty, which you definitely should for college (it's saved me twice now), it's fairly easy to get the heatsink replaced if you're having problems.  They put in a new one for me the last time I sent it in after a spill.  I've been cleaning out the vents since and it's worked fine.  Bear in mind this is a 5100 with a real desktop p4 in it which should have tons more problems than what you're looking at.

    Just my 2cents, if the price is right, go for it ... the warranty will take care of the rest, esp if heat/dust is your concern

  • Kenneth_HG

    209 Posts

    579

    0

    Posted July 14th, 2004 14:00

    well, i think there's no problem if you don't run 3d games with your notebook. since my 8600 also gets hot when i'm playing 3d games.. remember to spray your fan also.. my friend had a Hyundai m-life(cheap price in malaysia) ^_^ running on p4 2.0GHz, it's cool enough when used for normal documents and some software developing..

  • PINE

    384 Posts

    579

    0

    Posted July 15th, 2004 00:00

    I've had mine since Feburary and love it. Cost of the 8600 and 600 was one factor in the purchase. I blow out the fan and heat sink with compressed air once every week or two, my temps are always within reason (at 3.06-63c max, at 1.59-usually at about 30c).

    Yes I would buy one again, we change oil in our cars and vaccum our rugs don't we, a little maintance is not hard to do.

    You are going to find only the negatives on these forums,  their  purpose is to help solve problems.

     I read the overheating issues and agonized over ordering the 5150. It fit my needs and price range so I ordered it.I do not regret it.

    You have a return period if you do not like it, (30 days?).

    The choice is yours, my experiance has been good.

                                         Randy

    5150
    Mobile P4 3.06 HT
    64mb Nvidia
    768 Ram
    UXGA Samsung
    Hitachi 7k60
    1300 Wireless
    DVD+RW NEC 5100a
    Bios A29
    XP Pro

  • 579

    0

    Posted July 15th, 2004 12:00

    I would suggest another Dell laptop. It just seems comical to me that the user needs to spray out his/her laptop weekly. No new machine should suffer from those problems.

    I'd suggest a 600m or 8600. (Perhaps a slightly lower configuration to lower the price?) They have mobile processors which should help with the heat and come Centrino enabled, which most college kids can take advantage of!

  • penny1015

    5 Posts

    579

    0

    Posted July 15th, 2004 17:00

    Hi,
    Thanks for all your responses. We decided to go ahead with the order. My daughter says she is fine with using the air spray once a week. She is also very excited about getting it. She had an old IMac the first two years at college- and can't wait to change to a PC. We all have Mac's and love them, but she does not share our enthusiasm- especially when she is away at school and no one can help her with any technical difficulties she encounters- let's face it- most people are more familiar with PC's.
    Two other questions-1. Do most of you leave the laptop an 24/7? Since most schools are connected, most students leave their's on- IM messages and such.Will this harm the laptop?
    2. Can you buy a smaller,lighter AC adapter for the laptop? I have heard that Dell's adapter for this laptop is quite heavy.
    Once again, thanks for reassuring me and for answering me.
  • NemesisDB

    2 Intern

    •

    7944 Posts

    579

    0

    Posted July 15th, 2004 18:00

    Some have suggested that turning it off more will help solve the heat/fan/dust problems. When I'm at school I tend to leave mine on for weeks at a time though and I've never had any real problems with it -- I don't think you'll hurt it that way.  As for the adapter, not a clue.
  • TDunn

    379 Posts

    579

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2004 13:00

    No smaller adapter.......the big brick is the only one. 
    But as far as the system goes, it's a lot of bang for the buck..............TD

  • cobra_2004

    2 Intern

    •

    217 Posts

    113

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2004 14:00

    I would agree with TDunn, the adapter is pretty big, but I usually get good battery time. I find the adapter fits well in a good laptop carrying case. My friend got an XPS, man, if you think the 5150's adapter is big, then you havn't seen the XPS's. It's huge. Anyways, I've heard of people using other adapters in the 5150, but it wont charge the battery when the system is on, and it's not back by Dell, so if it fries your laptop, Dell isn't going to help you.