UNSOLVED

npgall

updated

23 years ago

Closed

N

npgall

26 Posts

0

56651

September 15th, 2003 00:00

Digital 5.1 audio over laptop S/PDIF port

I would like to connect a set of 5.1 surround sound speakers directly to my Inspiron 8500 for watching DVDs. I have observed many conflicting opinions on this subject in various threads so I decided to do some research on the subject and start a thread of my own.

First of all, I believe it is possible to output 5.1 surround sound audio directly from the S/PDIF port on Inspiron 8500 and 8600 laptops and possibly other models too. I haven't bought a set of surround sound speakers yet to test my theory, but I'm hoping someone else has and can test it to shed some light on the matter. Anyway, here's what I've uncovered so far...


The Inspiron 8500 audio chip is made by a company called SigmaTel, and the model of the chip is STAC9750. This chip complies with an audio chip specification defined by Intel; in particular, it complies with the Intel AC'97 v2.2 specification. This specification defines various modes of operation for the audio chip, and defines some minimum functionality that the chip must incorporate in order to fulfill the requirements of the specification.


When the laptop is playing stereo sound normally, it will output it simultaneously in both analog and digital form. The analog audio is sent to the internal speakers or headphone jack on the computer. The digital audio is sent in digital PCM format through the laptop's S/PDIF port. The AC'97 2.2 specification refers to this as "mixed mode" operation for "mixed data originating from the OS mixer service".


AC'97 2.2 also requires that the codec be able to operate in a "pass-thru" mode for "data originating from an independent S/PDIF source". This data can be PCM, MPEG, AC-3, DTS, or other format. The audio sent in this mode is not generated by the chip, rather the audio signal is sent into the chip and the chip passes the digital audio stream out through the S/PDIF port. An external Dolby Digital/DTS decoder and speakers must be connected to the S/PDIF port to play this audio.


As far as I know, PCM audio can be thought of as "dumb" digital audio. It does not incorporate any complex compression algorithms which means very little technology is needed to encode and to decode it. The SigmaTel audio chip in the Inspiron 8500 is able to generate this digital audio itself and output it over the S/PDIF link.


AC-3 and DTS are audio formats typically stored on DVD discs. They are much more advanced audio formats compared with PCM audio. They incorporate high levels of compression to reduce the amount of space needed to store the audio on disc, and many channels of audio may be encoded into one digital stream.  The SigmaTel chip is not able to generate digital audio of this complexity.


What this means, in my understanding, is that you can connect a set of surround sound speakers to the S/PDIF output on the Inspiron 8500 and, using the "pass thru" capability, you can output Dolby Digital surround sound to the speakers while playing a DVD.


There is a distinct difference however, between connecting a set of surround sound speakers directly to the Inspiron 8500's S/PDIF output, and connecting surround sound speakers to a computer with a multi-channel sound card.


Due to the SigmaTel chip's inability to encode multi-channel audio itself, you cannot use the S/PDIF output to get dynamically-generated surround sound.


If you plug a Creative Labs SoundBlaster Extigy into a USB port on the Inspiron 8500, and in turn, connect a set of surround sound speakers to the Extigy (either through analog connections or through a S/PDIF port), you can get surround sound output from your speakers in all applications, whether the applications are DVD movies or games.


In the case of games, the SigmaTel audio chip itself is not multi-channel, and so will only be capable of outputing PCM stereo audio over the S/PDIF link.


So what does this means for us?…


If you connect a set of surround sound speakers directly to the Inspiron 8500's S/PDIF port, you can get surround sound output in DVD movies, but you will not get surround sound output in games.
 
Anyway, that's "my two cents" on the subject :) I hope this information is accurate and useful, if not someone please tell me before I buy a set of surround sound speakers for watching DVDs with this laptop!

Message Edited by npgall on 09-15-2003 02:56 AM

  • Farit

    1 Message

    2040

    0

    Posted September 23rd, 2003 05:00

    I've connected my Inspiron 8200 via S/PDIF to a Sony home theatre system. It was necessary to choose "Use S/PDIF", in the sound preferences. Everything works fine, DD and DTS are dencoded by the Sony amplifier on its 5.1-channel sound system. However, you won't get more than 2 discrete channels anywhere but DVD. 

    Message Edited by Farit on 09-23-2003 01:56 AM

    Message Edited by Farit on 09-23-2003 02:07 AM

  • npgall

    26 Posts

    2040

    0

    Posted September 23rd, 2003 21:00

    That's great Farit, thanks for testing this. All I want to do is use the S/PDIF output for DVD 5.1 anyway - good to know it works.

    Many thanks.

  • Kanekane

    40 Posts

    2040

    0

    Posted November 6th, 2003 20:00

    Great introduction ont he 5.1 sound subject. That's a big problem today as consumers and product seller in general tend to think that spdif and toshlink digital connections always output in 5.1 whatever the sound source and the sound chip is !

    Alot of peoples also tend to think analog 3 stéréo jacks is always 5.1 compared to digital connection who need to be "switched" from pcm 2 chanels to 4.1 or 5.1...

    What I would like to add is that for the moment, if you have a stéréo source, like an mp3 in winamp or an older stéréo game, the max you will get from analog and digital connection will be 2 chanel, 2.1 is you have a sub or amp with build in cross over (not requiring it's own LFE chanel for filtering bass low frequency...).

    And for what I know, the only 3 sound card (chip) that can encode on the fly stéréo source like mp3 or windows wav sounds in AC3 (5.1) are the nForce series of boards having the nStorm audio codec (nForce 1 to 3) The Augigy 1 and 2, Live 5.1, Extigy, Guillemot cards and other like M audio and philips are like our Dell laptops, unable to create 5.1 chanels from a stéréo source.

    So as we are still nomad, not ready to sell our notebook to build an nForce based desktop (or like me are using our laptop 90% of the time for our multimedia ;-), our best solution for Surround sound is:

    To get a Dolby 5.1 or better amp (6.1, 7.1, DTS2, THX?!?), 5.1 or more speakers and to wire it up in digital S/PDIF mode from our inspi-titude S/PDIF port, then to use it in true 5.1, DTS and up mode while in DvD or AC3 source and to put it in Dolby Prologic or Prologic II while in mp3 and other stéréo sources.

    At this moment I'm using an older Aiwa NSX Dolby Pro Logic Analog 1997 system and using the Graphical EQ, the surround modes and the dolby pro logic mode, I get pretty damm good Surround sound from every source of audio I got ! and when I DivX, most of the time I'm alot surprised by the positionnal audio, voice from the center, back for from behind, deep bass from sub and front chanels ! The Chip in those Pro Logic amp contain ALOT of "false" surround settings, modes and options to "simulate" 5.1 using stéréo ! Same processing that in the nForce chips with more or elss options depending of the brand !

    Other than that a few High quality 5.1 computer speakers kits came with basic amp that contain a few "false" surround options.

    But that's my opinion, If you are an audio/video/computer hardware maniac like me I'm sure you already have put together your custom installation and maybe have found other ideas !

    By a day we will just run buying the new Extigy 4 running firewire and been able to get Dolby 12.2 encoding on the fly for our stéréo sources !

    Message Edited by Kanekane on 11-07-2003 03:00 PM

  • Andrew WOT

    194 Posts

    2040

    0

    Posted November 7th, 2003 17:00

    I would like to contribute a little to the subject from my experience with new USB external Soundblaster Audigy 2NX.

    Being successfully used SPDIF with internal AC97 Sigmatel in tandem with external Yamaha receiver with decoder I expected that after purchasing that new audio marvel I automatically get 5.1 or even 7.1 surround via SPDIF not only from AC3 encoded sources but virtually from anything.

    Yep, big mistake. To my suprise anything besides pass-through AC3 encoded signal from DVD reached receiver as 96Khz PCM Stereo. I was like WTF. After some internet reading over next day I found out that this is limitation of SPDIF and non AC3 encoded signal can be passed only as 2 channel stereo. So in order to get surround from such sources I have to connect analogue outs from the card to analogue ins on receiver. Extra headache, extra wires ......

    To the point - having SPDIF out doesn't mean that you get 5.1 in your speaker system or receiver even when generated signal is multichanneled unless the signal is AC3 (DD5.1, DTS...) encoded and to get it you don't need fancy audio card just SPDIF pass through capabilities of DVD player and card.

     

     

     

     

     

  • Kanekane

    40 Posts

    2040

    0

    Posted November 7th, 2003 18:00

    Thanks for this additionnal info Andrew, it remain me that the nForce serie (at least experimented nForce 1 and 2...) encode on the fly AC3 from stéréo source (when selected in the so nice NStorm panel) but only output this shelf created AC3 through Analog ports. The Toshlink connections still contain original PCM except when the source is "real" AC3 not generated (encoded) by the chip (e.g. DTS or 5.1 DvD...).

    It look like by these day and since the beginning of numeric interfaces, we are in a constant fight to use this new technology !

    To add a suggestion, I know even the cheapest Harman Kardon 5.1 receiver accept Analog 5.1 (or 7.1 in latest) inputs. Denon and certain Sony also have this option.

    What I would be very happy to see comming out would be a small boxe taking analog 5.1 and encoding it in AC3 to output in SPDIF and/or Toshlink !

    Also one question about the Audigy 2 NX, does it's able to encode on the fly stéréo source and output it in 5.1 using analog connection like nForce audio ?

  • dirgon

    174 Posts

    2086

    0

    Posted November 7th, 2003 20:00

    Fantastic thread folks.  Lot of useful information.

    Can someone suggest a good set of speakers that will work with the 8500 connected through the SPDIF port?

    Also, what about the Sound Blaster Extigy.  Would it be worthwhile to get the Extigy and use it with a hookup to the SPDIF port instead of USB or am I missing the mark on that particular device?

  • Andrew WOT

    194 Posts

    2086

    0

    Posted November 7th, 2003 21:00



    @Kanekane wrote:

    Thanks for this additionnal info Andrew, it remain me that the nForce serie (at least experimented nForce 1 and 2...) encode on the fly AC3 from stéréo source (when selected in the so nice NStorm panel) but only output this shelf created AC3 through Analog ports. The Toshlink connections still contain original PCM except when the source is "real" AC3 not generated (encoded) by the chip (e.g. DTS or 5.1 DvD...).

    It look like by these day and since the beginning of numeric interfaces, we are in a constant fight to use this new technology !

    To add a suggestion, I know even the cheapest Harman Kardon 5.1 receiver accept Analog 5.1 (or 7.1 in latest) inputs. Denon and certain Sony also have this option.

    What I would be very happy to see comming out would be a small boxe taking analog 5.1 and encoding it in AC3 to output in SPDIF and/or Toshlink !

    Also one question about the Audigy 2 NX, does it's able to encode on the fly stéréo source and output it in 5.1 using analog connection like nForce audio ?



    Yes, my receiver, not the cheapest btw, has 6.1 analogue input, this is what I'm going to use to get 5.1 from non AC3/DTS encoded signals when I receive ordered minijack extension wires. On the fly AC3 encoding esp. real time can be very difficult to implement because it involves coding and compression, doubt that one exists.

    Multichanneled analogue output generated by sound card is not AC3 btw. It's uncoded raw analogue, AC3 means encoded signal and requires some decoding device on receiving side to produce analogue audio (you can't send it directly to speakers). Audigy 2NX does have the possibility to produce 3d enchanced output from stereo or mono sources, it's called CMSS3D as well as add some extra EAX effects like auditorium, church or other types of listening environment.

    Details can be found here http://www.soundblaster.com/products/audigy2NX/

     

  • Kanekane

    40 Posts

    2086

    0

    Posted November 9th, 2003 21:00

    Hi Paul, I don't know for the I-8x00 (where x is 5 or 6) but when x was 0, 1 or 2, it was a standard accessory.

    If it's not included as standard, I would suggest you to go ebay as here it's frequent to see those brand new adaptors for sale for less than Dell sell them, like only a few bucks with free shipping.

    Also you should know that the plug is without the dongle, a standard S-Video jack (obvious, but some peoples don't know that).

  • PAUL ZIRIS

    14 Posts

    2086

    0

    Posted November 9th, 2003 21:00

    Does dell deliver the TV/digital audio adapter cable (s-video to s-video+composite+spdif cable) in standard with Inspiron 8500-8600?

    Thanks

  • npgall

    26 Posts

    668

    0

    Posted November 9th, 2003 22:00

    I got the dongle with my 8500 that has composite, s-video and coaxial s/pdif output. I'm pretty sure it comes with the I8600 too.

    EDIT: I just re-read the previous posts - Kanekane is right, the dongle is supplied but I did have to buy the cable to connect the dongle to my TV. Got it on eBay and it works well. Interesting posts BTW Kanekane and Andrew - cheers.

    Message Edited by npgall on 11-10-2003 01:03 AM