UNSOLVED

pj56

updated

17 years ago

P

pj56

3 Posts

0

68291

June 13th, 2009 00:00

Dell XPS M1710 GeForce Go 7950 GTX GPU failure now what?

My GPU has failed (and warranty is expired), from what I have read in various forums this is a reoccurring problem with the graphics card. I have done some research and noticed it might be possible to get a replacement video card for around ~$500. My concern is spending $500 only to have the same problem down the road. I am curious if anyone out there has replaced this card only to get the same failure, or if anyone has a found a way to defeat this problem? I have owned laptops for many years and abused many of them for around 3-4 years before a failure. With a little more that a year use of this dell laptop I feel like I might be sending it to the recycling depot way to premature, but maybe that is the only viable option at this point.

  • dgkpcon

    3597 Posts

    1008

    0

    Posted June 13th, 2009 11:00

    There are a number of posts about the XPS 1710 video card failure.I can not comment on that but my 7900GS has been replaced (under warranty still) 4 times in the past year.One of those was a bad replacement card sent out,so i guess that was a fluke.The other 3 were actual failures though.yours went out at a little over one year,my first failure was right at 2 years,second was 4 months after the replacement (this is when the bad card was sent out,and then replaced again 2 days later) and final failure was about 8 months later.

    So,to answer your question about having the same problem down the road,probably.Electronic components do not last forever and my experiences with mine,after the first failure,yes it will happen again.Have you checked ebay?...I have seen some 7950GTX's going for $325.00-$395.00.About 6 months ago i saw one for $295.00.Since yours is out of warranty,if you go thru ebay,you will get at least 30,60,or a 90 day warranty.Depending on the seller. I have seen some come with a 9 month warranty.

  • pj56

    3 Posts

    1008

    0

    Posted June 13th, 2009 14:00

    You know the amount of heat this laptop generates actually caused all the stickers on the bottom of the case to warp and melt.  I am actually surprised this laptop lasted 1 year.  I think ebay answered the question.  You can buy a used m1710 for ~$800-$1000 or a 7950 GTX from $400-500.  Even if I could get a steal of a deal on 7950 I dont think it worth the money or effort.  With all the posts I would think dell/nvidia would recall these products and fix them, I must say, I feel some what ripped off.

  • dgkpcon

    3597 Posts

    1008

    0

    Posted June 14th, 2009 10:00

    "With all the posts I would think dell/nvidia would recall these products and fix them, I must say, I feel some what ripped off."

    Nvidia has never announced that these or any G71 cards are defective.The problem lies within the system build itself.Insufficient cooling and placement of the heatsink and/or air vents is the problem in my opinion.If you have been inside,or seen the inside of the system durring the replacement of the video card you would understand.

     

    EDIT:Almost forgot to add.That is why anytime you purchase an expensive notebook like these you always purchase at least a 3 year warranty with it.Warranties come in handy in situations like these.

  • ebolaz

    3 Posts

    1012

    0

    Posted June 16th, 2009 07:00

    Yup. Dead display - and it died while on the net, not even while playing a game. :(

    I'm going to pull it apart & see what I can do, but really I'm suspecting I'll be trying to shoehorn in any old display adapter that I can make fit (wish me luck).

    I'm so reassured of quality... Apple is starting to look pretty good...

     

    --ebola

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    1012

    0

    Posted June 16th, 2009 07:00

    If you go the Apple route, buy the 3-year AppleCare - their hardware is no more reliable than Dell's.

     

  • ebolaz

    3 Posts

    1012

    0

    Posted December 21st, 2009 08:00

    mine sort of did for a while... I think it was the reduced resolution. Then... a while expired.

  • Alfred_T

    2 Posts

    1012

    0

    Posted December 21st, 2009 08:00

    Hi I noticed this thread.

    I also have the same laptop with dead display. An external display works ok though so I though that on-board video card was ok.

    Replaced screen and inverter board but stll dead.

    When your displays died did it work on external monitor?

  • pj56

    3 Posts

    1012

    0

    Posted December 21st, 2009 10:00

    When mine failed I tried the external display on mine, it did not work for me.  Originally I thought it was the display too.

    In the end, I sent that laptop, along with my XPS desktop which also had a heat related failure to the recycling depot.

  • Alfred_T

    2 Posts

    1012

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2009 01:00

    Ok thanks for the quick replies.

    Mine works fine on external but doesn't even detect the presence of the on-board display, and when using the function and f8 keys the external display blanks for a couple of seconds then comes on again.

    Maybe I've been sent a faulty replacement screen. I'll try getting back to the supplier..

     

    Alfred

  • ofthedoor

    7 Posts

    440

    0

    Posted December 22nd, 2009 14:00

    Same for me on my almost 3 year old XPS 1710. 2 GeForce Go 7900 GS already. I don't even replace the card anymore, I....BAKE it. Belive it or not.

    400 degrees for 15 mns. It melts the alloy solder that is cracked and caused the problems ( I assume this is what it does). The first time I baked it, the repair lasted 11 days. I increased the baking time to 15 mns. If it fails again, ...I will bake it again until it doesn't work at all anymore. Why? $585.00 is how much a refurbished card cost, and I am so done spending that much money on this laptop which has been trouble since day one.

    Here is how I found out about the "baking" repair:

     

    http://forum.notebookreview.com/showthread.php?t=392393&page=5