
UNSOLVED
Inspiron 530 graphics card upgrade
Hi,
I have an Insprion 530 with Intel E6420 running at 2.12 GHz, 4 GB RAM, NVidia 7600 GT, and a new 430 W PSU. I have been thinking to upgrade my graphics card, but I cannot figure out what should I purchase. I am also confused about the power requirements needed from NVidia or ATI Radeon that say their graphics card needs 400 W or more to run. Which graphics card can I put in without causing any conflicts with my system? I am thinking of getting the NVidia Geforce 240 or the Radeon 4860 HD. Can I use either of these or something that is similar or even better? I hope someone can give me some advice on this matter.
Sincerely,
David
Responses (31)
Solutions (0)
Do you think that HD 5750 will fit in the Inspiron 530? I checked the technical specs, and it lists that one needs a 450 W minimal to run this card. Also, I read it creates a lot of heat. My PSU has two fans as well as one fan from ATX case. Would that be enough to cool the case if it does get hot inside? Are any other cards I should consider?
Thanks,
David
Two fans on your power supply won't do much for cooling your case and with just one 92mm fan in the back exhausting heat, it doesn't help things a whole lot. The 530 is a small case which is why I prefer a video card that exhausts heat out the back versus keeping it inside. I have a GTS 250 in my 530 that exhausts heat out and it is much cooler than my previous 9600 GT. When you start to upgrade these cases with higher-end components producing more heat, you could possibly have issues down the road. There is just not much you can do to add the extra cooling you need either. Power wise, your entire system with the HD 5750 would not even need 200 watts. I didn't think the HD 5750 got that hot. The fan design on the card keeps the chip cooler, but you give up putting the heat inside your case. Some HD 5770s like this one HERE are designed to exhaust heat which could be an option. Remember that manufactures overstate quite a bit what is actually needed from the power supply.
Here is a chart showing some cards and what is needed by your entire system.
The HD 5750 is smaller than the GTS 250 so it will fit. The GTS 250 is better than the HD 5750, but the HD 5770 is better than the GTS 250 and uses less power. I do have a 500 watt power supply in my case. I have the EVGA GTS 250. I got a good deal on mine and it was only $79.99 after rebates, but that was back in June of last year. For whatever reason, the prices are higher now. If I was looking for a card today, I would probably choose the HD 5770 since it has newer technology and is DirectX 11 compatible or wait for the new Nvidia 300 series cards to come out later this month or next.
I have been checking out the ATI Radeon HD 5770 cards, and most of them require 450 W or more. I think I should have bought a better power supply for my computer something like a 500 Watt or higher since my PSU only does 430 Watts. Can you recommend a good power supply for this card as well as which company makes the most reliable graphics card such as XFX or Sapphire?
First of all, what power supply do you have (brand and model)? As you can see from the chart, you are not looking at much over 200 watts needed by your entire system with the HD 5770, but that does vary by review. Others run the HD 5770 on their Dell 375W power supplies. Sapphire is the number one manufacturer for ATI so they would be my first pick. I would just have to compare cards, costs and other features to narrow it down to the brand I would get. XFX does have a double lifetime warranty which is nice compared to Sapphire's 2 year warranty. However, most people upgrade their video cards before 2 years anyway. Sapphire, XFX, HIS & Gigabyte are generally the brands I look at and just compare features such as the cooling they are using even though I don't own an ATI card. If you find a card you like, see if you can find a professional review on it. The reviews on Newegg can be overwhelming and are always both positive and negative so it sometimes can be difficult to make a decision, but still worth looking at since they are owners of the card.
HERE is a review of the Sapphire HD 5770 I linked above.
I am using the Thermaltake TR2 430 Watt PSU, so far I really like it because it is so quiet. My Dell 305 W power supply was using the fan too much under easy conditions such as looking at email and web browsing at the same time. I am glad that other Dell Inspiron 530 owners were able to use this HD 5770 card without any problems. I am also glad that I do not have to purchase another PSU because I just purchase the Thermaltake last week. I am still reading this review on the Sapphire card, and so far I am liking what it says.
I also agree that the reviews at Newegg can be overwhelming because there is a 50/50 of positive and negative reviews. I think you have take those reviews with a grain of salt because some of them are very biased on some manufacturers than others.
Thanks for helping me on my decision as to which card I should buy. I think I will go ahead and purchase that Sapphire card and see how it works. I also think this will work better than my NVidia 7600 GT for my new Dell ST2310 23" monitor that is coming this Friday.
Do you know what program I should use to remove any leftovers from the NVidia drivers? I remember there was a program that would delete NVidia, ATI, and Creative files left on your computer, but I cannot remember the name of it. Isn't there a series of steps you have to do before you install a new graphics card to make sure it works correctly?
Sincerely,
David
Use Driver Sweeper. Make sure you use it in safe mode. The instructions are at the top of this video forum under Nvidia driver installation and ATI driver installation.
I hate to burst your bubble, but the Thermaltake according to the conclusion of THIS review is not a very good power supply and they are pretty thorough with their reviews. As a rule, buying a power supply for under $50 falls into the cheap category and this one is only $37. Maybe you will have good luck with it, it's hard to say. I know it is very popular on Newegg, but it is just not one I would choose. Based on the review, if it indeed just performs like a 350W PSU you may still have success with it since the HD 5770 still does not need this much.
What power supply and what wattage do you recommend? I was looking at the Antec EA500 from that same website, but some reviewers from newegg say it dies within a year or so. What brands are the best for quality and reliability that does not break the bank?
David Raymore

JMICHAEL
1721 Posts
897
0
Posted March 2nd, 2010 14:00
The 4860 might be too much for your power supply as it requires two PCIe hook ups and you may not have this on a 430W PSU unless you upgraded with a good name brand quality unit. The GT 240 is fine depending on what your purpose is for the card. I would look somewhere in between the two and maybe check out the HD 5750. It is going to be much better than the GT 240 and also has low power consumption. The GT 240 requires no additional power hook up and the HD 5750 just needs one.