
UNSOLVED
Can or should I put an x800 in my Dimension 8300
I have a Dimension 8300 with 1.9Ghz P4, 256 MB of RDRAM and a Geforce3 TI200 card. I am thinking of upgrading to 1Gig of RAM and a new video card.
First of all, should I be getting the PC3200 (400Mhz)RAM or the PC2700(333mhz) RAM?
I know it has been established that the Dell Powersupplies although rated at 250 Watts are actually 350 Watts, but I have been having a hard time finding reqirements for the new ATI x800 cards on the net. All I can find is how many pipelines the new cards have and how many FPS they can achieve on UT2004. I have yet to see a power requirement yet. Does anyone know if I can stick a x800 into my Dimeinsion 8300 without stability problems?
For some reason I have always favored Nvdia cars, but with Dells decision to go with a proprietary powersupply and the 6800's 480 Watt demand, it looks like the x800 is my only option for cutting edge graphics.
Is the x800 even a decent option for such an old computer? Will my 1.9 Ghz processor and obsolete chipset limit the potential of an x800 so much that I might as well go with something like a Radeon 9700 or 9800 instead?
Responses (5)
Solutions (0)
I can get two sticks of 512 MB RDRAM from Dell for about $300 and a x800 Pro for $400....Or if I wait a little while I could get a Radeon 9800 XT for $300-$400
If I am gonna drop the money for a new puter, I wouldn't get a refurb...I wouldn't even get a Dell. I love my current Dell, but their awfull choice to go with proprietary parts is causing my current heart-ache in upgrading. If I were just a regular web browsing, word processing user I would get a Dell every time, but I like graphic intensive games, which calls for cutting edge upgrades regularly. Dell systems just are not as friendly to upgrading. For right now I would just like to upgrade my current Dell. My dream would be for an Alienware with a Geforce 6800 video card, an Athalon 64 FX-53 or P4 Extreme(was waiting for Tejas, but now Intel ditched it) and a pair of 74 Gig 10,000 RPM hard drives in RAID 0.
CatoftheNight
1 Rookie
•
523 Posts
368
0
Posted May 25th, 2004 21:00
Never get Alienware. Overpriced, Bad Tech Support and sound like a hoover. You'd be far better off building your own system.
Nvidia has stated that the Two Molex connectors and the 480w power supply recommendations are for hard-core overclockers, and they have since lowered the power requirment to 350w and most likely two molex connectors still, and as they said, that's for stability. On top of that, they are also working on a one slot version. Personally, I'd go with the 6800 over the x800, as it has 16 pipelines of 12, which will give it a HUGE advantage down the road.
Back to your question...Sticking a x800 in that Dell would be a waste. Unless, of course, you only planned on having it like that for a week or so, and would be building your own system later...But Dells just don't seem to be Thermally designed to handle a x800, nor are their power supplies quite enough. Sorry.
Good luck!
I don't mean to sounds harsh, but why is it that everyone's answer now adays is why don't you just build your own system instead. You state Alienware has terrible Tech support, well guess how much Tech support you get if you build your own system....NONE. Plus you have to keep track of 15-20 different product warranties. I have had several friends who have had problems with compatabilities, corrupted memory and HDDs building their own system....at least with Alienware and Dell I know they test my sytem before the send it out and if there is a problem with it, I can get at least a little help resolving it.
Also the x800XT has 16 pipelines just like the nVidia. I am not going to start defending ATI, because I have always fought on the side of nVidia, but ATI expanded the x800XT from 12 to 16 pipelines as soon as they heard the 6800 had 16....the x800 Pro may still have only 12, but the XT has 16. Seeing your Avatar of a Canadian flag would make me think you would support ATI though, since they are a Canadian company.
My 8300 handles the X800 Pro just fine. If you look at the specs you'll see that it draws a little less power than the 9800XT and produces less heat as well. Here's a link to my 3dmark03 score using the X800 in my 8300.

1Bowtie
723 Posts
368
0
Posted May 23rd, 2004 21:00
Hi HOOfan
Your cpu is going to be the biggest bottleneck. Next for 1 gig of RDRam and the x800 vid card your looking at about $1000 dollars and you still have a minimal comp at best. It's your money but my advice to you is save your money and buy a refurb Dell on Dell's refurb site. Check my sig, i bought this one in Jan for about $1800.