UNSOLVED

lzs0

updated

6 years ago

L

lzs0

7 Posts

0

4483

June 19th, 2020 03:00

WD19TB with XPS 13 7390 2-in-1 with 2x 4K external monitors

I'm thinking about hooking up a WD19TB with an XPS 13 7390-2in-1 with two monitors. While doing some research, I didn't realise how complicated Thunderbolt 3 and dual external monitors can be! While there have been lots of helpful answers (thanks especially @jphughan !), I still have a few more to to clear my doubts.

I referred to the WD19TB's display resolution table (https://www.dell.com/support/manuals/hr/en/hrbsdt1/dell-wd19tb-dock/wd19_tb_userguide/display-resolution-table?guid=guid-5558fc88-5c31-4e2c-90be-42359855a1ae&lang=en-us). The XPS 13 7390 2-in-1 should support DP1.4, and thus I should look at the rows for HBR3 with TB. The column on dual monitor configuration refers to DP1.4 ports. My monitors are DP1.2 only. My questions are:

1. Can I still get 2x 4K@60Hz?  (I.e. the two monitors being DP1.2 doesn't matter)

2. Or, does it mean the WD19TB/notebook would operate in HBR2 mode because my monitors are DP1.2, and hence I should be looking at a maximum of 2x QHD@60Hz? 

3. Is there some mix-and-match possible? I.e. to support FHD@60Hz and 4K@60Hz which has a total bandwidth requirement of 15.7 Gbps, would work in if the WD19TB worked with HBR2 in TB mode?

I'd ordinarily expect DP1.4 host to surely be downward compatible to a DP1.2 monitor... but I'm not sure if things get complicated going through a Thunderbolt 3 dock.

Appreciate any help!

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2742

    3

    Posted June 19th, 2020 07:00

    @lzs0  Yes the XPS 13 7390 2-in-1 supports DP 1.4 output, so you're looking at the correct table.  It doesn't matter that your displays only support DP 1.2.  The documentation just describes the outputs as DP 1.4 because the outputs actually support DP 1.4.  It doesn't mean that's actually required in order to run the indicated configuration.  After all, if 4K 60 Hz weren't possible over DP 1.2, then it wouldn't be possible for you to have a 4K 60 Hz that only supported DP 1.2.

    Using DP 1.2 displays will not cause your system to fall back to DP 1.2 to the dock.

    You can mix and match, but you don't have to, and depending on the physical sizes of the displays involved, mixing FHD and 4K might mean you'd have to use different scaling factors for the different displays, and mixing and matching scale factors in Windows isn't a great experience at all for reasons that would lengthen this post quite a bit.

  • lzs0

    7 Posts

    2731

    0

    Posted June 19th, 2020 17:00

    Hi @jphughan, thanks for your clarification about the DP1.2/1.4 behaviour.

    Totally understand the different sizes/scaling. Windows doesn't seem to deal with scaling very well. Unfortunately, I'm making do with whatever monitors happen to be around to use.  

  • Robert_kh

    6 Posts

    2708

    1

    Posted June 20th, 2020 17:00

    Hey i have to warn you about this !

    I own this setup:
    xps 7390 2 in 1
    wd19tb
    2* dell u2718q

    it doesn't work properly... second monitor won't be recognized and if so will get at most 30hz...
    I've gone through hell with this setup.. driver updates, bios setting , bunch of different cables ..

    eventually the dell's support told me that the wd19tb doesn't support the xps 7390 2 in 1 thus the issues....

     

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2680

    2

    Posted June 21st, 2020 16:00

    @Robert_kh  Thanks for the real world experience note.  At least according to the documentation, the WD19TB absolutely supports the XPS 13 7390 2-in-1.  But as often occurs in the technology world, the fact that things should work together doesn't always mean that they will.  In fact there are multiple long threads right now about the newer XPS 13 9300 and a wide range of USB-C/TB3 issues that seem to be related to firmware issues.  In one case, a BIOS update seems to have broken the ability to use many USB-C to DisplayPort adapters.

    Real world experience is more useful than theory any day of the week, although I have to say I'm disappointed with whoever you heard from at Dell Support.  What they should have said was something along the lines of, "This combination should work, but since you're having trouble, we'll escalate this issue in case this is caused by a firmware issue on the system and/or dock."  I suspect that whoever told you it wasn't supported was just giving up, because that statement is not accurate.  Here is a dock guide from Dell's own site showing that it is compatible.  (Ironically however, that guide has some errors that I've reported to a Dell Support rep here, who escalated to the Documentation team and received confirmation that they were errors and would be fixed at some point.  Specifically, the two XPS 7390 models should be marked as compatible with the WD19 130W, not just the 180W version, since they only require 45W and therefore wouldn't even use the extra power of the 180W version even if it were there.  And second, the XPS 9530 line should say XPS 9550.  The XPS 9530 doesn't have USB-C or TB3 at all.  The first XPS 15 model to get that was the 9550, which isn't even mentioned on that PDF -- except in typo form as the 9530.)

  • Robert_kh

    6 Posts

    2660

    1

    Posted June 22nd, 2020 03:00

    Hey , thanks for the comment, by the documentation you can see for your self:
    https://topics-cdn.dell.com/pdf/dell-wd19tb-dock_users-guide3_en-us.pdf
    page 7: 

    xps 7390 2 in 1 is not really supported...  

     

    really hope that it's a software issue... and that dell would really take the time to fix it... i've spent a little fortune on this setup for work purposes... kinda mad about this issue

    Untitled.png

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2648

    2

    Posted June 22nd, 2020 06:00

    @Robert_kh  The most recent XPS 13 model listed in that documentation is the 9380, which is the model that directly preceded the 7390.  That documentation just hasn't been updated.  There isn't a newer dock than the WD19TB, and Dell definitely didn't just stop supporting docking stations on their XPS 13 system after the 9380.  That's just outdated.  Unfortunately it's not even remotely uncommon for Dell not to go back and update their system compatibility information in the documentation of their accessories as new systems launch after the accessory was introduced.  The PDF I linked clearly does mention the 7390, and the Documentation team confirmed that the 7390's compatibility information should be broader than it is, namely including the WD19 130W as recommended.

  • Robert_kh

    6 Posts

    2643

    0

    Posted June 22nd, 2020 07:00

    Thanks for the info  crossing fingers dell's developers will release new build for bios\firmware.. 
      

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2490

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2020 17:00

    @howdyneighbor  What dock outputs and cables did you use?

  • 1524

    0

    Posted July 16th, 2020 17:00

    DP on both and cables that came with U2718Qs

  • 2500

    1

    Posted July 16th, 2020 17:00

    To answer your question, NO you do not get 4k at 60hz on both monitors...even with laptop display turned off.  Just bought a WD19TB to try on my 7390 2 in 1.  No matter the monitor/card configuration. You only get 1 x 60Hz and 1 x 30Hz.  I am sending my docking station back to Amazon (yay Free Returns).  I had high hopes based on this thread, but based on real life past experiences with Dell and other manufacturers claims I was not surprised.

    Hope this helps and isnt too late.