UNSOLVED

ejolaus

updated

13 years ago

E

ejolaus

15 Posts

0

1145

March 9th, 2014 11:00

VNX 5400 and 5500 RAID levels

Hi there,

What is the recommendation in terms of RAID level for Telco applications running on these 2 systems?

VNX 5400

VNX 5500

What about Raid5 (4+1) and Raid6 (6+2)? Besides safety, what are the performance impacts?

  • Roger_Wu

    6 Operator

    •

    4025 Posts

    519

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2014 18:00

    You can refer to the whitepaper for more details: http://www.emc.com/collateral/software/white-papers/h10938-vnx-best-practices-wp.pdf

    RAID 6 is good for SATA disks. For SAS disks, RAID 5 is enough.


  • ejolaus

    15 Posts

    519

    0

    Posted March 13th, 2014 09:00

    Thanks for the document!

    But isn't now a days the endurance of both types of disks similar?

  • AdamFox

    254 Posts

    519

    0

    Posted March 13th, 2014 10:00

    Endurance isn't the issue, IMHO, as much as speed and size with respect to protection.

    It's a trade off.  Unless you have full stripe writes (which I never assume when sizing a system.  If we get them, it's better than expected, but I don't count on that to get to the performance I need), you will pay a higher write penalty with RAID 6 than RAID 5.  This makes sense because you have 2 parities to handle instead of 1 per stripe.  Reads are effectively the same since I don't care about parity when reading (assuming I'm not degraded).  What you get for that penalty is better protection.  Once I lose a drive, I care about how long I'm exposed with respect to the next failure for performance but more importantly for data integrity.  NL-SAS drives are slower and typically bigger which means the rebuild will take longer, in some cases significantly longer, than SAS drives.  This is why having the extra protection of RAID-6 is good  And if I'm willing to put data on NL-SAS drives, that data is typically not as performance sensitive as data I might put on faster drives so I'm more willing to take the write penalty in exchange for the better protection.  The same holds true for RAID width.  I have to do more reads do rebuild a 14+2 R6 than a 6+2 R6 so that can affect my rebuild time.  I also have less of a chance with bigger workloads in getting those full stripe writes with 14+2 unless I know I'm doing large sequential writes, which is not a typical workload for most applications, in my experience.

    Hope this helps.