UNSOLVED

ArchAngel78

updated

22 years ago

0

4429

November 16th, 2004 15:00

Hitachi/IBM Drives and the 700m

Hi everybody,

I just wanted to get a head count and a consolidated resource for everyone that is experiencing my problem with their Hitachi Hard drives.  I got the Hitachi 30 gig drive for my 700m.  Everything was fine until I noticed it clicking loudly about every 10 Minutes.  Did research on the message boards and find out that a lot of other people are experiencing the same thing.  I get on Dell Support Live Chat and they have me do a lot of tests before finally determining that it is indeed the hard drive.  They say that they will ship me a new hard drive.  I asked them explicitly to not send me another Hitachi/IBM drive because of all the problems.  They agreed. 

I was very happy to see that the next day I received a package from Dell and it is my new hard drive.  Unfortunately it is the exact same hard drive and a refurbished one at that.  In the spirit of fair play I install the new hard drive and after ghosting my old one over to it I start it up.  So I start up the computer and one of the first things it does it the clicking noise.  Haven’t heard the sound since but its only been about 20 minutes.  If I hear the clicking noise again I will have to call Dell and speak to a manager and really fire someone up because this is unacceptable.  What is everyone else’s experience with this?  Thanks!

Update:

After a long time talking on the phone to Dell Technical support I was forwarded to one of the tech reps managers.  He apologized a lot and said this is a known problem with the 700m's.  He said they are trying to get a different type of hard drive for the 700m (after telling me that they are a special type and size so other drives won't work).  He said I would be notified when they had different hard drives.  I am not trying to flame or complain to much but I am very frustrated with Dell support right now.  I honestly don't know whether to believe that they are trying to reach a solution for this problem.  Anybody else going through the same thing????

 

Message Edited by ArchAngel78 on 11-16-2004 01:27 PM

  • laffingbilly

    106 Posts

    214

    0

    Posted November 16th, 2004 18:00

    That is a complete lie...the 700m does not take a special hard drive or type of hard drive other than your standard 2.5" mobile hard drives.  that guy was clueless.  i would demand to talk to a manger.   once again that is completely false!!!  they replaced my bad Hitachi with a Fujitsu.  The service manual for the 700m shows a Seagate HD.  That is absolutely untrue what he said about it needing a special drive.  I'll say it again.  That is absolutely False.  They obviously know about the problem from the CSR's own admission.  Dell sells alot of other HD's for laptops which they could give you.  any HD manufacturer makes a 2.5" mobile for laptops.  I cannot believe he would lie like that.
  • TechniKal

    76 Posts

    214

    0

    Posted November 17th, 2004 02:00

    Check your power setting and see if you have your HD's set to power down after 10 minutes. If so, the 'clunk' that you're hearing is likely the heads being 'parked' as the drive spins down. It's a normal thing, though I do notice it's a bit louder on the Hitachi drives.
  • laffingbilly

    106 Posts

    214

    0

    Posted November 17th, 2004 06:00

    if it click click click that ain't no clunk.  call dell and get rid of it.
  • 214

    0

    Posted November 17th, 2004 12:00

    Its not the heads parking on the hard drive.  I checked the power save stuff and nothing caused it to happen and anyways if this is the case it would make the noise every time I closed the laptop.  I have not recieved an email for my case from the "Manager" that I talked to.  This forces me to believe that I was just "punted" in order to get me off the line and also lied to.  This has irritated me to no end and I am not certain as to what to do from here on out.  I am going to call again today and try to talk sense into someone.  Keep the replies coming everyone.
  • laffingbilly

    106 Posts

    214

    0

    Posted November 17th, 2004 20:00

    that's good, just ask for a manager this time