UNSOLVED

alexjent

updated

19 years ago

A

alexjent

6 Posts

0

20584

March 2nd, 2008 14:00

Dell D610 - Will a Seagate 160Gb ata-100 ST9460821A-RK HD owrk in this machine?

The title says it all.  I am about to pick up a couple of these Seagate HD's and just want assuarence from someone whi has been there, done that.

 

Also, I can't find an answer to: What is the largest HD the machine will support.  It running XP Pro SP2.

 

Thanks for any insight, things to watch out for, etc.

 

Alex

  • jackshack

    6447 Posts

    401

    0

    Posted March 2nd, 2008 15:00

    The problem is two-fold.  If you install the drive into your machine, and the bios does not report the full size of the drive, it does not have 48 bit LBA.  If it does report the full size you're ok.

     

    Most importantly, however, your os installation CD must support 48 bit LBA.  This is true for Windows XP with Service Pack 1 or later.  Given your info you are good to go on this point.

     

    With Win XP SP-1 or later you can use the drive whether or not the computer bios supports it.  The only difficulty is with utilities that use the bios routines to communicate with the drive.  Windows does not use the bios once the first few sectors have been read during the boot process and most folks I have heard from seem to get along fine so long as they only access the drive with their os, or a utility that has its own 48 bit LBA capable disk driver.

     

    Your machine has at least a chance of having 48 bit LBA.  Check out this post.  Fellow forum member ejn63 also recommends keeping a back-up image of the drive for emergencies, or at least of your data, in the event of problems.  I think this to be good advice.

     

  • alexjent

    6 Posts

    401

    0

    Posted March 2nd, 2008 16:00

    Thanks for the input and good info Jack.  I  guess we'll find out.  I'm to pick up a couple of these drives this afternoon.  The first thing I will do is boot into the BIOS, see what it reports and go from there.  The machine was shipped in late 2005.

     

    I'll post a definitive finding on how it went.

     

    Thanks,

    Alex

     

    D610 2.13GHZ 60Gb HD 2GB RAM

  • jackshack

    6447 Posts

    401

    0

    Posted March 2nd, 2008 17:00

    You're quite welcome.  Good luck!

     

  • leduke30

    2 Intern

    •

    4033 Posts

    401

    0

    Posted March 28th, 2008 01:00

    (Quote)

    Thanks for the input and good info Jack.  I  guess we'll find out.  I'm to pick up a couple of these drives this afternoon.  The first thing I will do is boot into the BIOS, see what it reports and go from there.  The machine was shipped in late 2005.

     

    I'll post a definitive finding on how it went.

     

     

    How did you make out with your 160s in the D610?

     

    Dell Latitude D510

    1,73ghz Pentium M w/Centrino Tech.
    15" XGA LCD Screen
    160gb 5400rpm Samsung HDD
    1024mb PC3200 DDR2 SDRAM
    Internal WiFi Mini-PCI Card
    DVD-R/RW
    Floppy w/USB Cord

     

    Message Edited by leduke30 on 03-27-2008 09:53 PM
  • alexjent

    6 Posts

    401

    0

    Posted March 28th, 2008 02:00

    Oppps!

     

    Sorry.  I forgot to get back!  Thanks for the bump.

     

    You were quite right.  The BIOS reports 120GB no matter what's in there (over 120GB) but LBA is in effect so the OS hummmmmms merrily along and My Computer properties shows the full 160 minus a bit for who knows what.  If someone else installs a different OS and the OS doesn't manage the LBA, that's their problem.

     

    Works for me!!

     

    Just got the 120Gb drives that are about to be installed.  Guess that BIOS might say 120GB.... :)

     

    Thanks for your help.

     

    Chow,

    Alex

  • leduke30

    2 Intern

    •

    4033 Posts

    401

    0

    Posted March 28th, 2008 03:00

    The reason a 160gb drive will show as a 149gb(+ or-) is HDD MFRs use a gigabyte of 10 to the ninth , but the computer recognizes its size in digital gigabytes of 2 to the 30th power or about 1.073gb. You lose about 7% in indicated capacity. Windows OS have always shown both values on the drive's properties window
  • Wmsmit

    2 Posts

    401

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2008 16:00

    I've installed the Seagate 160gb drive on two separate D610's. On each D610 it works for awhile (couple weeks) then all of a sudden I can't boot up - I get a blinking cursor after the Dell boot screen.

    I have BIOS version A06. My OS recognizes 148GB HD when it ran.

    Does anyone have a solution so I can boot up these laptops without reformating/reinstalling OS?

    I'm running Windows XP Pro SP3.

     

  • 401

    0

    Posted December 2nd, 2008 20:00

    I had the identical problem with my D600. I don't know for sure if the D610 has the same limitation, but I suspect it is the same thing from your description. The problem is that there's a 2**28 sector limit in the BIOS (~137GBytes). The BIOS and Windows don't complain, but then at some point the disk fills and "wraps" back to the start, wiping out the boot sectors, etc. The workaround was to partition into two drives: the boot drive C: is just under 2**28 sectors, and the second is a logical partition taking up the rest of the drive. The latter mounts fine after Windows has booted. I've tested this by filling it and the wraparound doesn't happen (after several months of heavy use now). So I have two drive letters, which isn't perfect, but it works well enough. Hope this helps.