Calling all Dimension E510 / 5150 owners, Hard Drive HOT Overheating and Case
Flaw
Hi All,
I have a Dell Dimension E510 / 5150 that I purchased new in January. I recently installed a second hard drive, Maxtor 250 GB. I began having a problem with the system shutting down during use. I was able to determine that it was caused by the hard drives being to hot. I switched the drives in the drive bays and that seemed to help a little, but after using the system with a load I have the same problem. The system shuts down during use. I purchased a SMART hard drive monitoring software utility called O&O Drive Led and my hard drive temps during normal operation are 48-52 degrees C. When I use the system for an extended period of time the temps rise to 55-58 degrees C. I am really not using any intense applications… just MS Office and the internet. I do not do any gaming whatsoever.
I decided to just run the systems original 160GB WD hard drive to see if that made any difference. Well the temps at idle were 44-46 Degrees C and with a load they were 52 degrees C. Which does seem a bit high in my book… Anyway when adding the second hard drive, the temps seem to increase. So I tried taking out the original hard drive and using just the new 250GB, I cloned the original drive with Ghost. Well the temps were a bit better, 40-42 Degrees C idle and 46 degrees under load. I didn’t notice any system crashes with the single hard drive configurations.
The problem seems to be the lack of air flow in the dual hard drive configurations. The drive on the bottom gets zero airflow causing both drives to overheat. I have since taken the side cover off the case when using the system, but this is a temporary solution at best. Even with the side cover off the drives still reach 50+ degrees C at load. This is just plain old unacceptable.
Dell touted about the new BTX case design and how the cases make the system run cooler. Well they don’t. In fact the drives run hotter in my new Dimension then they did in my old Dimension 8400 with the ATX case design.
“Design
The E510 features the sleek white and silver BTX chassis, which offers great benefits like the front venting area that draws cool air through the computer to help prevent overheating. Having fewer fans in the Quiet Case technology. Chassis also helps ensure that the E510 is quiet, leaving you to enjoy your DVDs and music in peace.”
Admittedly, the case is a lot quieter, but it does not effectively cool the system components besides the CPU. I spent a good 2 hours trying to figure out a way to cool the hard drives better. There is no space above or below to add a hard drive cooler. I even thought about putting 2 small 30-40mm fans in front of or behind the hard drive cage. The problem is that the back of the cage is a solid sheet of metal. I would have to drill numerous holes in it to get airflow moving front to back across the hard drives. The second option would be to put the fans in front of the cage , but there is so little space there it would be impossible. Besides the fact that the main system fan would pull in the hot air thus raising the CPU temp. I am at a loss. I have seen some others suggest external hard drive cases, but that really defeats the purpose of the computer case itself. No one should have to run there hard drives externally because of an apparent flaw in the case design.
This system just turned 7 months old and I wish I could return it for a full refund. I still have over 500 days left on my service contract, but doubt I will keep the system nearly that long. I am open to any suggestions you may have and it would be nice to see some response from Dell, but doubtful.
I tried calling tech support several times to see if they had any suggestions, but they only offered to warranty the hard drive and send me a new one. In the most recent call I explained this would not solve the issue, to Joe in India(na). He also offered to send me another system, but that it would be refurbished. Again, I explained that the issue would still not be resolved since there is a flaw in the case design. Besides that, I paid over $1000 7 months ago and am not going to accept a refurbished system as a replacement. I told him that the system ran okay with one hard drive in it and he then suggested only using one hard drive and not the second one. I asked, Well don’t you sell the same system in a 2 drive configuration? He said yes… Well???? Then he wanted me to describe the issue again for the third time. All this taking up 2 hours of my time as I tried to explain the issue over and over. I was even transferred to sales, for what I still don’t know.
Customer care and tech support were absolutely no help whatsoever. I have had Dell systems for many years, but its time to change. The lack of support and the issues with the new system design are disheartening. I wish I could just get one person at Dell to confirm the issue and tell me that they are taking steps to rectify the problem.
Please post comments, suggestions, and concerns… Hopefully Dell will respond.
I own a Dimension 510, and I am not encountering the same problem. However, I had a similar problem with my other desktop in which its case had similar characterisitics. Usually, the temperature increases depending on several factors, aside from the computer itself: room temperature and the location of the desktop. Although they may seem like irrelevant factors, they are significant. A solution to probably think about is changing the harddrives. You can keep the original HD that's moderately hot OR have double drive configuration; however, replace the HDs with lower RPM (rather than the usual 7200RPM, just use a lower standard 5400RPM) because you're not gaming anyways. The last resort... is to just put your computer near an A/C. :smileytongue:
Thanks for the response. The system is in a climate controlled atmosphere. The temp in the room never goes above 70 degrees F. The system is located on the lower level of an open desk so it has complete air flow from all sides and is low to the floor so it is directly in contact from the cool air vents of my AC. Lastly, downgrading to a 5400RPM drive is not worth it to me. Although I do not do any gaming, I do some web publishing and photo editing. Both of which require a faster speed hard drive. I appreciate your suggestions and they have already been previously considered. Why should I as a consumer have to downgrade to have a stable system? There is definitely a design flaw in the new cases. Greater airflow or a fan dedicated to the hard drive compartment would easily solve the issue.
I have a 5150 that came with a Seagate 80GB Sata drive, I have also installed 160 GB Seagate. Neither drives have had problems, while the have gotten warm, most drives do, I haven't had any issues like you speak of. I use this computer for DVD authoring, video editing, sometimes while playing tunes as well. I have had rendering video files while working with large photoshop files, basically very drive intensive stuff. I would consider 52C under load relatively normal
I also have a system I built myself with 2 Seagates stacked right on top of each other, probably 1/4 inch between them. This is in an HTPC case, the drives get very little if any airflow. These drives run constantly, recording multiple video streams while also playing back video streams. No problems there and I am sure they are, my case types when under full load are hitting mid 50's.
The reason I am telling you this is I think those temps are perfectly reasonable. Now if you are just surfing or using office, you must be have something running in the background, bad drive, or your temp reading is unreliable. I am in an ambient temp of about 72-76 degrees, we keep that AC set pretty high. I do think the case can be a noisy, but it was a relatively cheap system, you get what you pay for. The case itself breathes rather well, stacking drives like that shouldn't be an issue. It takes some work for me to get the CPU fan running full speed. Overall I am pleased with my purchase.
bznguyen
1 Message
947
0
Posted July 26th, 2006 15:00