UNSOLVED

Kellar

updated

19 years ago

K

Kellar

8 Posts

0

1247

April 24th, 2008 08:00

I can handle the truth: Windows or UNIX for NetWorker?

I'm new to a company and have been brought on as a backup admin. Over my 6 months I have become aware of just how badly the infrastructure has fallen into disrepair. We have had a number of minor disasters and now we have full management support to make ANY changes that will make restores more reliable.

Our infrastructure consists of:
1 x NetWorker Server on Solaris (biggest node)
1 x Storage Node on Solaris (big node)
6 x NetWorker Servers on Windows 2000/2003 (Small nodes)

There are lots of changes that need to be made, and a lot of new servers are coming in to replace older servers. Which OS would you go with and why? Here is what I have heard

1) Windows doesn't perform as well as UNIX, and Linux is the best for performance
2) The overwhealming majority of people run NetWorker on Windows, making support for patching and troubleshooting better

What other considerations are there? What OS would you standardize on if it were you and you had as much budget as you needed to bring a failing infrastructure back into line?
  • IKP1

    198 Posts

    811

    0

    Posted April 24th, 2008 08:00

    Hi,


    I would keep the I/O (storage node etc) on the hardware thats best suited for moving data fastest .... if your Sun hardware (normally the best for this task) can drive your LAN/Tapes (SAN) at a suitable speed, then I would keep them on this hardware. Last place I would put Storage Nodes would be Windows (unless they are co installed with applications) and you are backing up application direct to tape.

    Hope this helps

    IKP
  • ble1

    6 Operator

    •

    14354 Posts

    •

    56186 Points

    811

    0

    Posted April 28th, 2008 03:00

    Solaris as backup server is ok. Storage nodes I would say Solaris or HPUX. Funny enough I consider Windows to have less issues than Linux when it comes to backup tasks. As for performance I do not see much difference any more (the only issue is that with Windows Microsoft tend to change things from release to release while in Linux world some backward compatibility is kept at least).

    However, if you are rebuilding your environment, then I would first ask myself what HW does offer me what I need and based on HW operating system would come later.
  • Kellar

    8 Posts

    811

    0

    Posted April 28th, 2008 07:00

    Why would you say that Linux has less issues? I have to say that my biggest gain by going to Windows would be to go into the largest user base. I don't know how to confirm the stat that I heard that 90+% of people are running NetWorker on Windows, but if it is even close to that then it is a no-brainer: more support.

    Any people running NetWorker on Windows for larger implementations? We are looking at about 500 servers here, some file servers are in the 3-5TB range. To be honest, I am looking for any reason to get this off of UNIX, steer clear of Linux, and get it onto Windows. Someone tell me I'm out to lunch here.
  • IKP1

    198 Posts

    811

    1

    Posted April 28th, 2008 08:00

    Hi again,


    As per my previous comment .... you should look to use the hardware that can drive you requirement, also you need to look at what your trying to do ...

    1) NetWorker server - unless your really strapped I would not use this as a general purpose Storage Node, look for system which can manage the environment but does NOT need to drive a large number of tape driver except its own backups

    2) Storage Nodes - this is where the real power of the solution is - firstly look to put really powerful I/O servers with lots of LAN / SAN connectivity -make sure that not only has the external I/O got the power to drive the tapes but that the internal architecture is not a limiting factor. e.g. A couple of high speed LAN connectivity combined with SAN connectivity can soon put a high load on the internal connectivity of a server.

    3) Application Storage Node - you mention 3-5TB fire servers - have you considered connecting these systems to the backup environment directly and installing NetWorker Storage Node licenses. Just make sure you DON'T mix disk and tape on the same HBA.


    IKP
  • dgreggs1

    86 Posts

    811

    1

    Posted April 28th, 2008 08:00

    NetWorker strongest strength since time immemorial has been cross-platform support. The issues you may or not encounter have to do with the OS and administrators experience and comfort level in supporting Servers within his or hers environment. A NetWorker Server is pretty much the same across the build, the differences are not due to NetWorker but to the differences amongst the different Server platforms.

    I run NetWorker on Windows and Linux backing up Linux, Unix, and Windows clients. Operationally for me there isn't a difference between NetWorker Servers.

    I've been using NetWorker since 6.x (what a ride it has been) and have survived and thrived on 7.4.2. For me once I set things up correctly I don't have to touch NetWorker, it just runs. 99% of the time if I have an issue it is either on the clients side or the network side but not NetWorker (knock on wood).

    Whatever OS you choose you'll still want to follow suggestions in the Multi-Platform Performance Guide. If you take notice of NetWorker documentation you will see that most are written as multiplatform documentation. Networker has worked hard to have the same binaries across platforms.

    Just my 2 cents worth.
  • Kellar

    8 Posts

    811

    0

    Posted April 28th, 2008 09:00

    Thanks for the input gentlemen. IKP, I see what you are saying. We are strapped right now and the main NetWorker server handles a pretty decent load.

    We are ordering lots of new hardware and from what I can see the Sun platforms are much more expensive than just plain old x86/x64 boxes. My main concern is about the operating system and support for such; we can build physical infrastructure out in whatever way we want. I see no compelling reason to keep this on UNIX or Linux.
  • ble1

    6 Operator

    •

    14354 Posts

    •

    56186 Points

    811

    0

    Posted April 28th, 2008 12:00

    Why would you say that Linux has less issues?

    I didn't - I said the other way around. The only thing that I find better with Linux with administrative management from OS level. However chasing correct kernel versions and tuning all parameters required to have ideal setup makes it more difficult to handle than Windows at most of the sites. I personally don't like neither Windows nor Linux ]:)