UNSOLVED

swil7581

updated

20 years ago

S

swil7581

1 Message

0

16495

September 20th, 2006 11:00

Dell 2407 is the best monitor I have ever used

I have read so many negative posts about the 2407 that I had to tell you about my experience. I have had the Dell 2407 for about five days. I use it for gaming. I have played Prey, Half life 2, WOW, F.E.A.R and Oblivion on it. I was astonished by how amazing the games look. Everything is so colourful and crisp. I have the rev A02 and as yet I have not come across any banding issues and no ghosts. It is fantastic and I am in love with it and all I can say is do yourself a favour, esp if you are a gamer, and get one.  
  • 2002z06

    15 Posts

    609

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2006 12:00

    I was going to get one but you being the first good reply about that I will still wait.
  • SR45

    2 Intern

    •

    12138 Posts

    609

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2006 12:00

    Good to hear of another happy owner.  Have you tested the monitor using a monitor banding program to see if it can detect it  ? 
     

    Here are some free test programs:

    gradlin-v0.2-fs.exe

    RGB gradient test screens

    Checkemon

    Test screens for solid color, gradients & more.

    Softcare Monitor Test

    Test screens for gradients, solid colors, geometry & more.

    EIZO Monitor Tester

    24 test images for geometry, convergence, brightness, homogeneity and panel response time.

    Dead Pixel Buddy

    Solid color test screens.

    Undead Pixel

    Solid color test screens, pixel flasher.

    Dead Pixel Tester
    Solid color & gradient test screens, pixel flasher & more.

    Nokia Monitor Test

    Test screens for color, resolution, brightness, contrast, geometry, focus, readability, and more.

    NEC Monitor Test

    Test screens for color, resolution, brightness, contrast, geometry, focus, readability, and more.

    Pixel Persistence Analyser

    Tests for pixel persistence (aka 'ghosting') in LCD displays. Interprets user adjustments to test screens, and returns numerical values for Gamma Factor, Transition Time, scrolling text readability and other criteria.

    Passmark Monitor Test (shareware)

    Message Edited by SR45 on 09-20-2006 09:02 AM

  • Litt77

    8 Posts

    609

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2006 14:00

    I love mine also, no banding problems, A02. My laptop does have banding, and even then, it doesn't bother me and is generally not noticeable in most applications that I use (gaming and software development). If I were a graphic professional or photographer, I would probably consider other monitors that tout perfect color replication, but then instead of paying $600-$700, you would be paying close to $5000.

    The thing people have to realize is Dell probably sells hundreds if not thousands of these a day. If you look through the complaint posts, most of them are from the same people over and over. And even then you are seeing complaints from maybe 15-20 people when there are tens of thousands of people that own this monitor. This is not to say people should be happy with a broken monitor, but a lot of complaints revolve around things that are just inherit with less-expensive LCD monitors in general.
  • 2002z06

    15 Posts

    609

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2006 14:00

    I need to know if buying from Dell direct or a private vendor matters? Seen this monitor cheaper from another source other than Dell direct thanks.
  • albumleaf

    15 Posts

    611

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2006 14:00

    Happy AO3 user checkin in, I had one stuck pixel I rubbed out, and that's been it.
  • all the facts

    2 Intern

    •

    983 Posts

    611

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2006 19:00

    Litt 47,

    "love mine also, no banding problems, A02." That's great! I like mine also.
    Please post pics of no banding in dark to light color vertical, horizontal and circular gradients.

    People that want features added, corrected or have res. issues like these below just want to create an even better monitor. Nothing wrong with trying to perfect an already good product form customer feedback. Companies that listen to customer needs and wants come out on top of the sales game.
    The current list:

    (1) The 1600x1200 fixed aspect (1:1) has NOT been fixed. The 1:1 option is still grayed out at 1600x1200. This is not good when you have an ATI graphic card.

    (2) The inability to set 1600x1200 mode into 4:3 is one thing, but having this monitor forget about 4:3 setting is even more annoying. Whenever I run older games or other apps that uses fixed resolutions (such as starcraft, diablo2 etc), I'll have to navigate through the menu and set the 4:3 mode, then when monitor switches back to wide screen resolution of desktop, it seems forget about such setting and makes me navigate the menu to set 4:3 every single time whenever I start those programs.

    (3) Same problem with PIP, input always defaults to S-video no matter what, when I switch to different input (i.e. component) and then shuts pip off, when I turn pip back on it always resets back to s-video.

    (4) Moving mouse over bright backgrounds leaves a shimmery yellow, pink or green trail a few pixels wide on the A02 and A03.

    (5) The whole screen shimmers when scrolling fast.

    (6) Video tearing on 720p over both component/DVI when in 1:1 mode See http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=58435 and http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=62689

    (7) Incorrectly displays 1080i over component giving a usable image.

    (8) Vertical and horizontal banding in multimedia and gaming modes.

    Most of the repeated complaints are Quality Control issues in China and elsewhere, the SPC and DFSS programs are most likely still in an infancy stage of implementation. Something as simple as greasy fingerprints on screens could be corrected with 100% soft cotton gloves but, that adds cost to the process.

    All in all, 2407's competitive price, excellent Advanced Exchanged Warranty, connectivity jack panel, fast LCD makes it one of the best on the market today.

    Good Day!
  • Litt77

    8 Posts

    611

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2006 20:00

    I understand and I have no problem with what you are trying to accomplish. My point is simply there are many people very happy with the 2407 as is and it is an excellent value for what you get.

    I posted these banding pics in another thread, but here they are again:


    http://www.imminentguild.com/vert.jpg

    http://www.imminentguild.com/horiz.jpg

    A02 from China
    connected via DVI to a Radeon x1900xtx

    Message Edited by Litt77 on 09-20-2006 04:26 PM

  • SR45

    2 Intern

    •

    12138 Posts

    611

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2006 21:00

    Yep, Litt77, no banding seen in your two links.    Good to see a good monitor. 
  • all the facts

    2 Intern

    •

    983 Posts

    611

    0

    Posted September 21st, 2006 03:00

    Litt47 wrote,

    "My point is simply there are many people very happy with the 2407 as is and it is an excellent value for what you get."
    If you have read my posts, you know I agree with your statement, the 2407FPW is one of the best LCD's on the market for warranty, connectivity, price, features, etc. Just a few bugs to be worked out.

    That's one of the best A02's (your test patterns) I've seen:)

    It looks like my A02 thru VGA. Same test patterns used.
    My DVI still not so good.

    Both my A02's from China.

    Maybe it's that video card you have, and thanks for adding that info. it helps to know that.

    I'm going to be building a core 2 or quad core soon as the mobo selection widens and will be looking at video cards that perform well with the 2407's and hope it works out.

    Luck of the draw and a lot of variables weighing in on the production of LCD"s.


    Good Day:)

    Message Edited by all the facts on 09-20-2006 11:06 PM

  • 2002z06

    15 Posts

    226

    0

    Posted September 21st, 2006 03:00

    Just ordered mine tonight, hope I'm happy