UNSOLVED

cies

updated

11 years ago

C

cies

3 Posts

1

20046

June 15th, 2015 08:00

XPS 13 (9343) unwanted keyboard character repeat not fixed by A04 firmware update

I wrote this as feedback to DELL after reading this:

www.dell.com/.../EN


This is what I have to say:

A04 does not fix the problem of "character repeat". I've flashed to A04 several weeks ago and the problem persists. Interesting enough I've also noticed this problem with the previous XPS13 model that I owned, and on the DELL support forums I also found users of other XPSes that encounter the issue.

To illustrate my problem: this is with my bluetooth keyboard: asdfasdfasdfasdfasdfasdfasdfasdfasdfasdfasdfasdfasdf

This is with the XPS13 internal keyboard (after flashing to A04): asdfasdfasdfasdfasdffasdfasdffasdfasdfasdffasdffasdfasdf

Seriously this is unacceptable! Sure, it only happens when I type fast; and when I don't use an external keyboard. But this model is marketed as a DEVELOPER EDITION! Developers they type on keyboards for a living.

Major Heyden, who helped with Linux compatibility on the XPS13-2015, finally gave up on this machine. I don't know why exactly but I know that the keyboard really frustrated him too.

Once again: when making a developer edition latop, please make sure the keyboard works really well. The mechanical quality of the keyboard in the 2015 XPS13 is noticeably worse then the keyboard in the previous XPS13 edition.

Currently I'm in contact with the DELL support channel here in the Netherlands, but they seem to be oblivious of the fact that so many have already complained about this. They offer me to pick up the laptop and test, but all other victims of this issue say that this will not resolve the problem.

Here are some links to other pages on the DELL support forums that describe this issue:
http://en.community.dell.com/support-forums/laptop/f/3518/t/19280281
http://en.community.dell.com/support-forums/laptop/f/3518/t/19626873
http://commweb-ps3.us.dell.com/support-forums/laptop/f/3518/t/19627147
http://en.community.dell.com/support-forums/laptop/f/3518/t/19633313

And this is Hayden Mayor's blog on the XPS13:
https://major.io/2015/02/03/linux-support-dell-xps-13-9343-2015-model/


I really hope this issue can be resolved shortly, and for all models.

Otherwise, thanks for supporting (to some degree) Linux on your machines!

  • guido4000

    2 Posts

    746

    0

    Posted August 5th, 2015 04:00

    I have the same issue. A04 did not resolve the keyboard repeat issue.

    I am in contact with the Dell support in the Netherlands, too. But instead of helping me, they tell me I don't have a problem (without ever taking a look at the laptop).

    Here the email I got two days ago:

    Dear Mr. Hoermann,

    Unfortunately my rebook of this has been rejected, the bios upgrade should be the solution, if it is not it has to be escalated. The process of which I have now started.

    Met vriendelijke groet, / With best regards,

    Arjen Steen
    Technical Specialist / Spare Part Sales

    In my opinion it is a pretty bad business practice to negate technical issues in case they are obvious. Delivering malfunctioning hardware and not even trying to fix my problem leaves me wondering about how arrogant a company can become.

  • cies

    3 Posts

    746

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2015 08:00

    I'm running A05 for two days now and can confirm it did not fix the issue. According to many sources on the internet it affects many series of DELL laptops. I also had this problem with the previous edition of the XPS13; when problem persisted into the 2015 edition I got so fed up that now I'm telling everyone.

    I believe a keyboard is kind of essential, especially for a developer edition.

    My contact with DELL support in NL lead to them asking them to take the machine back and test it. I dont go down that route as many have told they will simply give it back telling you nothing is "broken" about. I need this machine for work, so I dont want to  miss it for several day with no avail.

  • ijontichy

    1 Message

    746

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2015 08:00

    In the meanwhile the support page links to the A05 update from July 31st (while the text still says that A04 is supposed to fix it):

    http://www.dell.com/support/home/us/en/19/Drivers/DriversDetails?driverId=YMRTD

    Since the changelog includes "Improved Keyboard behavior" I'm hopeful that this time they got it right...

  • david83

    2 Posts

    746

    0

    Posted August 27th, 2015 15:00

    I barely had the issue with A03 (laptop shipped with it), 'upgraded' to A05 and I have unbearable double key issues, specially double spaces, and also phantom spaces (spaces while typing words and not being even close to the space) but every once in a while I have double letters too, specially M.

    I am tempted to downgrade as I have not seen any other improvement whatsoever with A05, but I still hope Dell will finally get their stuff together and release a real fix for this issue. Not tolerable to fail in something this basic in an otherwise great laptop