
UNSOLVED
Closed
Requesting opinions for how experts/experienced user rate XPS, Voodoo and Alienware systems
I'm on the market for a high end laptop and was looking at the XPS but also am looking at Voodoo PC's and Alienware laptops. I'd be interested in getting any and all opinions of these laptops as well as recommendations for other suitable laptops that I may not know about.
I have usually gone with Dell, but hear repeated comments that Dell customer service has been sliding I was wondering how other customer service departments compare.
How do the systems themselves compare? I see that Voodoo uses 64 bit processors, Is this the direction Dell will be going in the near future? How to 64 bit processors compare with the P4 3.4 and PM 1.7?
I do use my laptop for gaming, but also need the speed and memory for 3D structural engineering programs which require high processing ability (dynamic analysis and mode shape animations of high-rise buildings, etc.).
I also see Voodoo offers the choice of a model with a 17" screen, but not a WUXGA. I utilize CAD software also, so a nice large screen would be quite nice. I am willing to attached a larger secondary monitor for this and just go with the 15.4. Does the DVI output on the XPS allow connection to say a large 23" Apple flatscreen or to a HDTV monitor and have sharp resolution (unlike the S-video connection to TVs that I have seen)?
Thanks in advance for the information and recommendations.
Responses (4)
Solutions (0)
Are you saying that the Extreme Edition model (with the 2 Mb of 3rd level cache) is acheivible with the vanilla XPS by just adding the memory to a socket in the vanilla model? If so this is a nice feature. I see Dell charges 1 grand for this upgrade. If one could do it later this would be a plus. What does this memory cost elsewhere now?
Thanks,
tomale

bioart
13 Posts
631
0
Posted May 12th, 2004 00:00
I got the XPS, (just sent it back to fix a rattling video fan, but that's another topic for later discussion :)
At looked at the other machines and after a bad experience with a VPRmatrix (briefly sold by best buy and now no longer available thus difficult to service) I decided to go with the Dell. The machines are very comparable, though I think the XPS will actually run cooler due to its size and distribution. The WUXGA is amazing. Maybe I would consider the 16" screen, but the 15.4 is good. Processor wise, the 3.4 is and will be more than enough for some time, so I'm not worried about it. I'm however, dissapointed at the fact thjat Intel is not going to keep going with the desktop pentiums and thus the socket will probably change. I'm planning on upgrading my vanilla 3.4 to an extreme in 6 Mo to a year when the price comes down. The fact that it's a socket is useful :)
All in all, the Dell looks pretty good (even compared to the other ones) and They'll be around for some time. You could argue the same about the other systems, but not as strongly as for Dell.
Art