UNSOLVED

enoesque73

updated

20 years ago

Closed

E

enoesque73

27 Posts

0

39643

February 28th, 2006 10:00

Opinions on TrueLife screens for 9400 please?

I'm about to buy a 9400, and I'm finalising my spec.  Before going for a widescreen laptop, I visited some local PC stores to see the resolution and finish on the screens.
 
I thought the Sonys and the HPs screens which are the glossy finish were way too reflective - I could see lots of reflection on the screen, and didn't find it easy to just see the laptop screen.
 
So, my question is, are the 9400 TrueLife screens this shiny?  And is there a problem with reflections?  What do existing 9400 owners with TrueLife screens think of them?
 
Also, I'm used to 1600 * 1200 resolution on my Inspiron 8100 15" screen - is the 1900 * 1200 perfectly viewable on the 9400?
 
Finally, am I right in saying that if I take the next res down from 1900 that the screen isn't TrueLife?
 
Any input very much appreciated.
 
 
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    557

    0

    Posted February 28th, 2006 11:00

    All of the TrueLife screens are very reflective. Some people like them - they do have a large visual impact in a store display (which is likely why you find them on so many models sold at retail).

    Whether they'll hold up in the long run is open to question - they'll also show dirt, dust, fingerprints and scratches easily.

    If you are happy with the UXGA you have now, the WUXGA should be fine resolution-wise; it's a True Life screen though. It looks like the base screen (WXGA) is stnadard, coated (non TrueLife).
  • enoesque73

    27 Posts

    557

    0

    Posted February 28th, 2006 11:00

    Thanks for your response.
     
    I was in a shop looking at the glossy screens, and I could see the reflections of various lights in the shop, and displays behind me, reflected on the screen.
     
    I could really do with the 1900*1200 res, but I'm not sure if the glossy screen will be a put off?
     
    Does the screen reflect badly under normal use, like at home, if there aren't lots of lights nearby or behind?
  • Excrazymac

    94 Posts

    557

    0

    Posted February 28th, 2006 13:00

    don't base the resolution bump on the TrueLife screen. they aren't a VERY big distraction.

    some people don't like the glossy look, but others think it makes it sleeker. essentially you get a bit more contrast for a little less portability. you probably won't want to try and use it in the sun.

    indoors, you're fine. the 1920x1200 screen is a lot more real estate than the 1440x900. you are probably better with the 1920x1200 if you're ok with the 15" 1600x1200 screen. it's just wider.

    1440x900 doesn't have truelife.
  • enoesque73

    27 Posts

    557

    0

    Posted February 28th, 2006 14:00

    Thanks Excrazymac for your input.

    I will rarely, if ever use the laptop outdoors - it'll mostly be indoors.

    And I'm fine with 1600*1200 - I'm a programmer, so for various reasons I like this resolution, so the folk who don't like the 1900*1200 haven't put me off it for this reason.

    It really is just the glossy screen that I'm concerned about - especially if it reflects too much other light.

    Any other opinions?

  • Maverikva

    121 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted February 28th, 2006 21:00

    Well, I have to jump in here... I upgraded to the Truelife screen and am moderately disappointed with it.  It is reflective, yet the colors don't look nearly as vivid as those I've seen on the HPs.  If I were to do over my purchase, I would not have upgraded to Truelife.  Also, the display is quite bright and I have to turn the brightness down otherwise it gives me a headache.  I expected better quality as well - it's obviously much brighter toward the bottom of the screen than toward the top.  The higher resolution is nice, but I would definitely trade it for one less reflective; I find the reflections rather annoying.  I've only had my E1705 a few days though and perhaps after more time adjusting to the display my opinion will change.
  • Cpt_Jack

    17 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted February 28th, 2006 22:00

    I like the TrueLife screen on my E1705.  It was the one upgrade I wasn't sure about until I received the laptop, but now that I have it, I'm very glad that I did not go with the other screen.  The screen is definitely more glossy than that on my 9100 but not as much as other brands I've seen at computer stores.  I'm a software developer as well, and I love widescreen displays because I don't have to break lines of code as often, which I think makes the code much more readable.  This display is truly great to look at.  I usually use it at one step below maximum brightness (which conserves a little battery, too) and it's plenty bright enough.  I find that the reflectiveness of the screen is not at all distracting to me.  I'm sure it's a very individual preference, however.

    As a side note, I was extremely disappointed with this screen when I first turned my E1705 on.  It took me about ten minutes before I realized that Dell had shipped the laptop with the brightness set to about level three of eight!

  • enoesque73

    27 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted March 1st, 2006 06:00

    Thanks for your opinion Maverikva.

    So far, you're the only person who's responded negatively in this thread.

    You say

    > I find the reflections rather annoying.

    Are you working in a very lit area, with lots of lights above and behind you, like in an office, or is this at home?

  • Maverikva

    121 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted March 1st, 2006 09:00

    It's much more bearable in areas without overhead lights.  Also, if you have the brightness turned up the reflections are much less of an annoyance, but if you're running on battery power this may be an issue.  For me, it's not as I usually am on AC anyway. 

    Again, I've only had it only a matter of days and am still adjusting.

  • -Friendlyname-

    2 Intern

    •

    858 Posts

    656

    0

    Posted March 1st, 2006 10:00

    Does anyone fit in this category?

    I wonder if wearing contact lenses makes the glare worse.  I have more trouble with glare generally and steered away from the true life.

    Jane

  • davy19

    18 Posts

    1006

    0

    Posted March 1st, 2006 18:00

    I have seen both a friend had WUXGA reflective, and after about 30 minutes I would get a headache it looks nice at first, but if you going to be using for long hours as primary PC...it not good for the eyes I dont think, and I have perfect vision, dont need glasses

     

    I went with WXGA on my 1705 and quality is superb and wife complains I am on too much

    Message Edited by davy19 on 03-01-2006 02:46 PM