UNSOLVED

kentiler

updated

9 years ago

K

kentiler

10 Posts

0

2102

October 20th, 2017 12:00

Dell needs to have a recall on the Inspiron 5547 Right Hinge Issue

My daughter went to use her laptop last night for homework, and by just opening the screen, the right hinge broke away from the laptop.  In research this issue, I've many people have had the exact same issue.  This laptop has not been dropped or abused.  When a hinge breaks under very light use - she uses it about 5 times a month - there is a problem with this design.  In every case I've seen - it's a hinge issue with the right one.  I called Dell, but they said it would be a cost to repair it.  This is crazy - it's clearly a defective design!!!!

There is a pretty long thread here, but it's closed:
http://en.community.dell.com/support-forums/laptop/f/3518/t/19622428?pi41097=4

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    1214

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2017 13:00

    It actually isn't.  Most people are right-handed and raise the lid single-handed (instead of using both hands, or in the center as it's designed to be raised).  That puts torque on a part not designed to handle it -- which is why the hinge mount will crack.

  • kentiler

    10 Posts

    1214

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2017 13:00

    A laptop that has been opened/closed no more than 150 times - whether opened 1 handed or not - is not well built!  This is a poor design.  

  • gruss

    10 Posts

    1214

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2017 18:00

    I had the same problem last year. Dell initially agreed to fix under warranty but I had to ship it to them and would be without it for 10 business days. I found the upper case on the internet for $35 and replaced it myself in an hour. I determined the problem is that the hinge nuts were over tightened when the laptop was built which puts extra stress on the screw mounts when opened and closed. The hinge screws into metal inserts pressed into the plastic which cracked. I loosened the nuts a good half turn making sure the lid would stay up opened half way. I have now had the laptop longer than I did when the hinge mount broke with no issues.

  • kentiler

    10 Posts

    1214

    0

    Posted October 21st, 2017 05:00

    Without opening the case, I'd say the lower case is the issue.  When I push the hinge back in to where it should be, you can see the screw is still there in the bottom of the case, but it's still attached to the hinge.  If we leave the laptop open, I think it will be OK.  We just can't open/close it anymore.  Not much point of having a laptop then, though.