UNSOLVED

fbarwell

updated

22 years ago

Closed

F

fbarwell

23 Posts

0

11865

July 21st, 2004 18:00

8600 -vs- D800 -vs- M60 -- How can there be such a price difference?

Hey gang,

I just compared these 3 systems using Dell Canada's web site.  I set the 3 systems up as identical as I could.  Would you believe that the M60 was almost $1000 more than the D800??

Configuration as follows:
Intel 745, 1.8gHz
WUXGA screen
XP Pro
1gb RAM (2 sticks)
60gb 7200 hard drive
128mb video
Intel 2200 wireless
Port replicator (m60 comes with a c/port II)
Bluetooth adapter
3yr onsite complete care

The biggest difference was video cards on each:
8600:  ATI 9600
D800:  NVidia GeForce 5650
M60: NVidia Quadro FX 1000

The only other credible difference was the D800 didn't have a DVD writer. (wasn't shown as an option).

The prices you ask?
8600:   $4696
D800:   $4243
M60:  $5209

So what gives?  The 8600 doesn't even have the parallel, serial, or IR ports anymore and it's still more than the D800.  Am I missing something?

  • 336

    0

    Posted July 26th, 2004 22:00

    The M60 has a workstation class video card which adds about $1000 to the price, easy.

    The D800 does not have a DVD writer but that usually only adds about $200 so I don't know where the other $200 went, perhaps extra included software as the 8600 is a consumer model whereas the D800 is a business model?

  • 336

    0

    Posted July 27th, 2004 15:00

    Support for more OpenGL instructions in hardware.
    Optimized drivers for specific OpenGL applications, i.e. Lightware, Maya, ArcGIS.

    Generally a gaming card is tuned for...games.  Most games do well with just a limited set of OpenGL instuctions in hardware and the rest can be handled by software.  An applications such as Lightwave requires a lot more hardware support, thus the increased price.

    If you're purchasing the laptop for gaming then I would not recommend the extra epsense of the Quadro family of cards such as found in the M60.

  • fbarwell

    23 Posts

    336

    0

    Posted July 27th, 2004 15:00

    Just a followup on my own original message... I've learned that the D800 has slower memory that the I8600.

    A "workstation class" video card?  What makes it so special that it's worth $1000 more?

  • TDunn

    379 Posts

    336

    0

    Posted July 27th, 2004 18:00

    My D800 runs PC2700 (333MHz) memory at speed.
    Currently the D800 does offer both 4X and 8X DVD+RW.
    The original Go4200 ran games better than the Quadro Go700 I tried.
    Now I have an ATI 9600 and it has worked fine....no problems.................TD

  • FatBelly

    57 Posts

    336

    0

    Posted July 28th, 2004 13:00

    TD, can you please confirm that I understand what you said - that the D800 will run PC2700 RAM at 333MHz?  I am currently using the standard 266MHz RAM modules, and I understood from what I had read previously that although you could fit PC2700 modules in the D800, they would only run at 266MHz.  If your memory is running at 333, do you need to hack the system in any way to get it to run at speed, or does it simply happen automatically?  Are there any FSB or other pipeline bottlenecks in the D800 that negate the advantage of the extra speed?  Is the difference in RAM speed noticeable?

    Sorry to throw so many questions at you!  Thanks in advance for any answers.

    FatBelly

  • TDunn

    379 Posts

    336

    0

    Posted July 28th, 2004 20:00

    I was able to swap memory with an M60.  I did nothing but put it in and go.
    IMO the cost isn't justified to replace the PC2100 only for performance increase.
    The best advice I can pass along is to get a stick from Crucial and try it.
    You can return it if you're not happy with the outcome.
    There are some posts in the Latitude forum regarding some systems running at
    speed and others that don't. 
    Now.....I have to confess.....my MB was replaced with an M60 MB that was to be flashed to a D800 bios.  I didn't let the tech do it.
    I am now basically running my D800 with the guts of an M60 and the ATI 9600.
    I have had no problems. 
    I use my system for large and small venue shows and meetings and I trust it as much as any computer can be trusted to perform.
    The M60 I have has a P-M 1.4 and the PC2100 memory. 
    It encodes WMV faster than my 1.6 D800......however.....the M60 doesn't have nearly as much loaded on it and I think that has a lot to do with the performance. 
    My D800 also has a 7K60 (7200RPM) vs. the 40GB (5400RPM) in the M60. 
    So I'm convinced that the kitchen sink I have loaded in the D800 adversely affects performance.

    BTW.....the 700M looks very interesting......I have an X300 on the way but I might have to swap for the new Inspiron.......

    ...................TD