
UNSOLVED
Closed
O
onefromthesky
3 Posts
0
21873
May 10th, 2004 09:00
8600 Motherboard Fault
Hi,
I have had my Inspiron 8600 for just under 48 hours and have noticed that it will periodically not turn on correctly. The three lights will light up (Num Lock, Scl Lock And CAPS) then after about 7 seconds it will power down without doing anything. Now I would consider myself quite knoledgable on PCs after ripping everything out of the laptop and even using different RAM, it still did the same so after readiing the forum and discovering other people had teh same problem I boiled it down to a motherboard fault.
I have a couple of questions,
1) many people seem to be having this problem, so what is dell doing to create this problem in the first place, anybody with this problem just post here to get an idea on numbers.
2) Does anybody know what the problem is, is it a hardware problem or bad coding of a chip, im just curious. I thought that it was maybe a BIOS problem and so flashed with tha latest A08 BIOS (O the difference).
3) I have already sent the laptop back to dell after setting up a return, thanks to the helful lady at the end of the telephone. I also didn't send them the HD or the DVD-RW drives, do you think this would be a problem for them?
4) I have the legacy porst on the back of my system, presumably this would mean that I have the 8600 and NOT the 8600c, other than the legacy ports, what is the difference between the two systems?
5) Finaly, I know it shouldn't be here but it saves another post, the graphics card. I have a friend who has a 1.4 Pentium M with the 5650 in it. I have the 1.7 with the 8600pro in it but my system only makes another 500 3dmark 2001 marks at 9750 (all updated drivers etc etc), I was expecting more maybe 11k? How do these to graphics chips compare to each other, I haven't had a chance to fully test my laptop but is the 8600 better in the "field" compared to the 5650?
thanks in advance
Responses (7)
Solutions (0)
onefromthesky
3 Posts
218
0
Posted May 10th, 2004 10:00
No I didn't order it as a refurb, however, i do come from the UK so maybe that makes a difference? I shouldn't think so, I do hope that when they do send it back I still have the legeacy ports though, Il be most upset if they give me the new "c" chassis and board!
I thought that the 9600 should be better than the 5650 all along, but as I have a better processor I would have thought that the performace margin would have been larger, never mind, Im happy anyway as It does run all of my games perfecly well.
Another thought, how long do poeples batteries last, mine lasts just ofer 4:10-4:20 minutes, if I play it right, which i thought was pretty good really.
thanks
- 1) Keep in mind that ony people with problems post on this borad, soit seems when browsing through this board that every Inspiron has a problem.
2) Don't know, didn'r have this problem
3) Many people do so, so there should be no problem.
4) Interesting that you still got the "real" 8600. Did you order it as a refurb? The 8600c doesn't have serial, parallel, IrDA and the trackstick. Till now, there is no known advantage over the 8600 (chipset revision numbers and so on).
5) The Radeon 9600PT and the Geforce 5650 get almost the same 3dmark2001 scores. The 5650 gets 2570 in 3dmark2003 and the 9600 gets around 2850 in 3dmark2003. The real advantage of the 9600PT can be seen in newer games like FarCRY where it performs better (compared my i8600 with a friend's i8600 1.7 Radeon9600). OpenGL performance should be roughly the same with both cards. I can reassure you that the 9600 is better than the 5650. MightyMack
95 Posts
218
0
Posted May 10th, 2004 13:00
My brand new (ok 13 days old) 8600C had the same problem...read http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_general&message.id=155473
and http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_general&message.id=155266
The tech rep worked on the lines of it being a Win XP problem rather than a Mobo problem and made me go through the hoops (change power management settings, remove all items from startup etc) before giving up and transferring me to the Advanced OS support dept. There the people told me that I would have to pay for this support ! So I setup a return and back it went.
I know it cannot be a OS problem, I am thinking a BIOS or Mobo problem.
- At last I seem to have found something that works. I switch the laptop on and leave it for 5 minutes or so in it's un-booted state (only fans and HDD seem to run). After 5 minutes, switch it off and immediately back on again. Works just about every time, but still not a proper fix.
onefromthesky
3 Posts
218
0
Posted May 14th, 2004 10:00
got the machine back the other day, turned out to be a graphicsd card fault, so they rpelaced the graphics card and all seems well.
So its obviously not a mobo fault wich we all thought it was!!

mikewi
20 Posts
218
0
Posted May 10th, 2004 10:00
I have an Inspiron 9100 suffering the exact same problem with booting. Dell support are arranging for the motherboard to be replaced (luckily it's covered with an on-site contract). Interestingly they didn't have to think about it for too long, which implies that it's either
a) a standard first step in solving any problem, or
b) a common fault with motherboards not receiving sufficient power.
What I don't understand is this: why did this problem occur a couple of days into use? No hardware has been added which would be started as part of the boot sequence and therefore increase power demands. That implies that the motherboard develops a fault all by itself. I also don't understand why this is an intermittent problem, and why it seems to boot more reliably on battery - surely the sequence of powering up components at boot is the same regardless of the power source?
Does anyone have any ideas?