
UNSOLVED
S
shdbcamping1
475 Posts
0
11801
August 13th, 2008 13:00
XPS420 vs XPS630i some advice...
As owner of both, I believe that there is no difference other than price!
1. For those that are VERY tech savy, the 630i may provide you with some exciting challenges.
2. For those that are not... the 630i has the opportunity to provide you with challenges that you probably don't want!!!!! It's still maturing and Dell will probably figure it out(caveaut) depending what they decide to advertise.
3. For those that are "very" tech savy but want a "shoe-in" out of the box. Give it some time to "Mature"... see #2 above.
In My Opinion... If you have to buy now, choose the Dell XPS420 as you can get tons more for the money without the ?????'s. For those that can afford to wait, WAIT and see if the 630i can be fixed without the ??????'s.
Either way I would, even after my miserable experience with the 630i, choose Dell (and DID). Apparently there are 630i's out there that customers are happy with. It just didn't happen with mine and/or many others if you are following this forum. So, go a comparable "safer" and cheaper bet (XPS420) or "Roll the Dice". Dell made it right for me, It just wasn't a ride I wanted when I bought a Brand New Computer!!!!!
Sean
Responses (7)
Solutions (0)
Sean
Appreciate your post, I am debating either a 420 or 630.
What is it exactly that you prefer about the 420 over the 630. I've read problems about the lights, 8x/16x etc but this is the same as the 420 ie. the 420 doesn't have lights and is 8x.
Can you give me some input as ot other differences/advantages as im leaning towards the 630tia
shdbcamping1
475 Posts
248
0
Posted August 15th, 2008 14:00
malik999,1. The XPS420 is hundreds less than the 630i when comparably equipped.2. The XPS420 is X16 mode for the graphics PCIe slot. 630i is X8 mode maximum. I was only planning on single GPU with the multiple GPU cards coming out. Without X16 mode for single Graphics card, extra cost not worth it.3. The XPS420 performs much better than the 2 630i's that I had before I decided on a refund for the bad advertisments.4. My XPS420 is flawless out of the box so far. Both my 630i's required countless attempts at installing/uninstalling drivers that came out seemingly daily.5. The overclocking never worked on either of my 630i's so that portion of it's advantage over the 420 was mute. ESA seemed to be my culprit. Again extra cost 630i, not worth it.6. Nvidea ESA wreaked havok with multiple parts of my system running the same software that worked flawlessly for years on my old Dell DIM8200. Internet connection, Optical drives, virtual drives.7. The LightFX was a neat selling point for the 630i. Without it extra cost not justified.7. The kicker.... ZERO hours in system maintenance with XPS420. Hundreds of hours before I called it quits with the 630i.My point is 420 has better performance in my opinion having had both systems. The 630i has potential but not close to a sure bet yet. If you get a "problem system" you are not going to be in a "Happy Place" (had to use that ELK sorry for the infringement :smileysurprised: ). If you don't have to buy a system right now, wait to see if the 630i will ever become better quality assured. ALL my old software and games are flawlessly loaded and played on my 420.See number one above. You don't know what you'll get yet with a 630i.Hope that helped.Seandontexpectmetob
100 Posts
248
0
Posted August 16th, 2008 01:00
Check this out and make your own decision :smileyhappy:
- and the xps 420 has a later intel chipset, x38 i believe, vs the older chipset that the xps 630i has, nvidia 650i...but the xps 630i is stanard atx,,,which would weigh heavily in my decision to buy,,,since you supposedly can replace the motherboard. its too bad dell did not use the 680 chipset,,,but that would have cut into the high end sales i quess on other models.,,Message Edited by ronss on 08-16-2008 03:38 AM
shdbcamping1
475 Posts
248
0
Posted August 16th, 2008 07:00
OK... again,
*************************************************
My point is, the 420 has better performance in my opinion having had both systems. The 630i has potential but not close to a sure bet yet. If you get a "problem system" you are not going to be in a "Happy Place" (had to use that ELK sorry for the infringement
). If you don't have to buy a system right now, wait to see if the 630i will ever become better quality assured. ALL my old software and games are flawlessly loaded and played on my 420.
*************************************************I am not saying that there are not satisfied 630i customers out there. They post here a lot. They try to underplay the fact that the 630i has had and still has reliability problems by saying that their system works fine. Many of them have already made hardware changes to their systems, and thats fine if that's what a consumer wants to do with a Brand New Computer.It's a tough economy. I'm trying to warn potential consumers of the other side of the reliability Happy Coin, in case they are simply looking to buy a computer that has investment stop with the delivery of their system. For those computer buyers: Wait on the XPS630i or get an XPS420 now. I have had both and have been on the "Tails you Lose" side of the reliability Happy Coin with 2 (that's TWO 630i systems). I have a 420 now and so far am on the "Heads I Win" side of the happy coin.I'm sure that it's time for anotherb "I'm a 630i Happy Coin" poster to chime in AGAIN, and AGAIN, and AGAIN.....Seanshdbcamping1
475 Posts
248
0
Posted August 16th, 2008 13:00
ronss wrote:***********************************************and the xps 420 has a later intel chipset, x38 i believe, vs the older chipset that the xps 630i has, nvidia 650i...but the xps 630i is stanard atx,,,which would weigh heavily in my decision to buy,,,since you supposedly can replace the motherboard. its too bad dell did not use the 680 chipset,,,***********************************************Valid point added ronss. The X38 chipset is supposed to be NextGen ddr3 MOBO ram ready although I have not yet seen any x38 board posts that say it does in all actuality. The 680 chipset is another good point as to... If it was in my 630i I would probably not have had a reason to send it back. I don't think the 680 board would have required another MIO board... but I never researched that board that deep.Thanks ronss :smileywink:Sean

player8
145 Posts
248
0
Posted August 14th, 2008 11:00
You are "rolling the dice" with any electronics. That is how it is. The thing is that some brands and models tend to be better than others.
I'll agree that the 630 was rolled out prematurely, but i think that anyone getting it today would have less of a headache, than 5 months ago. And those getting later in the year should have even less of a problem.
Maybe this will be a learning experience for dell to hold back a release until all the kinks are worked. (doubt it)
:smileytongue: