UNSOLVED

Feorod

updated

22 years ago

F

Feorod

10 Posts

0

16638

October 10th, 2004 21:00

nVidia Quadro2 64M vs AGP Card 2X 64M

Hi all,

I have a nVidia Quadro 2 64M card in my Dell Precision 410. I tried to install Prince of Persia and this video card seems not to be supported. I checked to buy a 128M card, but I am learning that this Dell AGP slot is 2X and that new cards have to be at least 2X compatible... Moreover, I learned (from the clerk at FutureShop) that most 128M AGP cards start at 4X...

Questions:

Am I stuck forever with a 64M 2X card ??

I cannot figure out if the nVidia Quadro is PCI or AGP...!!!

If it is PCI, is it true to say that a 64M AGP card would be much more faster than the PCI equivalent ???


Thanx in advance for your enlightning answers..

Eric, Quebec
  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2004 06:00

    The Radeon 9800 Pro Card Works Just fine in the 410. They go for about $199 at Newegg.com The Minimum card that Works would be a Geforce FX5200. They go for about $50 at Newegg.com The Radeon 9800 Pro is about 4 Times Faster with the 410 than the Geforce FX5200. POP will run on a 5200 but it will be VERRRY SLOWW.
  • Feorod

    10 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2004 12:00

    Hi again,

    Thanx for the quick answer man. But, the specs for the Radeon 9800 ask for a motherboard with minimum 4X AGP slot. Let me remind you that the Dell 410 motherboard has a simple 2x AGP slot..

    Have you inserted a Radeon 9800 in a Dell 410 ?? Did it work ??

    I want to believe..!

    Eric
  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted October 12th, 2004 01:00

    Let me remind you that I HAVE a Dell precision 410 with Radeon 9800 pro INSTALLED. I also Have a Precision 610 also with Radeon 9800 pro installed.

    I wouldn't tell you something works If I havent Tried it Myself.



    <ADMIN NOTE: Broken link has been removed from this post by Dell>



    The biggest hurdle here is the 300 vs 200/140/110/85 watt power supply.
    You cant use a 9800 pro in a small system Like a GX150 or GX270.

    They work fine in the 410 or 610 but only run at AGP 2X
    2x/4X AGP runs @ 1.5 Volts so a 9800 PRO will only run at AGP 2X when used in these older systems. 1.5V AGP cards are usually backwards compatible with older 2X AGP slots on 440BX and 440GX motherboards.

    .8V is the voltage requirement of new 8x AGP cards utilizing AGP specification 3.0. Motherboards supporting 8x AGP support both 1.5V AGP 2.0 compliant cards (AGP 4x) and newer .8V AGP 3.0 compliant cards (AGP 8x). The keying for AGP 3.0 cards is identical to that of AGP 2.0 cards to retain backward compatibility. A motherboard that supports 8x AGP should work fine with a 1.5V (AGP 4x video card), and a motherboard that supports 1.5V (AGP 4x) video cards should work ok with a .8V video card (AGP 8x), however in the later example the video card would only work at the fastest speed the motherboard supports (AGP 2x/4x).

    AGP 1.0 cards run at 3.3v and will not FIT into the AGP 2.0 slots.

    (Gorillas have been known to FORCE 1.0 cards into the slots killing the motherboard.)

    Forcing an AGP 1.0 3.3V card into a 1.5V motherboard tends to eat the board.

    Another look at the confusion is in the table here:

    http://www.ertyu.org/~steven_nikkel/agpcompatibility.html

    Speed is always backwards compatible,
    for example, a 4x device must be able to run at 2x and 1x.


    The signalling voltage is the only incompatible part.


    An 8x device must be 0.8v,
    a 4x device can be 1.5v or 0.8v,
    a 2x or 1x device can be 3.3v or 1.5v.


    The connectors are keyed so that you can only use compatible equipment.
    AGP 1.0 and 2.0 devices using a 1.5v key, signal at 1.5v,

    while AGP 3.0 devices using the 1.5v key and signal at 0.8v.


    AGP 3.0 devices must be tolerant of 1.5v signalling though, they won't necessarily work,

     but will not be destroyed if inserted into an AGP 1.0/2.0 slot.

    Forcing and AGP 1.0 3.3V card into a newer motherboard WILL destroy it.

     

     

     

    Message Edited by SpeedStep on 10-12-2004 04:36 AM

  • Feorod

    10 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted October 12th, 2004 12:00

    Hi again,

    Thanx for the explicit reply. I am NO expert on video card and thought 4X or higher AGP card couldn't even be plugged into a 2X AGP motherboard (such as the Precision 410's).

    Here I see it is possible and viable.

    I'll think about this possibility... but given the price of all this, I must admit I'm considering buying a XBox system for my gaming needs...

    Thanx a million again...

    Eric
  • kmeal

    3 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted April 3rd, 2005 06:00

    What's not explictly made clear above is that your Precision 610 MT, even though it has a 2x AGP slot, it's probably a 3.3v slot (mine is - found out the hard way after I bought a 6600 GT and the cards aren't even physically compatible).  For the AGP 2.0 or 3.0 cards (ie 4x and 8x) to work in the motherboard, even downgraded in speed, my understanding is that your AGP slot has to be 1.5v & 2x..  The motherboard in my Precision 610MT is 2x but 3.3v..

    Cheers,

    Kerry.

    Message Edited by kmeal on 04-03-2005 01:53 AM

  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted April 3rd, 2005 15:00



    @Feorod wrote:
    Hi all,

    I have a nVidia Quadro 2 64M card in my Dell Precision 410. I tried to install Prince of Persia and this video card seems not to be supported. I checked to buy a 128M card, but I am learning that this Dell AGP slot is 2X and that new cards have to be at least 2X compatible... Moreover, I learned (from the clerk at FutureShop) that most 128M AGP cards start at 4X...

    Questions:

    Am I stuck forever with a 64M 2X card ??

    I cannot figure out if the nVidia Quadro is PCI or AGP...!!!

    If it is PCI, is it true to say that a 64M AGP card would be much more faster than the PCI equivalent ???


    Thanx in advance for your enlightning answers..

    Eric, Quebec

    A Radeon 9800 Pro Works OR a Geforce FX5200 or FX5500 AGP works fine.
    I started with the Geforce FX5200 and changed to the Radeon 9800 Pro because the 5200 was a bit too slow.

    http://www.pcmall.com/pcmall/shop/detail~dpno~167866.asp

     

  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted April 3rd, 2005 15:00


    @kmeal wrote:

    What's not explictly made clear above is that your Precision 610 MT, even though it has a 2x AGP slot, it's probably a 3.3v slot (mine is - found out the hard way after I bought a 6600 GT and the cards aren't even physically compatible).  For the AGP 2.0 or 3.0 cards (ie 4x and 8x) to work in the motherboard, even downgraded in speed, my understanding is that your AGP slot has to be 1.5v & 2x..  The motherboard in my Precision 610MT is 2x but 3.3v..

    Cheers, Kerry.


    The Geforce FX6600 Series cards are about 4 years newer than the 9800 pro.
    I have used Geforce FX5200 and FX5500 and Radeon 9000,9100,9200,9800 Pro in
    both a 410 and a 610 and they work just fine and dandy.

    I prefer the Radeon 9800 pro due to its 380mhz gpu vs 250 or 270 for the Geforce FX 5200/5500 series.

    It turns out to be about 33percent faster than the others at AGP2x.
    I'm Not sure why you find that .8v cards being non workable in 1999 motherboards
    that have AGP 1X/2X Not AGP 4X/8X slots. That said the Slot In some
    boards is what they call universal so the cards just go in. Putting a .8v card
    into an AGP 2.X slot is a recipie for a fire.

    Motherboard           Key(s)     Speed(s)                  Voltage(s)
    AGP  3.3v                3.3v              2x, 1x                      3.3v          (Early 440LX motherboards)

    AGP  1.5v                1.5v         4x, 2x, 1x                     1.5v           (Geforce FX5200/5500)
    Univ AGP                 none       4x, 2x, 1x             3.3v, 1.5v
    AGP  3.0                  1.5v        8x, 4x                            0.8v           (Geforce FX6600)
    Univ 1.5v AGP 3.0   1.5v        8x, 4x, 2x,             1.5v, 0.8v           Radeon 9800PRO
    Universal AGP 3.0   none       8x, 4x, 2x, 1x        3.3v, 1.5v, 0.8v

    Not all manufacturers use Keys. Thus the confusion as to what fits in what slot and what works.

    Message Edited by SpeedStep on 04-03-200512:57 PM

    Message Edited by SpeedStep on 04-03-2005 12:58 PM

  • kmeal

    3 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted April 4th, 2005 10:00

    I'm not sure how you get a Radeon 9800 pro or Geforce FX 5200/5500 series to actually work in a 610 motherboard.. Are they 3.3v cards?
     
    You're dead right in all you said above, but my point is that the AGP slot in the 610 MT I've got is this one:
     
    AGP  3.3v                3.3v              2x, 1x                      3.3v          (Early 440LX motherboards)
     
    and it is explicitly keyed to 3.3v, so I suspect a 1.5v keyed card won't even plug into it..
     
    I'm guessing I've got an earlier edition motherboard than the 610 you're using.
     
    (And yes I avoided frying a .8v card when I took my old card out and looked at the AGP slot & realized it was 3.3v)..
     
    Kerry.
  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    518

    0

    Posted April 17th, 2005 22:00

    The only 3.3V exclusive cards are AGP 1.0x

    Most modern motherboards that are 2X/4X/8X are 1.5V video because that is REQUIRED for most newer boards like the 845,850,865,875 AGP 4X SLOTS.

    Again stop annoying me saying that it doesnt work. IT DOES.

    Tested and running and this goll darn message posted from the 610 with a 9800PRO
    RETAIL ATI CARD installed.

    These are cards that I am running.

    One clue is that the 9800PRO has Directx 8.1 drivers. Thats how old it is.
    Early powermac G4 systems had AGP 2X max and a mac version of the 9800PRO is what was used in them. The only diff between the MAC and PC version is the BIOS on the video card.