UNSOLVED

JayLynn

updated

22 years ago

J

JayLynn

2 Posts

0

10702

October 10th, 2004 22:00

Dim 4600 sticky list of rec. cards

The GeForce FX 5700 is listed as ok for the Dimension 4600. I need a cheap replacement for the integrated audio and ordered the 5700LE. Now I'm worried that the LE has some important difference that will render it useless for the 4600, ie. dimensions, interface, etc. I don't know enough about the technical aspects to wade through the specs for both models and figure it out. Is the LE ok for 4600 too? 
  • B4runo

    1 Rookie

    •

    1100 Posts

    271

    0

    Posted October 10th, 2004 22:00

    FYI:

    I printed and strictly followed the respective Video FAQs.  It sometimes seemed tedious, but the results were worth it.  Taking a peek at the LCD monitor after hooking up the digital output was startling in comparison.  If you are going that route, don't forget to download the correct monitor driver from DELL. 

    Good luck,
    B4runo
     
  • B4runo

    1 Rookie

    •

    1100 Posts

    271

    0

    Posted October 10th, 2004 22:00

    JayLynn:

    I understand your question.  Unfortunately, I don't know the tech aspects either.  I do know that I recently researched that card and couldn't find what the "LE" means either.  I recently purchased and installed a FX5700LE card, and have been satisfied so far.  I have had it in and running for 4 days and no problems.

    Good luck,

    B4runo

    DIMM 4400
    BIOS A06, date 6/12/02
    Win XP Home Edition, SP2
    Pentium4 2.0AGHz
    1 GB DIMM RAM
    80 GB 7200 RPM Ultra ATA Hard Drive
    Iomega 80GB External HDD
    XFX GeForce FX 5700LE 128MB DDR 8X AGP w/ TV & DVI
    17", 1702FP Digital Flat Panel Display
    Belkin F5U508 USB 2.0/Firewire PCI card 

  • JayLynn

    2 Posts

    271

    0

    Posted October 10th, 2004 22:00

    B4runo - it looks like I bought the identical card, hoping I'll have the same results you have. We shall see in 2 days. Thanks for the quick response.
  • Thirdrockfromsu1

    1 Rookie

    •

    366 Posts

    271

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2004 00:00

    B4runo...Do get back to us on that subject.  I sent my ATI 9600 XT back with issues and am now thinking of the new Nvidia 6600 GT ( AGP version ), but would like to know if your new card is better than my Ti 4200 ( Nvidia ).

     

    http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-145-091&depa=1  This link will take you to the spec's on your card at Newegg.com
     
    SR

    Dell Dim 4400 ( Purchase June 2002 )
    2.6 ghz (Upgraded from 1.7 ghz)
    400 Mhz bus
    768 Mb DDR 2100 Ram
    Windows XP Home SP-2
    Gainwards Nvida Ti 4200 128 mb video
    Roadrunner Cable modem
    17 Inch Dell 1703 FP monitor
    15 Inch NEC 1560 NX LCD
    Dell sound bar for monitor
    AVG 6.0 Version 773
    Bios A06
    250 watts mean average p/s ( 345 Watts Peak )
  • B4runo

    1 Rookie

    •

    1100 Posts

    271

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2004 00:00

    Thirdrockfromsun:

    Here is a paste quote from Tigerwolf 7 about the 5700LE:

    "Unfortunately it's really hard to find benchmarks of the 5700LE, especially ones that also include a Geforce 4.

    That said, the Geforce 4 should be quite a bit faster. The 5700LE is an underclocked version of the normal 5700 (both the core and memory clocks are slower). The clock speed should be the same as the Geforce 4 (250mhz…although my Geforce 4 4200 came clocked at 275mhz). But the Geforce 4 has double the pixel pipelines of the 5700. 4x2 versus 2x2 on the 5700. On top of that the Geforce 4 has faster memory-probably over 500mhz versus 400mhz on the 5700LE. Some 5700LEs have 64-bit memory interfaces, which make them even worse.

    (I'm assuming you're looking at that XFX card on Tigerdirect for $59. I can't find info on that anywhere as to whether the memory interface is 64-bit or 128-bit. XFX doesn’t even say on their site...so the safe guess is that it's probably only 64-bit, which would end up giving the Geforce 4 effectively more than double the memory bandwidth.)

    The 5700 is a newer design of course, so it can probably do some things more efficiently (like anti aliasing, memory bandwidth usage, etc.), but those advantages are overshadowed by the massive performance benefit the Geforce 4 starts out with by having double the pixel pipelines and more memory bandwidth. The 5700 also has PS 2.0 support while the 4200 is limited to PS 1.3, but realistically the 5700LE is going to need to run the same code as the 4200 (or lower) to keep performance up, so it’s not really a benefit.

    So anyway, the Geforce 4 should definitely be the better buy of the two. You can’t beat the performance it’ll give you for less than around $150ish.

    Just to warn you though, all cards in that general class (Geforce 4/5600/5700, Radeon 9600) are starting to show their age on the newest game engines like Doom 3 and Farcry. They’ll definitely run them, but nowhere near full settings. But like I said, to do significantly better you’d really have to spend $170 or more to get into the Geforce 5900 range.

    For a quick performance comparison, here’s some Doom 3 numbers with a Geforce 5700 Ultra and a Geforce 4.

    http://www20.graphics.tomshardware.com/graphic/20040809/doom3-04.html

    The 5700 Ultra is around 40% faster than the Geforce 4, and a 5700 le is (at best) around half as powerful as an Ultra, which would make the Geforce 4 a little over 40% faster than a 5700 le at Doom 3. Much more if the 5700 le only has a 64-bit memory interface.

    Message Edited by tigerwolf7 on 09-22-2004 07:43 PM "

    This was a post from a thread I started inquiring about my then planned video card upgrade, emphasis added.  I was looking at the Geforce4 Ti 4200, but it was clearanced out before I could get back and pick one up.  I think I would have preferred a Ti 4200 like yours.  I will keep you informed on the 5700LE.  I do know that it certainly was a dramatic improvement over the stock card that came with the system, over 2 years ago.
     
    B4runo
  • Thirdrockfromsu1

    1 Rookie

    •

    366 Posts

    271

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2004 00:00

    B4runo...Do get back to us on that subject.  I sent my ATI 9600 XT back with issues and am now thinking of the new Nvidia 6600 GT ( AGP version ), but would like to know if your new card is better than my Ti 4200 ( Nvidia ).