UNSOLVED

biggieb

updated

22 years ago

B

biggieb

8 Posts

0

6518

December 10th, 2004 03:00

6800 256MB vs. X800 XT 128 MB

I just ordered another 8400 today. I ended up going with the regular 6800 with 256mb of memory. My question is my brother has a 128 MB X800 XT that came in his XPS. Which card is faster? Is it a big increase either way? Any info. would be greatly appreciated.
  • 547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 08:00

    Look at this test results charts from Tom's hardware,
    Most of the tests go fot the X800XT 256 MB....i am not sure if there is a 128 Version..
    But never heard about the 128 MB ver..
     
    The new GeForce 6800 Ultra and GT cards with PCI Express are running at the same clock speeds than the AGP versions: 400/550 for the GeForce 6800 PCIe and 350/500 for the GT
    The X800XT Core/memory is 500/500...when overclocked reaches a bit further.
     
    So comparing the the 6800 to the X800XT......the X800XT rocks
  • Airblazer

    251 Posts

    547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 11:00

    the X800XT is 1000/500 while the 6800Gt is 900/500
  • spainolator

    125 Posts

    547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 15:00

    The difference is biiig,in favour of x800xt. It has 256MB of memory,not 128,and it's much better than the 6800 dell sells,since it's a gto(overclocked 6800nu). Differences are:

                                                  nVidia 6800                        Ati X800xt

    Pipelines                                       12                                   16

    Clocks                              Don't really know...                 500/1000

    Performance...                     3000 marks                       5500 marks

    I'm basing on 3dmark05. 6800gto is much worse in everything compared to x800xt,which doesn't mean 6800gto is a bad card. All the way round,it's a very good card that will run games really well. Enjoy it, what matters is gaming not the specifications. Just go&play with it,best way to see how good the card is.

  • ZeviB

    7 Posts

    547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 16:00

    How come the X800 is not presented as an option when I configure a new Dim 8400?

    Also, please see another question in a new thread ("GeForce 6800 GTO and IEEE 1394 conflict")

    Thanks,

    Zevi.

  • tigerwolf7

    2 Intern

    •

    3906 Posts

    547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 16:00

    Okay, big problem here.  There is no such thing as an x800XT with 128MB.  He's either got an x800XT with 256MB, or if it really has 128MB, then it's an x800se.

    The Geforce 6800 is better than an x800se, but worse than an x800xt.  The x800xt is a much more expensive card though, so that's not surprising (<$300 retail versus >$500 retail usually).

  • tigerwolf7

    2 Intern

    •

    3906 Posts

    547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 17:00

    Dell used to offer the x800se, but seems to have replaced it with the Geforce 6800, which is a better card.
     
    I think when they first started offering the 8400 they also gave you the option of buying an x800xt, but people were literally waiting MONTHS for their systems to ship with that card.  It could be limited availability is why they don't let you configure the 8400 with the highest end cards from Nvidia or ATi (they'd want to leave them for their highest end system first).
     
    You had to pay hundreds more for the x800XT when it was available.
  • biggieb

    8 Posts

    713

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 20:00

    Again though I was trying to compare the 6800 not the 6800 GTO or whatever it is.
  • The_Man42

    415 Posts

    547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 20:00

    heh I waited for my X800XT in my 8400, It's essentially an XPS in an 8400 case, I ordered in July and got my system at the end of August, I wasn't going to pass up the deal I got, plus part of it was processor availability at the time.
     
    you'll need a special code to get an X800XT in a D8400 now, which are usually tough to find, the only place I've seen them are in custom high end configs used in PC mag. to compare the system to other high end systems.
  • biggieb

    8 Posts

    547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 20:00

    Hmmm. I thought he did have a 128 mb X800 XT but maybe it is the SE version. So the 6800 with 256 and a p4 3.0 with 1 gb ram would do what in 3dmark03? What about the X800Se?
  • spainolator

    125 Posts

    547

    0

    Posted December 10th, 2004 20:00

    Same as The_Man42...got it when I saw it...just worse cpu than him though...