lividllama

updated

9 months ago

L

lividllama

1 Rookie

•

6 Posts

0

41758

September 17th, 2021 05:00

WD19 dock changed monitor resolution

I've had an Inspiron 7580 and a WD19 dock working for the past 18 months connected to 2 monitors, one ultrawide 2560x1080 (connected using displayport) and one 1920x1080 (using displayport to DVI adapter). Yesterday, after working undocked for a while and plugging the laptop back in, the second monitor started being recognized as only 1280x1024.

  • There was no driver updates that I recall, and in any case I reverted to an system restore point from the previous day.
  • My wife has almost the same setup (same monitors, but her dock is an WD15, so the second monitor is connected through VGA). My laptop works on her docking station. Her laptop presents the same symptom connected to my docking station.
  • I also tried swapping the problematic monitors, so the monitor itself is not the problem.
  • If I disconnect the large monitor, the smaller one starts being recognized properly.
  • Finally, the light on the docking station's power button seemed a little dimmer than I remember, so I tried swapping the power brick, but the problem persisted.

Again, this is a setup that has worked for 18 months.
I thinking it's a hardware problem, but  a very specific one (everything else on the docking station works), so I'd like to check if I'm missing something before calling tech support.
Thanks!

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    21292

    0

    Posted September 21st, 2021 06:00

    @lividllama  You're of course free to think what you want, but I've dealt with many of these exact threads of people using an HBR2 system with a USB-C dock and having trouble running a 1440p+1080p setup.  Here is the page from the WD19 User Guide indicating that with an HBR2 system, your dual display max is 1920x1080 60 Hz.  (Dual 1920x1200 60 Hz works, but Dell doesn't seem to acknowledge that less common resolution.)  Unfortunately Dell's specs for the system don't identify the specific DisplayPort revision it supports, but if you do some research, you will find that Intel only introduced DisplayPort 1.4 support in its GPUs with Core 10th Gen "Ice Lake" CPUs, but not Core 10th Gen "Comet Lake" GPUs, and then Core 11th Gen "Tiger Lake" CPUs.  You have a Core 8th Gen CPU.  Yes, you have an NVIDIA GPU, but if you check Windows Display Settings > Advanced, your display will be indicated as being connected to your Intel GPU.

    Dropping the resolution won't necessarily free up bandwidth because Windows 10 distinguishes between the "desktop resolution" and the "active signal resolution".  Essentially, changing the resolution in Windows Display Settings now just causes Windows to render at a lower resolution, but the actual signal on the wire is still running at the display's native resolution.  The GPU scales up the image rendered at a lower resolution up to the display's native resolution.  There are some advantages to this, such as avoiding a brief black screen when you change resolutions (because the display doesn't actually see a resolution change anymore) and being able to run sub-native resolutions even on the handful of displays on the market that don't have a built-in scaler chip and therefore wouldn't be able to do that otherwise.  But one of the drawbacks to that approach is that lowering your resolution doesn't free up bandwidth.  However, I believe that at least on some systems, changing the resolution inside Intel Graphics Control Panel (or Command Center) does change the active signal resolution.  So if you haven't tried that, give it a shot.

    Otherwise, I get what you're saying that it worked before, but I also suggested that it may have been because one or both of your displays had been running below the standard 60 Hz refresh rate, which would also reduce bandwidth requirements.  I suppose you could try doing that too if you decide that it's an acceptable setup for you.  Good luck.

  • lividllama

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    23834

    1

    Posted September 21st, 2021 14:00

    For the record in case anyone has the same problem.

    I was messing around with my monitor's menu and for some reason had enabled FreeSync on it. That had no immediate effect, so I forgot completely about it. BUT when I undocked and docked back, the monitor would not go below 60Hz anymore when connected through DisplayPort. That was what caused the OTHER monitor to change resolutions.

    Thanks again @jphughan for giving me enough information to not only solve the problem but find out the original culprit.

  • XPS_Man

    7 Practitioner

    •

    2448 Posts

    •

    11950 Points

    19855

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2021 11:00

    18 Months = Dock is Out of warranty 

    Clearly the issue is with the dock,  you have 2 Display ports on dock and I believe you have swapped the cables in between already . You have also tried connecting one monitor at a time.  ??? 

     

    Only thing you can attempt is to update the firmware of dock, there was a new firmware released 2 months ago. 

    <ADMIN NOTE: Broken link has been removed from this post by Dell>

     

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    19848

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2021 12:00

    @lividllama  If you were able to run that display setup from that system, then it's likely that one or both of them was running below the standard 60 Hz refresh rate.  The Inspiron 7580 uses a Core 8th Gen CPU, which means it runs DisplayPort HBR2 over USB-C, not HBR3.  As noted in the WD19 User Guide, when running a dual display setup from an HBR2 system, you're limited to 1080p (technically 1920x1200 works, but Dell doesn't seem to account for that less common resolution in its documentation).  Running 2560x1440 only works when that's the only display connected.  Those all assume the standard 60 Hz refresh rate.  You might be able to get both displays running at their native resolutions by manually dropping the refresh rates in Windows Display Settings, although sub-60 Hz refresh rates aren't always an acceptable experience.

  • lividllama

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    21321

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2021 12:00

    Hi,

    Yeah, I've swapped the cables, forgot to add that to the list.

    I checked the firmware but it was already updated.

    Connecting one monitor at a time works, which is the most bizarre thing to me (seems that the bandwidth capacity of the dock decreased). When connecting only the small monitor it works. When I connect the large one the small one stops working properly.

    I'm going to contact technical support and ask for a replacement. Glad I got the 36 months warranty.

    Thanks!

  • lividllama

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    21298

    0

    Posted September 21st, 2021 04:00

    Thanks @jphughan but I don't think that's the case... as I said, I had it working flawlessly for 18 months. Also, i didn't touch anything. I unplugged from the dock, spent 15 minutes working away from it, and when I got back the monitor was disconnected.
    Also, I tried lowering the resolution of the large monitor and the small one still isn't recognized properly.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    21292

    0

    Posted September 21st, 2021 06:00

    @lividllama  One more page of interest for you from the WD19 User Guide might be this one.  That indicates that a 1440p+1080p 60 Hz setup requires 8.8 Gbps of bandwidth (5.6 + 3.2).  As noted in the notes above that table, an HBR2 system has an effective data rate of 4.3 Gbps per lane, and on a regular USB-C, non-Thunderbolt dock, there are two lanes allocated to video, giving you 8.6 Gbps of bandwidth -- just a bit short of what you need.

  • lividllama

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    21284

    0

    Posted September 21st, 2021 13:00

    Actually now I think you're right @jphughan. I connected again to my wife's WD15, and the large monitor is running at 50Hz there. So probably there is the bandwidth issue. BUT something has changed, because before Thursday night both my and her computers connected without issue on both docking stations, and since then both are unable to set the large monitor* to 50Hz. So I guess I'll see if the replacement does any difference.

     

    *Reminder, we both have the same pair of monitors. The large one is not quite 144op, it's 2560x1080. Not sure how that changes the math.

     

    P.S. I hadn't touched the large monitor because it was not where the issue was presenting itself, but I decided to connect it with an HDMI instead of DisplayPort cable and everything worked.
    Internal monitor on 1920x1080 60Hz
    LG Ultrawide on 2560x1080 50Hz
    Dell D2216H on 1080x1920 60Hz
    So it seems that something in either side of the LG monitor DisplayPort connection is not allowing the refresh to go to 50Hz (I couldn't find a way to set it manually and when it's connected through DisplayPort the option for 50Hz does not appear).

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    21280

    0

    Posted September 21st, 2021 13:00

    @lividllama Interesting find.  2560x1080 only requires 75% of the bandwidth of 2560x1440, so that plus dropping to 50 Hz may have been enough to get you under the bandwidth ceiling.  I guess I could do the math by starting from the table in that WD19 User Guide site that shows bandwidth requirements for certain resolutions and refresh rates and then multiplying by appropriate decimal values to scale up or down to the particulars of your setup, but I'll leave that to you if you're curious.  In terms of why 50 Hz isn't available over DisplayPort, did you even check the Intel Graphics Control Panel rather than just Windows Display Settings?  If it's not available even there, that might be a limitation of the drivers, or the dock firmware in terms of what refreshes it passes through from the display's EDID, or a difference in what the display sends in its EDID on different inputs.  Whatever the cause, the reason might be that 50 Hz would be more likely to be used over HDMI anyway because at least some European countries use 50 Hz for video rather than 60 Hz because their AC electrical grid runs at 50 Hz rather than 60 Hz, and back in the days of CRT TVs, watching 50 Hz video on a TV plugged into 60 Hz AC power or vice versa would not have worked well.  And that's why European DVDs are sometimes encoded in 50i (interlaced) rather than 60i as they are in the US.  With modern technology it isn't an issue, but inertia and legacy are powerful forces.

    But in any case, I'm glad you've got a setup that works for you.  Just be aware that video that was actually shot at either 30 fps or 60 fps may not appear quite right when viewed on a display that's refreshing at 50 Hz, because in the former case the 30 fps video frames won't map cleanly onto a 50 Hz display, and in the latter case you have that problem AND the fact that the display isn't showing the content as smoothly as it could be presented to begin with.  Then again, we've had this problem for a while with film that gets shot at 24 fps, which doesn't map cleanly onto a 60 Hz display either, which gave rise to the solution called "3:2 pulldown".  Probably more information than you needed and maybe more than you wanted, but hopefully at least some of that was interesting!

  • lividllama

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    21278

    0

    Posted September 21st, 2021 14:00

    That's very interesting, thanks for the information!

    Still I wonder why it worked over DisplayPort, on both computers, until last week... but now I'm thinking it may be a problem with the monitor, not with the docking station. Anyway, after work hours I'll try to connect my docking station to both her monitors to check.

    In any case I marked you early response as a solution, because I definitely got it working based on that (even though I'll still try to work out a root cause).