UNSOLVED

kcoect

updated

20 years ago

K

kcoect

23 Posts

0

48417

November 15th, 2006 00:00

Anyone have some honest opinions about "Free" anti-virus/spyware tools?

I'm curious because I've heard different stories about the various "free" tools that exist out there.  I know that the tools like Ad-Aware and Spybot are good for passive scans of machines, and HiJack this is good for gathering in-depth information, but what free tools (or relitavly in-expensive tools) exists out there that can provide adequate protection of a PC?
 
I have a number of friends who work in the IT field, one continually states that the "AOL Free anti-virus and anti-spyware tools" have actaully very good for his business because he's constantly cleaning up things that it misses.  In addition, he kind of feels the same way about the free tools that are built into everyone's toolbars that are getting installed all over the place recently.
 
I also subscribe to Consumer Reports Magazine and tools like AVG are in the top 10 tools, it was only 7 or so in the list.  My own personal experience has shown that the free tools are good, but if you really want to effectively clean a machine, you should get something like Spy-sweeper for spyware, etc.
 
So, what is the real consensus on "free" tools for anti-virus/spyware?  If money wasn't an option, which anti-virus or anti-spyware tool would you get?
 
Thanks!
 
Kevin Coe
 

Message Edited by kcoect on 11-20-200611:13 AM

  • zbestwun2001

    4 Apprentice

    •

    8831 Posts

    891

    0

    Posted November 15th, 2006 01:00

    I use AVG7 and it has done me great!!

    zb1
  • RoadiJeff

    1158 Posts

    891

    0

    Posted November 15th, 2006 02:00

    I personally use the ones listed below (all free).  Been using them for about a year and they work great.  Also, here's a link to a detailed review of two free AV utilites written recently by one of the forum regulars.  Avast vs AVG
     
    Lavasoft Ad-Aware Personal (antispyware)

    Spybot - Search & Destroy (antispyware)

    Avast! Home Edition (antivirus)

    ZoneAlarm Basic (two-way firewall)
     
  • europa303

    1 Rookie

    •

    4428 Posts

    891

    0

    Posted November 15th, 2006 03:00

    Kcoect, as to anti-spyware software you may want to read this recent review: http://www.pcworld.com/article/id,126890/article.html
    and for internet security suites this: http://www.pcworld.com/article/id,125857;page,1/article.html
  • joe53

    5 Journeyman

    •

    5772 Posts

    •

    17269 Points

    891

    0

    Posted November 15th, 2006 07:00

    Kevin Coe:
     
    "If money wasn't an option, which anti-virus or anti-spyware tool would you get?"
     
    If money were no object, I would get exactly what I already have, as indicated below. (They all happen to be free, but that is not why I chose them).
     
    Why? Because they get the job done with a minimum of hassle, they all co-exist nicely, and they don't hog memory or slow down performance. I have paid for and used several of the other big-name AV and AS programs in the past, and ultimately dumped them when they failed me in one or more of the above criteria- usually because of performance or hassle issues.
     
    Most of the website comparisons you will see of AV programs rank them mainly according to detection rates (as did Consumer Reports). The free AV's (AVG and avast!)  don't get top billing, yet I have used and continue to recommend either. Lab tests are one thing- the real world is another. So how do I know AVG (or avast!) are not missing infections? Apart from the fact my system doesn't exhibit symptoms of infection, I have regularly scanned with the "leading" AV online scanners (Kaspersky, Bitdefender, for example) which have never detected anything.
     
    I use the same logic with my anti-spyware. If  "second opinion" online scans from Trend-Micro's Antispyware, or from Panda's online ActiveScan don't detect anything, I assume my free AS apps are doing the job.
     
    That said, I'm just an average user without state secrets or sensitive data to protect, trying to stay out of trouble. If security were paramount, my choices might well be different. I also practice "safe surfing", don't open unknown email attachments, don't use file-sharing programs,  don't visit risky websites, and have configured IE  and OE to protect my system. Those that engage in risky behaviour (present company excepted, of course!) might well be better served by some of the top-ranked paid apps.
     
    I have, however, paid for one defense- a hardware firewall that came with my router.  Even though I use a standalone PC, it is one expense I never regretted.
     
    (Incidently- why the link to the gift site?)
     
    _______________________________________________________

    My essential (free) defenses:

    - avast! antivirus v.4.7
    - ZoneAlarm firewall v.6.1.744.001
    - Windows Defender (Final release) Resident Anti-Spyware
    - AVG/ewido anti-spyware v.7.5  (demand anti-spyware/anti-trojan scanner)
    - a-squared Free 2.0 (demand  anti-spyware/anti-trojan scanner)
    - SpywareBlaster v.3.5.1  (blocks bad activeX installation)
    - MVPS Hosts file
    - BillP's WinPatrol v.10
     
  • ky331

    5 Journeyman

    •

    15640 Posts

    •

    45086 Points

    891

    0

    Posted November 15th, 2006 14:00

    Rather than repeating any products already mentioned above (several of which I use), let me mention one additional free scanner:   
     
     
    This is a relatively new program, that's rapidly gaining in popularity.   The only "downside" is that the scanner takes a long time to run (relative to most others), but that's likely because this scanner attempts to be more thorough than the others --- it seems to catch & fix a rather wide array of spyware.   And its author,  Nick Skrepetos, is very receptive to comments/suggestions from the public, participating in many user forums. 
     
    In fact, this program is a recent addition to Spyware Warrior's recommended list:

     
    Note:  The free version does not offer resident/real-time protection.

    Message Edited by ky331 on 11-15-200611:17 AM

  • kcoect

    23 Posts

    891

    0

    Posted November 15th, 2006 15:00

    You can call it a force of habit, the gift site is acually something my wife has wanted to do for a very long time and I just kind of paste it into my signature just about everywhere I go...  She's done a neat job with it and I always kind of think "what the heck", you never know what you may find on the Internet and where you may find it :).  To be honest, I just copy and past in the signature and since it was a little late at night, I didn't even think to take it out (which I've done with this post)...
     
     
    Thanks for all the info guys, I'm going to try some of those other free tools tonight when I get home!
     
    - Kevin
     
     
     

    Message Edited by kcoect on 11-20-200611:14 AM

  • Hoot

    31 Posts

    892

    0

    Posted November 16th, 2006 14:00

    Add mcafee free SITE ADVISOR to warn you of bad sites. Worlks great.
  • zbestwun2001

    4 Apprentice

    •

    8831 Posts

    892

    0

    Posted November 16th, 2006 19:00

    If you are comfortable with that good, but I don't recommend that.

    Live One Care is only free for 90 days then you have to pay.

    It also includes Windows Defender.

    Running you system with no AV is like running thru a Rose Garden naked and hopeing you don't get stuck by a thorn. Personally I would rather be dressed and protected just in case a thorn has the idea of sticking me.

    zb1
  • brian_pwnz_you

    1 Rookie

    •

    96 Posts

    892

    0

    Posted November 16th, 2006 19:00

    well if ur an experienced user u dont really need any of that i dont use antivirus or spyware or nething i have windows xp media center with xp firewall enabled with all the updates installed from microsoft but if i do feel the need to do a scan i just use windows live one care and i just did a  online scan and came up clean but if ur xp is legit id recommend you to try this online scan its good and has other tools with it heres t he link http://safety.live.com/site/en-US/default.htm
     
     
    Xps 400
    2.8 pentium d core
    1gb ddr2
    80 gb sata
     
  • brian_pwnz_you

    1 Rookie

    •

    96 Posts

    968

    0

    Posted November 16th, 2006 19:00

    the online scan im talkin about is free forever no 90 day period thats only if u install windows live one care and have it running.