UNSOLVED

AppliedVisual

updated

23 years ago

0

43097

August 21st, 2003 14:00

SDVD6004 Frustrations - Dell incompetence & More

This is going to be a lengthy post - lots to say. 

I purchased (nearly 2 months ago) an Inspiron 5100.  Everything seemed to be great, had no problems until last week when I went to burn a DVD+R.  I produced a coaster.  Since I had previously burned more than 15 DVD+RW discs without a problem using Sonic Foundry's DVD Architect, I shrugged this off and tried another -- same result.  Now I'm a bit puzzled, so I restarted the system and tried again with a different software - the junk myDVD software that comes installed on the system.  Same result, the drive loses track of the disc media part of the way into burning the disc and aborts.  I thought I had a bad bunch of discs, which was hard to believe as I was using Verbatim 2.4X +R media and 3 in a row were "bad".  I tried burning a Ritek 4X, a Fuji 4X and a Memorex 4X, all with the exact same results.

I call Dell tech support and they tell me it's a software issue and I was inclined to agree because the DVD+RW discs burned just fine (or so I thought).  I had hoped that Dell's software support would have some insight, but it turns out all they could recommend was to install all the latest updates (which I had already done).  After talking to 3 different support people, one of them found someone else at software support who had heard of my problem and knew of it happening to a few others.  Their advice was to check the forums here and contact tech support again about the problem.

So I visited the forum here...  Wow.  Tons of people having this very problem or something similar.  So I checked my firmware with Nero's info tool that comes with Nero 5.5.  I have the 0.99 firmware that some people believe to be the problem.  I contacted Dell tech support and couldn't convince the tech that it wasn't a software problem - he finally just got rid of me by transfering me to software support when I was in the middle of a sentence.  ...Real professionalism there.

I re-contacted tech support (this time spent more than an hour on hold) and got a different tech.  Once again, I received no help and was basically told that I must be doing something wrong.  After nearly 30 minutes of the tech repetitively suggesting that I double check that my battery isn't low when I write a disc and that the disc is properly snapped into the drive while he fumbled through knowledge base articles, he finally just told me his shift was over and he had to leave.  He transferred me to another tech, but I sat on hold with no answer for another 15 minutes and finally just hung up.  At this point, I was ready to kill so I waited until the following morning to call back.

So the next morning, I call back.  I speak with another tech and this time around I actually get someone who has heard of this problem!  But he didn't know anything more than some users were having trouble writing +R media and occasionally CD-RW (which I had not tried).  So he gave me some callback information to reach him directly and more quickly and sent me off on my way to test all the media types I could on the drive and also to make sure the discs were all readable in another system, if I could.  Strangely enough, I hadn't got around to writing any CD-R/RW discs on this system and haven't had time or a need to read those previous DVD+RW discs I wrote in another unit.  Turns out that only my insprion 5100 will read the CD-RW and DVD+RW discs it creates, nothing else will!!!  CD-R discs seem to work fine and are compatible on several of my systems. 

I took this info and got back to this tech, still had to wait on hold for nearly an hour, but I did get directly to him.  I gave him all the information and he basically said "that's very interesting" and asked me to hold while he got someone else.  Another tech answered, who must have been a tech supervisor or something.  He was friendly and seemed fully aware of this issue.  He said, Dell will send me a replacement drive and it will fix my compatibility issues with writing CD-RW and DVD+RW media so I can read them in other systems.  So I asked him if they knew why the drive does not write DVD+R..  To this he replied that Dell's DVDRW drives do not support DVD+R media.  I of course pointed out to him that it was supposed to, it's advertised to do so and Dell even sells +R media to go with these drives.  He just ignored my statement and said my drive would ship out that day via Airborne Express.  ...That was yesterday.

So I'm now awaiting Airborne to deliver my SDVD6004 replacement to see if the new drive has the updated firmware (which, BTW, nobody in tech support knew anything about).  Perhaps it will, perhaps it won't, but hopefully a new drive will fix my problems.  If not, my next step will be to demand Dell either fixes the problem or refunds my money...  I bought a Sony notebook two weeks before this Dell unit and it writes DVD+R and all other formats just fine...  Their new model also supports DVD-R/RW in additon to +R/RW, which would simplify a lot of things, since of my two desktop systems with DVD burners one uses a Pioneer DVD-RW and the other has a Sony DVD-RW|+RW.  I'm very tempted to just demand a refund and buy the Sony.

Additionally, I have been doing a lot of other research on the net and it seems that this SDVD6004 drive unit from Philips is an OEM product only and even at that is only being used by a couple select vendors.  The other major vendor besides Dell happens to be HP.  There's a lot of HP customers who have notebooks that can't read or write +R or other formats properly. 

The big question I have is how is it possible that a drive like this passes Philips' own quality control testing?  Obviously it did...  And even with that, how is it that such a drive also passes testing and qualification for use by Dell and HP in their products?  Obviously, nobody thoroughly tested this drive before electing to use it mass assembly of new systems.  If this problem is this widespread, how come Philips hasn't made a firmware update available to their OEMs yet?  Or if they have, how come HP and Dell are not making it available to their tech support people and even their customers?

One final note to Dell-BobT.  I'm not sure what your relationship is to Dell other than you're moderator of this forum.  But I do have to say that your robotic, canned posts are of little help and will often waste people's time.  If these posts are automated, then perhaps I can forgive a little.  But when people post with these issues and you simply thank them for using the form and send them to look for software updates and firmware updates that don't exist, it's not helpful or productive.  This is of course all my opinion, but when a problem is as serious as this and has such a high occurance as this, perhaps the moderator could be a little more helpful and refer users to a specific thread where it has already been discussed.  And if you are truly an affiliate or employee of Dell, wouldn't it be beneficial to everyone if you were to notify tech support that there is a serious problem with these drive units and there are lots of people who would like a fix.  I imagine that there's tons of people lurking this forum who have these problems, but don't say anything.  They just quietly wait in the back and hope that someday soon that firmware update will be posted for download.  A couple years ago, there was a serious issue with a drive controller on some PowerEdge systems... Lots of people having problems, but no real help or information from Dell.  The forums were peppered with the issue like this one here and the moderator gathered all the related posts to that problem and gave them to tech support.  Suddenly tech support was aware of the problem and a fix was available within a week or two.  If the right people in tech support get the information, things will get fixed.  For some reason problems don't get identified nearly as quick when random customers with problems phone in and tech support overlooks a real issue by fixing it with a replaced drive.  In the end, fixing the issue properly will save both Dell and their customers time and money.  I don't intend to overstep any boundaries or tell you how to do your job, but I do believe that the function of a forum moderator is to do more than post generic, canned responses and play the role of cyber-nanny when someone uses profanity, which the forum software does automatically...  It wouldn't even let me refer to the SDVD6004 drive by the "c" word that rhymes with "wrap".

For those of you that have read this far into the post, thanks for reading and I hope all of you with this or similar problems with the SDVD6004 unit will share your experiences with getting the problems fixed.  ...Good or bad experiences.  I will post a follow-up when I receive my replacement drive (hopefully today, otherwise tomorrow). 

  • rob983

    20 Posts

    473

    0

    Posted August 21st, 2003 17:00

    Good job AppliedVisual,

    I too, am sick of the goof-ups by Dell. They have sent me a replacement 5100 & a replacement drive for a combined total of (3) 6004 drives and I still have the same problem. I've called tech support so much that they hang up on me now, So much for Award Winning Support!

    The last time I talked to them they said that they would send me a email with a link for the firmware update. 

    that was two days ago.

    DUDE! you got a DELL!

    (yeah right!) 

  • 473

    0

    Posted August 21st, 2003 23:00

    Well, here's an update...

    Airborne delivered the new drive this afternoon and I installed it.  I immediately went to Nero's InfoTool and saw that the firmware revision was still v0.99.  So no updated firmware on this drive....

    Anyway, I then just went into myDVD and loaded the simple project I had created, which nearly fills a DVD (short by about 250MB).  I clicked burn and let it start writing a DVD+R...  And to my utter amazement, it finished without error!!!  The disc was perfectly playable in 3 separate PCs and two DVD players I tried.  So I then wrote a DVD+RW disc with the same project and now this +RW is a usable disc in the other PCs that can read +RW that couldn't read the discs produced with the old drive.

    I'm going to work with it more tomorrow and write another couple +R discs and re-do several of the +RW discs I had written before.  I'm also curious to see if the +RWs I had produced before (that wouldn't read in anything but this Inspiron system) will still be readable on this new drive.

    So, FWIW, the problem so far does not seem to be related to the drive's firmware.  I'm more inclined to believe that these drives are exceptionally fragile and if it works fine now, how long will it be before it quits?  Will it take a small bump or vibration to damage this unit? 

    Extrapolating from what I know about CDR/DVDR technology and my engineering background, I'm willing to bet that if the firmware is indeed not the problem, that the real problem is a defective, damaged, or mis-aligned laser or lense mechanism on the drive.  The laser has to focus in a different manner for CD-R/RW and DVD+R/RW formats.  Perhaps this is why it would write one, but not the other and the servo tracking would get out of wack when writing a +R because as it moved outward from the center of the disc, it would increasingly be writing in the wrong place - if the lense was just ever so slighly out of alignment.

    Either way, the Philips SDVD6004 is a very frail unit.  This is was very obvious when swapping the drive out.  And it looks like it is a quality control nightmare just from my own experience with the unit and the number of similar complaints here.

    ...I'll post another update after I work with all of this some more.

    - Jeff

     

  • Richacon

    1 Message

    473

    0

    Posted August 22nd, 2003 05:00

    Well said AppliedVisual,

    I can relate to everything you said in your post. I have gone through the same incredible journal that you have. It is incredible how much of a "pass it on" attitude Dell reps have and at times showing extreme incompetence. I have wasted literally hours on the phone speaking with technical telephone reps about the Philips DVD drive. I have to date not burned any DVD's. I have used MySonic DVD, Pinnacle Studio and Roxio software. Uninstalled and reinstalled software. Reading other posts on this site I have also tried different DVD disc manufacturers (Sony, Memorex, Fuji). Still no burning. I finally received a response to my last e-mail from two days ago. I explained the situation completely in this e-mail that I can not burn a DVD - response that i received was directed to a CD-RW drive FAQ and upgrading Roxio 5. Needless to say I explained in my e-mail that I have Roxio 6. Anyway quite dissappointed with Dell's award winning service. Not sure what i can do next.

    Anybody have any suggestions? Ideally I would like to send the drive back and get my money back, but it has been over 30 days for return. I guess continue to deal with a never-ending story.

    So much for Dell!

     

  • 473

    0

    Posted August 22nd, 2003 15:00

    Since my last post, I have burned two more +R discs without error and have burned two +RW discs without error.  Attempting to read the suspect +RW discs written with the previous drive has proved to be a futile endeavor.  In fact, all the discs appear to be ruined as neither this new drive from Dell, nor my other +RW drive can make sense of them.  They still do get recognized as +RW media, so it may be possible still to reformat or blank them out, but it will take some work as I get a media error with the badly written discs.  I'm more inclined to just toss them.  But all seems to be well with the new drive.  I am however, somewhat concerned about its durability and longevity.

    I contacted Airborne Express so they could pick up the defective drive for return.  I told the lady at Airborne that I had a return ship label for some defective computer parts.  She said "Is it going back to Dell?"  After I answered, she said that they have been seeing an unusually high amount of returns back to Dell lately and I was at least the 10th caller she had herself this morning with a return pickup going to Dell.  ...I thought that was somewhat interesting.

    For now, all I can recommend to others who still have problems with the SDVD6004 drive unit is to keep pounding on tech support for replacements until you get one that works.  Maybe they'll start to acknowledge there's a serious quality control issue here.  If you have a service contract with on-site support, you're in better shape because you can always request to use the on-site service option.  That way they can send a tech out who won't be able to figure it out and then maybe you'll get somewhere.  That was going to be my next approach -- to tell them to send someone out to fix it.  It's also possible to return it to Dell during the warranty period and demand that they fix the system.

    Dell tech "support" always assumes that the customer is a complete m0r0n.  While in some cases this may be true, there are also quite a few of us customers who know what we're doing.  I know that the economics don't work out to where they can staff every tech support cubicle with a systems expert, but they should at least try to find people who are knowledgeable and willing to learn about the systems Dell offers.  Perhaps have dedicated tech people for Inspiron systems and another group for Dimension systems, etc..  Have current and late-model hardware available to the tech people so they can work with it too.  Otherwise, tech support degenerates to what it is now -- a glorified telemarketing operation that gets the customers to call them.  It would also be nice if their techs could do more than simply steer people to the knowledgebase or software updates.  I would bet that 75% of the time, people who are calling tech support have already tried those options.  Dell support in the past has always been rather good, at least in my experiences.  But I haven't had to contact Dell support in about 3 years now and it's obvious that a lot has changed since then.  I quit buying from Gateway about 7+ years ago because their systems quality went into the toilet and so did their support.  Seems Dell is starting to do the same...  I haven't looked into Gateway since that last system I bought, which was an i486 desktop and I have heard they have improved over the past few years.  But I doubt I will ever buy from them again as I'd rather not give them the chance to rip me off yet again.  I'm starting to feel the same way about Dell...  As someone who runs several systems, including servers and performance workstations, I usually build most systems personally.  It doesn't really save money and definitely not time, but at least I know exactly what I have to work with and I can build exactly what I want and hold the quality as high as I can afford.  I'll see how this Inspiron 5100 continues to perform for us here... And I'm holding off on my planned purchase of an 8500 to replace the Inspiron 8000 I use every day because of this quality issue.

  • Entropy42

    529 Posts

    473

    0

    Posted August 22nd, 2003 18:00

    Sadly, this is common throughout the industry. Support quality is going downhill across the board.

    Dell is still far better than the likes of Compaq... Overall, my 8200 has been one of the most reliable systems I've ever owned. The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence.

    The only better vendors than Dell quality-wise in my experience are IBM, Apple, and Alienware (And even then, only Alienware's desktop systems... Their laptops are overpriced leg-burning monstrosities). Toshiba used to be excellent, but for the past 4-5 years, all of their models seem relatively flimsy. Dell fluctuates every few years... 4-5 years ago when I was selling computers at Cornell's campus store they were horrible, and they really shaped up by my senior year with the Inspiron 8000 - I knew MANY people who were using 8000s and loved them, which prompted me to reccommend an 8000 to my father when he was shopping for a laptop, and to buying an 8200 for myself a year later. My father absolutely loves his 8000, and my 8200 has served me well.

    Yes, screwups are bound to happen. Backing the DVD+RW format was an extremely bad decision on Dell's part - They should have looked at Sony and Philips' track record in format wars. The only time Sony has won a format war was when they were up against Philips (MD vs DCC), and even then, MD never really took off. It says great things about a format when the creator of the format can't even produce a drive that burns discs properly.

    Message Edited by Entropy42 on 08-22-2003 02:50 PM

  • TommyGadget

    23 Posts

    473

    0

    Posted September 26th, 2003 19:00

    I would like to chime in here. My new Inspiron 600m has this Philips drive in it, and I would like to share my experiences. First off, I think it is important to note that I am using Windows XP Pro with service pack 1. I have lots of software installed on this machine, and all my drivers are up to date. I use CloneDVD to copy my kiddie movies because the kids destroy the discs after about two weeks. I bought two types of media because they were on sale. For my laptop backups I use KHypermedia DVD+RW discs. I have not had a single problem writing these discs and copying the contents with different drives. My DVD+R experiences, however, have been different. First of all, I use Memorex 4x media because it was on sale. I burned some discs and my failure rate was about 20%, and on the good burns, my home DVD player would have a glitch or two on maybe 40% of the discs. I installed some more software (visual enhancements for WinXP), and my failure rate rose to 100%! My solution is as follows: Start your computer and create a new user. Log in as this user (must have admin privileges). Go to the performance section of your system properties and uncheck the visual enhancements. After this, disable system restore for all drives. Disable file indexing. If using a laptop, choose maximum performance profile. Reboot. Log in and check to see that no optional software is in your startup group. I have had 100% success so far with the following media: Memorex 4x, and Optimum DVD+R from Staples. I call this user DVDBurner. Apparently things that run in the background can really mess up the tempermental drive.

    TommyGadget

  • TommyGadget

    23 Posts

    473

    0

    Posted October 23rd, 2003 17:00

    I guess I jinxed myself by saying I got 100% burn success. This drive is burning coasters randomly and without any discernable pattern. Upgrading the drive firmware did not help. Now I am toast. First message to Dell techs got nowhere. Their response clearly indicated that they didn't even read my message (sigh). The saga continues. Getting a new drive seems unlikely unless I call and blow my stack.

    TommyGadget

  • TheGSRGuy

    2 Intern

    •

    281 Posts

    473

    0

    Posted October 23rd, 2003 19:00

    Even the updated firmware isn't going to fix the problem. Dell told me that there are focusing problems with the laser & lens, that is why people are having problems.

    Call and insist on the NEC 4x burner.
  • Walter_SA

    12 Posts

    473

    0

    Posted October 24th, 2003 01:00

    TheGSRGuy :

    Even the updated firmware isn't going to fix the problem. Dell told me that there are focusing problems with the laser & lens, that is why people are having problems.

    Call and insist on the NEC 4x burner.

     

    I second that! Philips drives are very much lottery thing. Some of them work and depends on your luck whether you go through 1 or 5 to get the right one. NEC is much safer option but you have to convince Dell to give you one.

    To people who haven't ordered their systems yet(8500, 8600, 5150...) I'd recommend you go for more expensive but realiable 4xNEC drive or, save some money and forget about DVD burners all together. 2x Philips drives are just not worth the risk or hassle! I was going to return my laptop and get one without DVD burner had they not sent me NEC drive.

    BTW, Pioneer are soon going to ship DVD+-R/+-RW drive for laptops. Not sure how much $$$ but it may be worth as an aftermarket upgrade (all you do is slot it in the Dell cradle you got with your Dell provided drive).

     

  • TommyGadget

    23 Posts

    465

    0

    Posted October 24th, 2003 02:00

    Well, I have to give credit where credit is due. I replied to the EMAIL with the newbie link and the tech that answered was respectful and promised a new drive right away. I will update the saga as it unfolds. No indication if they would send the NEC or another Philips. I guess we'll have to wait and see.

    TommyGadget