
UNSOLVED
Closed
Known defect, Seagate ST2000DM001-9YN164, Dell XPS One
I posted this here but it got redirected to the Support forum but the Dell employee moderating that forum insists it belongs back over here, so here we are again. I've been beating my head on Dell Support ever since I bought my machine on the fact that the hard disk continually re-calibrates. I've been round and round with Dell Customer support since I bought the machine. I get a continual run around with the outright blatant lie that they know of no trouble with this drive. Here are messages from the Dell community site with all the other customers so affected:
There’s even a YouTube video of some other helpless customer whose drive made this noise until it finally failed:
Further, it is a well known problem with this particular drive:
The same drive is in other Dell machines with equally dissatisfied customers:
Responses (9)
Solutions (0)
Attached is the diagnostic output (doesn't show anything...the machine is a XPS One 2710. The machine makes the same noises while running regularly (even if the thing is pretty much asleep, my wife kicked the machine out of our bedroom over having to listen to the thing beeping all night long) or under the diagnostics, of course the diagnostics don't show anything. Periodically the drive just drops off line entirely and the machine crashes and then the reboot fails (no boot image) until you power cycle. I've been through countless bios upgrades and other time wasters from support poking at the problem with a stick. The one thing I did get out of the Diags is the exact Seagate model number which let me find out that it's not this particular Dell machine. The drive has known defects across the board (in other Dell systems and even in non-Dell). It's a known defect in these 2TB Seagates.
----
ImageBase: C929E000
EPSA Build 4220.10 UEFI ROM, Service Tag: GN9GWS1, SystemID: 054BStarting PSA Main.
Examining ACPI descriptors...
Password Jumper = Not Installed
IR Detector = Installed
Camera = Installed
Touch Panel = Installed
Service Mode Jumper = Not Installed
Hard Drive 0-0-0 = Installed
OEM: ATA, product: ST2000DM001-9YN164, revision: CC4G,
S/N: W240Q491, type: SATA, size: 2 TB
CDROM Drive 0-0-0 = Installed
OEM: PLDS, product: DVD+-RW DL-8A4SH, revision: HD11,
S/N: D288Y5508124B40LKA00
BootPath = MBR of Hard Drive 0-0-0
Name = CPU Thermistor
Temperature = 60 C
ThermalZone = 0
Name = Video Thermistor
Temperature = 51 C
ThermalZone = 0
System Memory = 8192 MB
BANK 0 ChannelA-DIMM0, 4096 MB, DDR3, 1600 MHz, S/N: E96A90FE, P/N: 16JTF51264HZ-1G6M1
BANK 2 ChannelB-DIMM0, 4096 MB, DDR3, 1600 MHz, S/N: E96A90FF, P/N: 16JTF51264HZ-1G6M1
** Cables - Various Tests **
PlatformSSID = 054B
Test Results : Pass** Hard Drive 0-0-0 - DST Short Test **
Test Results : Running** CDROM Drive 0-0-0 - Optical Device Built-in Self Test **
Test Results : Pass** OS Boot Path 0-0-0 - Various Tests **
Test Results : Pass** Video Card - Video Card Connection Test **
Test Results : Pass** Video Card - Video Memory Test **
Vendor Name: uEFI
Product ID: Graphics Protocol
Vendor Version: N/A
Memory Start = 0xd0000000 Memory size tested 64.00MB
Test Results : Pass** CPU FAN - Various Tests **
High Speed RPM ........: 4300
Max Speed RPM .........: 4300
Required samples in range 1
Maximum samples 30
Target fan RPM.........: 1050
Detected fan RPM.......: 1123
Tolerance in percent...: 25
Required samples in range 1
Maximum samples 30
Target fan RPM.........: 4300
Detected fan RPM.......: 4249
Tolerance in percent...: 20
Test Results : Pass** MXM FAN - Various Tests **
High Speed RPM ........: 5800
Max Speed RPM .........: 5800
Required samples in range 1
Maximum samples 30
Target fan RPM.........: 2450
Detected fan RPM.......: 2572
Tolerance in percent...: 30
Required samples in range 1
Maximum samples 30
Target fan RPM.........: 5800
Detected fan RPM.......: 5617
Tolerance in percent...: 20
Test Results : Pass** System Management - Various Tests **
Test Results : Pass** Processor - Various Processor Tests **
Running Dirty Cache Reads Test
Running Alternating CPU Writes Test
Running Random Access Thrash Test
Test Results : Pass** Memory - Data Bus Stress Test **
Testing with 8 CPUs
Allocated 0x1F6058000 bytes (8032 MB) for testing
Testing 5 MB at 0x100000
Testing 495 MB at 0x1100000
Testing 510 MB at 0x20200000
Testing 2158 MB at 0x40005000
Testing 3 MB at 0xC6E16000
Testing 4 MB at 0xC8E6F000
Testing 1 MB at 0xC9CDF000
Testing 4854 MB at 0x100000000
Test Results : Pass** Memory - Ground Bounce Test **
Testing with 8 CPUs
Allocated 0x1F6058000 bytes (8032 MB) for testing
Testing 5 MB at 0x100000
Testing 495 MB at 0x1100000
Testing 510 MB at 0x20200000
Testing 2158 MB at 0x40005000
Testing 3 MB at 0xC6E16000
Testing 4 MB at 0xC8E6F000
Testing 1 MB at 0xC9CDF000
Testing 4854 MB at 0x100000000
Test Results : Pass** Memory - March C- Test **
Testing with 8 CPUs
Allocated 0x1F6058000 bytes (8032 MB) for testing
Testing 5 MB at 0x100000
Testing 495 MB at 0x1100000
Testing 510 MB at 0x20200000
Testing 2158 MB at 0x40005000
Testing 3 MB at 0xC6E16000
Testing 4 MB at 0xC8E6F000
Testing 1 MB at 0xC9CDF000
Testing 4854 MB at 0x100000000
Test Results : Pass** Memory - WCMATS Test **
Testing with 8 CPUs
Allocated 0x1F6058000 bytes (8032 MB) for testing
Testing 5 MB at 0x100000
Testing 495 MB at 0x1100000
Testing 510 MB at 0x20200000
Testing 2158 MB at 0x40005000
Testing 3 MB at 0xC6E16000
Testing 4 MB at 0xC8E6F000
Testing 1 MB at 0xC9CDF000
Testing 4854 MB at 0x100000000
Test Results : Pass** Memory - WCMch Test **
Testing with 8 CPUs
Allocated 0x1F6058000 bytes (8032 MB) for testing
Testing 5 MB at 0x100000
Testing 495 MB at 0x1100000
Testing 510 MB at 0x20200000
Testing 2158 MB at 0x40005000
Testing 3 MB at 0xC6E16000
Testing 4 MB at 0xC8E6F000
Testing 1 MB at 0xC9CDF000
Testing 4854 MB at 0x100000000
Test Results : Pass** Memory - XMATS32 Test **
Testing with 8 CPUs
Allocated 0x1F6058000 bytes (8032 MB) for testing
Testing 5 MB at 0x100000
Testing 495 MB at 0x1100000
Testing 510 MB at 0x20200000
Testing 2158 MB at 0x40005000
Testing 3 MB at 0xC6E16000
Testing 4 MB at 0xC8E6F000
Testing 1 MB at 0xC9CDF000
Testing 4854 MB at 0x100000000
Test Results : Pass** Hard Drive 0-0-0 - DST Short Test **
Test Results : PassThe tech support guys have walked me through countless BIOS and other upgrades. No help. The drive makes the noise whether it's running windows or the diagnostics but the diagnostics don't show anything. It's a known defect with these 2TB Seagate drives. The fact that Dell won't own up to it is even more unconscionable in that the online backup system I paid for from Dell is stuck in an unauthorized state so I can't even back up the system to the cloud at this point (and yes I do have an offline USB backup that I do periodically since this drive from talking to the community will burn up at any minute).
If there is a true hardware problem causing the system to reboot, that should show up during the diagnostics but you need to run the long test, not the short one.
Since you've already engaged tech support, I'm not sure there's much else I can suggest.
It can run for days without crashing, but it continues to make the re-calibrate noise continually (performance suffers while it's doing that). This is a known problem with these Seagates. Dell steadfastly refuses to own up to the problem. I've tried opening a ticket at Seagate. They may have more scruples than Dell.
DELL-Chris M
Community Manager
•
56891 Posts
•
232143 Points
5340
0
Posted November 29th, 2014 22:00
The XPS One 2710 and the XPS 8500 sold with the same 2TB drives =
2WK2D 2TB, S3, 7.2K, Seagate Muskie 6G (sold on 27 different desktop models)
Y4N52 2TB, S3, 7.2K, Seagate-GRDABP (sold on 23 different desktop models)
YD6FM 2TB, S3, 7.2K, Seagate-GRDA (sold on 22 different desktop models)
6HFW3 2TB, S3, 7.2K, Toshiba-MARS (sold on 29 different desktop models)
NMT49 2TB, S3, 7.2K, Hitachi-Mariner (sold on 20 different desktop models)YD6FM is theSeagate ST2000DM001-9YN164 drive.
Periodically run the Dell Diagnostics on just the HDD. When it fails, take a picture of the screen. That is all the proof you would need to have support replace the HDD with any of the other 2TB HDD listed above.
DELL-Chris M (old account)
#IWork4Dell
Dell tech support is stonewalling doing anything on this. I can't believe that Dell is causing all this customer angst over a drive they KNOW is defective from the manufacturer and a new one is only $70 retail.
The last bit of nonsense is that they claim that YD5FM and Y4N52 are exactly the same drive. Which makes little sense. Why would both Seagate and Dell give different part numbers to the same drive?
Running the diags is pointless. When the drive works, it passes the diags. When it doesn't work all it does is go into the recalibration spasms which doesn't cause an error, it just causes a fraction of a second hiccup in the system performance each time. When it drops off line completely you can't do anything with the systems (since the diags require a reboot, you've likely reset the drive at that point anyhow).
DELL-Chris M
Community Manager
•
56891 Posts
•
232143 Points
5340
0
Posted December 5th, 2014 07:00
All you can is wait for a complete failure of the drive. When it occurs, ask them to replace it with one of the other 2TB drives.
DELL-Chris M (old account)
#IWork4Dell
Apologies for the lateness, but I think you should add a disclaimer to your last sentence that reads, "as long as you are within warranty." If you are out of warranty, 22 month old XPS 2720 in my case, your only option is to buy a replacement hard drive (or write off $3k and bin it). One orders a Y4N52 and then one receives a NYR3N. I swapped them out and now I am in an even worse place, "No Bootable Device."

osprey4
6 Operator
•
34230 Posts
5340
0
Posted November 29th, 2014 12:00
Hi Flyingron,
What model is your desktop? Have you tried the suggested firmware update? When you run the Dell diagnostics, do you hear the same noise?