UNSOLVED

AM Radio

updated

20 years ago

AR

AM Radio

13 Posts

0

14315

January 10th, 2007 03:00

Inspiron 9400 DVD replacement: Sony for Optiarc

just got my replacement.

the Sony DW-Q58A was noisy, and really really slow. (7mins to move 700mbs.)

now i have the Optiarc DVD+-RW AD-5540A V102C. quick google shows that Optiarc is a joint venture between Sony and NEC -- didn't know that.

well, unfortunately, it's just as slow as the sony it replaces, even though Nero Drive Speed says the readspeed is 24X. can someone tell me if it takes them 7minutes to copy the contents of one 700MB disc on an Inspiron 9400? or are laptop/slim dvd-drives this slow typically?

many thanks.
  • AM Radio

    13 Posts

    235

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2007 03:00

    whoops, here's some info on Optiarc

    http://liggydee.cdfreaks.com/page/5540/
  • Entropy42

    529 Posts

    235

    0

    Posted January 12th, 2007 13:00

    It sounds like you are reading a 700MB CD?

    No high-speed CD drives (and I believe it is the same for higher-speed DVD) drives achieve their maximum read speed across the entire disc.

    There are a few types of CD/DVD drives
    CLV - Constant Linear Velocity - The disc spins faster at the center in order to achieve a constant data rate across the entire disc. (i.e. the linear velocity of the disc relative to the read head stays constant.) CLV above around 8x or so is not possible, as the required rotation rates at the disc center would be higher than any CD media could handle.
    Zoned CLV (Z-CLV) - Same as CLV except that at certain areas of the disc the drive changes its linear velocity. As a result you get 6-8x constant for the first few megabytes, a higher speed for the next few, and the maximum rated speed only for the last 50-100 MB of the disc. I know the CD-R and CD-ROM/DVD combo drives that came with my Inspiron 8200 were Z-CLV
    CAV - Constant Angular Velocity. The disc spins at the same RPM at all times, data rate increases smoothly as you approach the outside of the disc. Most super-high-speed (48-52x CD or so) are CAV, probably so are the 8x+ DVD drives.

    7 minutes to copy 700 MB is approximately 12x speed on average, which is only a bit below the average speed I'd expect from a 24x Z-CLV or CAV drive across the entirety of a disc. (24x pure CLV cannot exist, a CD or DVD would spin so fast that it would distort or even shatter. I remember that someone once tried simulating the rotation rate of a 24x pure CLV drive at the beginning of a disc using a Dremel tool - mmm shrapnel!)

    FYI, 1x DVD speed is defined differently from 1x CD speed. 1x CD speed is 150 KB/second, 1x DVD is around 1.1-1.2 MB/second, or around 8-9x CD. Flash memory is typically rated in the same scale as CDs, 1x = 150 KB/sec.

    High-speed CD drives will always be noisy, since the rotation rates needed are so high (close to the physical limits of CD media for a 48-52x CAV) Due to higher data density, DVDs require a far lower rotational rate to achieve the same throughput as a CD. (I believe a 1x DVD, which provides the same transfer rate as an 8x-9x CD, rotates only somewhat faster than a 1x CD. This is due to the fact that the data density of a DVD is 6.7 times that of a CD.)
  • 235

    0

    Posted January 13th, 2007 14:00

    I have the same Optiarc AD-5540A w/ 102C Firmware in the Inspiron I just bought and it is slow as the dickens.  When I put a CD in, it sits and sits then after a few minutes the CD contents might show up.  I tried to copy a disk that has about 600MB on it, but it wouldn't read the original disk and I gave up after about 10 minutes of the hourglass.  I'm contacting support about the problem, but it's very frustrating since our other 6 Inspirons with different CD drives don't have the problem.
  • alexandra06

    1 Message

    235

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2007 16:00

    hi...im just wondering if anyone could help me... dell replaced my dvd drive because i wasnt reading any cd's before but now i have another problem...my drive is unable to burn any cd's...it says "no suitable drive is detected....." and i spoke with the dell technicain they ran all the test that they needed saying that they will send me another replacement or whatever if that still doesnt work they will reboot my computer something like that....is there anything that i can do to make my drive work? without going to the whole process of deleting all my programs