UNSOLVED

dbarker0814

updated

19 years ago

D

dbarker0814

11 Posts

0

51337

October 6th, 2005 20:00

8500 Docking Station IRQ Conflict

I have a serious problem. I have an Inspiron 8500 with port replicator running XP Pro. When I re-boot on the Port replicator I loose my CD rom Drive due to an IRQ Conflict. Undock the laptop and re-boot and everything is fine. Only happens when booting or re-booting on the docking station.

Now, purchasing a new system board sounds like a great sales pitch, but where is the support here, I want a detailed explanation as to the cause. I see that there are a lot of people running into the same problem.

I've already spent the money for a replacement board, DOESN'T fix anything. The board works fine until docked to a NEW port replicator, which was also recommended.
  • 481

    0

    Posted October 14th, 2005 02:00

    Similar problem here with an Inspiron 8600.  Boot in the docking station, Secondary IDE Channel (controlling DVD-RW) has IRQ(15) conflict with COM1 (which I disabled, uninstalled, etc.) and DVD-RW does not work.  Reboot out of docking station and AOK.

    Any guidance from Dell (or anyone else) on how to resolve?  Dell support says I need a new HD, memory & DVD-RW.  Sounds like a System Board problem to me, but what do I know...

  • dbarker0814

    11 Posts

    481

    0

    Posted October 14th, 2005 13:00

    Dell apparently doesn't want to support the hardware, the only thing that I've been able to determine is that it is the system board, nothing else makes sense.

    Dell recommends buying a new laptop since the system board is $500 or more.

    100's of people are having the same problem with similar models like the Latitude D800 and Inspiron 8600. That tells me that its definately something that they've seen, they're just with-holding information from consumers. My opinion is that Dell knows what the problem is, won't admit it because they may be required to fix tons of systems still under warranty, and that is expensive.

    Good luck, but for my money, I'm buying a Vaio, dell won't be seeing another penny from me or my company including servers.
  • dbarker0814

    11 Posts

    480

    0

    Posted October 14th, 2005 14:00

    Unfortunately, I can say with some certainty that the problem isn't with a Windows / software update. Re-installing windows from the provided discs from dell will have the same result. Essentially, it seems that there is a problem with the ACPI controller. I can't tell you how many hours I wasted trying different things including installing window 98se which allows you to manage resources manually.

    If I were you, I'd demand that board be replaced before your warranty expires, otherwise Dell will probably waste a bunch of your time trying to resolve the problem.

    Best of Luck!
  • dbarker0814

    11 Posts

    480

    0

    Posted October 14th, 2005 14:00

    Just another note... Notice the complete silence on the topic from Dell's forum moderators. Can't imagine why...
  • 481

    0

    Posted October 14th, 2005 14:00

    Lucky me, my Inspiron is still under support with Dell - I'm not holding my breath, though, based on your comments and those of others.
     
    I read in another posting a theory that this problem is caused by an OS update (i.e. Windows Update).  This makes some sense, in that no one seems to be able to associate a specific hardware change with the problem.  Any thoughts on that angle?
     
    Good luck with your Sony - I have a colleague in New Hampshire who swore he would never touch another VAIO after his negative experience with their hardware and support.  I have similar feelings about Compaq  Maybe it's time for a Toshiba???
  • 480

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2005 15:00

    Well, Dell is 0 for 1 so far.  They shipped me "refurbished" DVD-RW, memory and hard drive, none of which improved the situation.  Confirmed your results that original Windows version (SP1) and original drivers did not solve the problem.  Only took them a week to get the parts to me...  I wonder what will be next - System board?
  • dbarker0814

    11 Posts

    480

    0

    Posted October 18th, 2005 16:00

    A new system board should resolve the problem, although your docking station could have caused the problem in the first place. I would try that, and if you have an alternative docking station, I would try using it before connecting a new system board to docking station that is not working.

    One other note, you have to re-install windows while the machine is un-docked, otherwise your likely to recieve a stop error from the windows install.

    Good luck,
    ~D
  • wagggie

    13 Posts

    480

    0

    Posted October 26th, 2005 11:00

    Hey,
     
    I thought my search may turn up some other people with the same issues.  I have been having this same problem for about a year.  Search my other posts and you will see the alternate thread.  Basically I had to turn the computer on WHILE UNDOCKED then once its at the login screen you have hot dock it.  It then assigns separate IRQs to the docking station and the CD drive.
     
    Hope that helps temporarily until Dell can take care of this.  I have seen nothing from them on the subject yet.
     
    Jason
  • Splighf

    2 Posts

    480

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2005 21:00

    I've also had the same problem for the past year.  Dell has sent me two port replicators and a replacement CD/DVD drive.  No luck.  Still can't see the CD drive if I boot up docked.

    Their last fix is to replace my motherboard, but I have to send my laptop back to them for 5-10 days.  This is a show stopper for me.

    Anybody figure out if there is another fix?  I just don't get why Dell hasn't posted a fix for this.

  • dbarker0814

    11 Posts

    322

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2005 02:00

    Sorry to hear your also experiencing the same problem.  One thing that I've heard is that may or not be valuable, but don't use any of the same docking stations once the mother board is replaced.  I've been told that a bad docking station can cause the problem, and that once the board is messed up, your only option is a replacement.

    I really don't expect Dell will ever take any action to correct the problem.  I would expect that it's something that could be fixed in the Bios, but I don't know for certain.  The only reason I make that assumption is that if you HOT DOCK as described in a previous post, you can get your system working with out the IRQ conflicts.

    I have replaced the motherboard in my system now and it is working as it should.  Another Tip, don't waste your time contacting Dell for a replacement out of warranty, they want over $500 for refurbished boards that you can find under $300 if your patient.  Besides, Dell won't warrant the replacement parts anyway.

    Good luck to you, I hope Dell will correct the problem based on the number of companies with these models, I think it's only a matter of time.

    ~d