Does the 2407WFP support 1080i through DVI?
* No.
Does the 2407WFP support 1080p through DVI?
* No.
Does the 2407WFP support 1080p through component?
* No.
Does the 2407WFP support 1080i through component?
* Yes.
Does the 2407WFP support 720p through component?
* Yes.
Message Edited by DELL-ChrisM on 06-15-200612:18 PM
so.... one of the big new features (aside from reduced gray to gray time and maybe a tiny bit with lag are there any other?) is HDCP and yet it doesn't work with 1080i/p DVI??
while the 2405 handles 1080i/p DVI but no HDCP??
I guess I could accept 1080i component (if it really stays at 1080i and not 540p conversion!) for xbox 360 PS/3 type stuff, but if I couldn't do 1080 for DVD and HDTV through my computer using DVI and HDCP....
I would probably try to have my computer drive everything, but do you mean to say that even using my computer running a software DVD player using an internal bluray drive or when vista arrives with HDTV cable support that it won't allow the computer to send 1080 HD programming to the 2407 display?!! maybe HDCP won't be used for HD discs for some years (1-2 bad, 6 or more maybe okish) but I know vista would use it for HDTV through cable and satellite.
i'm not sure what the point of this monitor is.
why go through all the steps and then put an older cheap chip into it that can't delace 1080i or some weird crippled HDCP chip that blocks over 720p content?
hopefully, much of this is not the case and just miscommunication and understanding.
"i'm not sure what the point of this monitor is.
why go through all the steps and then put an older cheap chip into it that can't delace 1080i or some weird crippled HDCP chip that blocks over 720p content?
hopefully, much of this is not the case and just miscommunication and understanding."
Agreed.
Also will any future version of the 2407wfp support Full (1080p) HDCP, or should I return it and get a monitor that can actually do what it is adverstised as doing?
actually how is it even possible that you say that there is no DVI support for 1080i AND p? And why was 1080i removed from the 2407 (it was in the 2405)? I have read that people have not been able to get external 1080i devices to work, but how can 1080p not work? How can the computer make a native 1920x1200 display through DVI then? Did you just mean no HDCP at 1080?
And is it really true that if I tried to play a 1080p bluray disk or view (using Vista) a 1080 HDTV program protected by HDCP on my computer (not fed through some external player or tuner) that the monitor would choke unless the videos were downconverted to 720p or the HDCP protection was somehow stripped????
I really hope this is not the case. Maybe this is why the website no longer says much about HDCP, because it doesn't really support it in reality?
The 2405 supports top quality DVI 1080i feeds from cable boxes only that doesn't work since no HDCP and then the 2407 adds HDCP but removes 1080i so that doesn't work either? Again I could even grudgingly live with this if it would support 1080p HDCP signals sent directly through a future HDCP video card and Vista, but sounds like forces 720p so that doesn't work either.
If so, any time frame on a replacement model that actually has HDCP?
really wish this stupid DRM HDCP garbage was never invented to begin with.
yeah, although the other options currently out there seem to have issues too though (no HDCP and/or worse lag and/or 16:9 videos forced to be stretched awkwardly into 16:10, if I understand correctly).
I still have a bit of hope for the 2407 though since the claim about no 1080p over DVI seems to make no sense and tentatively appears to be wrong, so hopefully the no 1080p HDCP is also wrong.
If so, then I should be able to use my PC to drive everything and I should be fine (won't be able to plug cable DVI directly into it and perhaps have to use component for game systems, but I didn't plan on doing that stuff all that much so it's not a game ending for me).
Perhaps the comment about 720p DVI only just meant that you can't plug in a cable set top box (or other 1080i source) and have it display as either 1080i or 1080p only as 540p even though you can use the DVI connector to run 1080p material, even HDCP flagged material, so long as you have a computer to generate a 1080p signal from the 1080 source? This would seem to make sense. Hopefully it can accept BOTH 720p AND 1080p HDCP or not from your PC (tuning in HDTV cable with vista or running HD disks) even if it can't handle external 1080i signals of any sort.
My guess is that it can do the following even with HDCP flagged:
handle 720p
convert 1080i to 720p and then display
handle both 720p and 1080p video if generated by a computer
as well as have no trouble using a PS3 at 1080p through DVI port.
hopefully that is correct.
All we need is someone with a HDCP flagged test disk to test it out, but I'm not sure if there are any.
DELL-Chris M
Community Manager
•
56891 Posts
•
232143 Points
458
0
Posted June 14th, 2006 15:00
* No.
Does the 2407WFP support 1080p through DVI?
* No.
Does the 2407WFP support 1080p through component?
* No.
Does the 2407WFP support 1080i through component?
* Yes.
Does the 2407WFP support 720p through component?
* Yes.
Message Edited by DELL-ChrisM on 06-15-200612:18 PM
DELL-Chris M (old account)
#IWork4Dell