UNSOLVED

lappy65

updated

16 years ago

L

lappy65

6 Posts

0

182937

January 2nd, 2011 19:00

Display Port Tale of Woe

I recently purchased three shiny new Dell U2211H monitors to set up an Eyefinity system to run from my ASUS EAH5870HD video card. I purchased the Dell monitors because they were reasonably priced after the 15% discount and had native Displayport support which meant I wouldn't have to bother with an active DP-DVI adaptor for the third monitor.  My first problem was that I hadn't realised Dell don't provide a DP cable with the monitors (only Power, USB, VGA & DVI), so off to half a dozen or so computer shops before finding one that actually had some Astrotek (www.astrotek.com.hk) DP M-M 1 meter cables in stock, the others either didn't know what Display Port even was and treated me like I was talking gibberish (thanks HN sales droid Display Port is NOT S-Video, VGA, DVI or HDMI), only had mini DP to DVI adaptors (most of the others) or did know what I wanted and could get one in for me. 

Anyway, after picking up my cable from the other side of town I connected up my third monitor and powered on the computer to be greeted by three blank screens and fans running at full throttle.  Disconnecting the DP connected monitor and rebooting the computer brought up a warning message that Overclocking had failed and failsafe defaults had been loaded into BIOS for me, great.  Swapping cables and monitors in various combinations confirmed that all three worked fine on DVI but if any monitor was connected to DP the computer would fail to boot with fans running full bore and my BIOS settings lost again on the next successful boot.  But if I connected the DP cable after the computer was already booted then it would happily detect the third monitor and allow me to set up eyefinity which is a beautiful thing when it's working.

So off to Google/AMD/Dell in search of a solution, after many false trails I finally stumbled across this game forum topic at AMD:
http://forums.amd.com/game/messageview.cfm?catid=260&threadid=127563

this sounded familiar so i went to the NEC link mentioned in the thread:
http://www.necdisplay.com/cms/documents/UserManuals/DisplayPort_Notice.pdf

I dug out my trusty multimeter and found Pin 20 is indeed connected to Pin 20 on the other end of the cable. Bingo.

A little more digging uncovered the following explanation from the Display Port consortium themselves, though the question should probably say "Why shouldn't there be a wire on Pin 20 as mine clearly does."

http://www.displayport.org/consumer/?q=content/faq
"Q: Why isn’t there a wire on pin 20 (POWER) on the standard external DisplayPort cables?
A: The reason power isn't included in standard cables is because both source and sink devices are designed to provide power.  Captive, attached cables often include the power wire. If it is desired, for example, that a particular source device utilize the power available from the mating sink device, then that Source device could include an attached or dedicated cable that carries the DisplayPort power signal. Same could be applied to a sink device. "

So to sum up, if you're experiencing strange symptoms with a monitor connected with a Display Port cable, check the cable to see if pin 20 is connected and if it is replace it with one that isn't.
I have ordered a belkin 1.8 m cable from Dell but If anybody knows what other brand of cables don't have pin 20 connected it might be nice for other people to know.

p.s. the contacts on the DP cable are very small so I needed very fine wires wrapped around my multimeter probes to test the cable.

  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    1908

    0

    Posted January 6th, 2011 20:00

    Good post.


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • lappy65

    6 Posts

    1908

    0

    Posted January 6th, 2011 21:00

    Thanks,

    I'm still waiting for the Belkin cable to arrive and I'll post back here when it does. 

    I'm also having trouble getting a full refund from the store I bought the faulty cable from, they calim there's nothing wrong with it (though they were unwilling to demonstrate it working for me) and as it's now second hand goods they'll only give me $15 of the $25 purchase price, but that's another story, if they don't respond favourably to my official complaint the office of Fair Trading will get involved and their name will be mud.

  • lappy65

    6 Posts

    1908

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2011 15:00

    The Belkin cable finally arrived (lack of stock/delivery problems due to floods here in Brisbane??), checked with a multimeter, Pin 20 is NOT connected Hoorah!!!  Plugged in the cable, booted up the computer with no issues, set up eyefinity now widescreen gaming at 5760 x 1080 woo hoo:emotion-2:

  • Joseph Stateson

    2 Intern

    •

    153 Posts

    •

    2 Points

    1908

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2011 15:00

    HI

    Do you know if your DP cable provides audio?  I just added a 3rd monitor (26in 1080p) to an ATI 5850 cypress made by HIS using an HIS DP cable with built in power (USB not required).  However, the cable, i got it here,

    http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00439G3NW/ref=oss_product

    needed a DVI to HDMI adapter.  After I assembled it, the audio was missing although the win7 mixer indicated it was playing thru the DP.  According to WIKI, a DP "can" pass audio but that is not a requirement in the DP spec.  I have not heard from HIS yet and when I read your post I got to wondering if you can get audio thru the DP's you are using.  I am getting autio thru the regular speakers on my PC, but I would rather use the speakers in the TV.  I know they work because an HDMI cable straight from my pc to the tv works fine, but only the DP supports 3 monitors so I cannot use the HDMI.

    thanks for looking

  • lappy65

    6 Posts

    1908

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2011 16:00

    HI

    Do you know if your DP cable provides audio?  I just added a 3rd monitor (26in 1080p) to an ATI 5850 cypress made by HIS using an HIS DP cable with built in power (USB not required).  However, the cable, i got it here,

    http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00439G3NW/ref=oss_product

    needed a DVI to HDMI adapter.  After I assembled it, the audio was missing although the win7 mixer indicated it was playing thru the DP.  According to WIKI, a DP "can" pass audio but that is not a requirement in the DP spec.  I have not heard from HIS yet and when I read your post I got to wondering if you can get audio thru the DP's you are using.  I am getting autio thru the regular speakers on my PC, but I would rather use the speakers in the TV.  I know they work because an HDMI cable straight from my pc to the tv works fine, but only the DP supports 3 monitors so I cannot use the HDMI.

    thanks for looking

    My monitors don't have speakers so i don't know if audio works through my DP cable (It should, the latest version of the standard does support audio), but I only use the DP cable on one of the monitors in my eyefinity setup as the other two are currently connected via the DVI ports on my graphics card and I know you can use One DVI with One HDMI and One DP.  My ASUS EAH5870HD supports eyefinity where One display must be via DP the other two can be both DVI or one DVI  and one HDMI.

    Audio cannot pass through DVI so the adaptor you linked to (DP to DVI) won't pass the audio from the DP connection also if the monitor you bought doesn't have speakers like mine you won't get audio.  What monitors do you have?  A DP to HDMI adaptor may pass audio.

    Is your video card this one?:- http://www.hisdigital.com/un/product2-474.shtml , if so then you could use the HDMI port to drive the monitor with the speakers, you don't need to drive all three monitors from DP to get eyefinity working, just the one.

    My understanding is that to get audio through your video card you will need to connect HDMI to HDMI Monitor or DP to DP monitor or DP to HDMI monitor via adaptor , assuming your monitors have digital audio decoding capability, or go via a surround sound amp with digital decoding capability on HDMI or DP inputs.

  • Joseph Stateson

    2 Intern

    •

    153 Posts

    •

    2 Points

    1908

    0

    Posted January 22nd, 2011 06:00

    Thanks - I now see what the problem is. To get audio,  I need to use the HDMI port and it needs to connect to my VIZIO 1080p.  The DP (with the DVI adapter) and one of the DVI need to go to my  matched Planar 17" monitors. http://stateson.net/images/036.jpg  Unfortunately, the two planars are VGA and go thru a dual VGA  KVM switch.  They are not DVI monitors so even if I bypass the KVM I cannot use the DVI from the DP adapter.

    Alternately, an active DP to HDMI adapter that passes audio would have worked.

     The DP to DVI I got on amazon does not support analog VGA as it is only DVI-D so I cannot gender it to the KVM (I tried). 

    The TV has 2ch audio input so I can connect that to my cypress system and be able to use its remote to change the volume.  That will free up my speakers for another system on the KVM.  The KVM does not switch audio.

  • MCalca1706

    11 Posts

    1908

    0

    Posted November 18th, 2011 22:00

    Can you tell me exactly which Belkin cable worked from a Display Port Monitor to HDMI?

    I have a Dell U2412 Monitor With Display Port and need to get a HDMI Adapter that actually works.

                                                                                                               Thank You  

  • lappy65

    6 Posts

    1908

    0

    Posted November 19th, 2011 03:00

    "Can you tell me exactly which Belkin cable worked from a Display Port Monitor to HDMI?

    I have a Dell U2412 Monitor With Display Port and need to get a HDMI Adapter that actually works. "

    Any cheap HDMI to DVI adaptor should work ok.

    I don't tink the Dell U2412 has speakers does it, so do you need to go to the trouble of converting HDMI to DP?  If your video card/source has HDMI it would be much cheaper and easier to get a HDMI to DVI cable or adaptor and use that since the Dell U2412 has a DVI port as well as DP and VGA.  DVI and HDMI use the same digital signaling standards for the video just HDMI also has digital audio lines which are missing on DVI and they use a different connector, but there is no need for active conversion as there would be going HDMI/DVI to DP, hence much cheaper adaptors/converters.  If your video source has DVI then just use the DVI to DVI cable that came with the monitor.

    Hope this helps, if it doesn't then more info about your setup (video card model or video source) might help us give you more apropriate answers.

  • 1908

    0

    Posted December 23rd, 2011 21:00

    Thanks for the tip.  I had a bad cable and wasn't patient enough to wait for another so I ripped out pin 20 with an exacto knife and tweezers on the displayport end and it worked!

    This is a risky mod though that I wouldn't recommend.  Pin 20 is hot and if you mess this up you could create a short.