UNSOLVED

markcars

updated

21 years ago

M

markcars

4 Posts

0

14106

September 15th, 2005 17:00

Dell 2405FP Monitor blurred images with movies

I purchased a brand new DELL 2405 monitor which I absolutely love when it comes to output from the PC. Icons, text etc have no complaints from me. I am pleased with all that. However when I hook up a DVD player to it and watch movies, the quality is like a blurred image! I even tried using the expensive component video cables which deliver crisp and extremely sharp images on my Sony 32" TV and 42 inch Panasonic Flat screen TV from the same DVD player, but when hooked up to my Dell 2405, the quality totally dissapoints me.
I mean when I see a car I cannot even see the hub clearly. Even movie title text is quite blurred and hazy. People almost seem to have 4 eyes instead of 2!! Is there something that needs to be done to watch regular video input?

Thanks

Mark
  • korrson

    1 Rookie

    •

    592 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 15th, 2005 23:00

    Its called ghosting and is still a problem with LCD monitors.

    That why for gaming (fast action) many still use analog monitors.

    Or you pay extra for ones with a low response time. Its a number in milliseconds.
    The lower the number the higher the price usually.
  • Dingram

    20 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 16th, 2005 02:00

    That sounds pretty bad... I've had my 2405 for almost two weeks and have watched movies every day through my laptop computer (connected via VGA port).  No problems here.. all images and movement is crisp and clear.

     

     

     

     

  • markcars

    4 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 16th, 2005 16:00

    I have been using computers for over 20 years now and LCDs since they started coming out in the market. My Sony 18.5 inch costed me about $1500 with extended warranty at Circuit City when I bought it, but never saw such bad performance with an LCD monitor in the past. I have 5 other LCD monitors, a Sony 18.5 inch, 2 NEC 17inch, a NEC 15 inch and a Samsung 17 inch. Also have four laptops, (A Toshiba, a compaq presario x1000, a dell and a sony vaio all of which I have no complaints about) I am extremely pleased with their performance even when I view movies on them. I know what ghosting is, but unfortunately never saw one with this terrible performance when it comes to movie video.

    What can I do now? Upon reading other members' problems, I don't want to even try to exchange this one for fear of getting something with other problems which I do not want.

    I will just keep it for my PC and get a real TV (either plasma or DLP or LCos).

    I was just hoping for something that I did not get. At least it is extremely nice for my PC. All icons and text are upto or surpass my standards. A test pattern displayed on the monitor show perfect results. No complaints in that area.
  • korrson

    1 Rookie

    •

    592 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2005 00:00

    Thanks for the extra information, I was just guessing with the limited data you posted.

    OK if Dell has cheapened out and this model has a slow response time and you're not happy with it ...return it right away..you only have 3 weeks I believe.
    Then you can select another from a store where you can try it out before you buy.

    That is a problem when you buy online and you can't SEE the monitor in action.
    Good luck in your decision!
  • parkerti

    610 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2005 01:00

    The 2405 has a 12ms response time. The original poster should not be experiencing ghosting with that response time. I feel his problem lies elsewhere but I am not sure where.
  • SatireWolf

    41 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2005 02:00

    Your problem is in the input conversion. The 2405fpw was never meant as a gamer/movie screen, and it has a VERY cheap scaler (ie, your 480P input is being scaled to 1080 something).

    The scaler / analogue input is the issue. If you used a dvd player with a dvi output and it's own built in scaler (ie. samsung with a 1080i or 720p upscale and dvi output) you wouldn't have this issue.

    It's in the electronics before it ever hits the screen. There's just too much noise on the analogue inputs and the scaler is doing a darn poor job of dealing with it.

    Either use digital inputs or return the monitor. The guys who have recorded 'lagged' video used rgb inputs and the noise on the inputs is what caused the problem primarily.

    P.S. the rgb cables that come with LCD's are VERY poor cables. If it's not half to three quarters of an inch in diameter, it's not shielded properly.
  • korrson

    1 Rookie

    •

    592 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 19th, 2005 01:00

    Thanks SatireWolf
    This is one reason I have not bought a HD TV yet.
    I have an older DVD player and I know that can make movies look terrible on a HD screen TV with 1080 resolution... so I stick with my old analog Sony Wega TV.

    >>The scaler / analogue input is the issue. If you used a dvd player with a dvi output and it's own built in scaler (ie. samsung with a 1080i or 720p upscale and dvi output) you wouldn't have this issue.<<<


    >>deliver crisp and extremely sharp images on my Sony 32" TV and 42 inch Panasonic Flat screen TV from the same DVD player, but when hooked up to my Dell 2405, the quality totally dissapoints me.<<<

    So are the Sony 32" TV and 42 inch Panasonic Flat screen TV analog???
    I love my Sony 36" analog Wega. It makes DVDs look better than my sister's big digial HD screen but then I will have to check now what DVD player she is using.

    Message Edited by korrson on 09-18-2005 09:57 PM

  • SatireWolf

    41 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 19th, 2005 22:00

    Well your sony/panasonic screens have very advanced scaler's/filters for analog noise. If you're using RCA cables for input it's analog. They're built to deal with imperfect inputs, computer monitors aren't.

    The point is that you buy home theater equipment with high end Silicon Image and other quality scaler's to ensure that your output video looks fine when your inputs are lower resolution than your output.

    Scaler chips can cost upwards of 100 dollars, thus quality DVD players often cost 500+ dollars to get a superb output for high end displays.
  • markcars

    4 Posts

    396

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2005 14:00

    I just prefer keeping it for what it does best, PC work. For movies, I've decided to purchase something more professional after my next move.  For now I am enjoying my Viewsonic projector on my 80 inch glass beaded screen and a Harman Kardon sound system that pleases me without any complaints.     
     
    As for the cables, I wonder why they let you use Component cables when the quality does not even surpass (or even near) regular Composite.  I did use a very expensive component cable (My monitor did not come with any component cables) hoping to enjoy  some movies. I guess I can use those cables on my next purchase of a good TV.
     
    thanks.
  • SatireWolf

    41 Posts

    258

    0

    Posted September 20th, 2005 16:00



    @markcars wrote:
    I just prefer keeping it for what it does best, PC work. For movies, I've decided to purchase something more professional after my next move. For now I am enjoying my Viewsonic projector on my 80 inch glass beaded screen and a Harman Kardon sound system that pleases me without any complaints.
    As for the cables, I wonder why they let you use Component cables when the quality does not even surpass (or even near) regular Composite. I did use a very expensive component cable (My monitor did not come with any component cables) hoping to enjoy some movies. I guess I can use those cables on my next purchase of a good TV.
    thanks.





    Why? Marketing gimmic....