UNSOLVED

ajw798

updated

20 years ago

A

ajw798

2 Posts

0

7020

June 9th, 2006 10:00

2005wfp : How much banding is acceptable?

As above.
I'm not sure how much banding is acceptable for such a monitor. I've bought mine recently and now I'm on my first replacement (there won't be another, I'll make a fuss till I get a refund) and having heard about the various banding/luminosity issues, I'd like to know what I *should* see! I'm get banding under WOW mostly in the atmosphere/sky as seen in previous screenshots.
Cheers
Anthony

Message Edited by ajw798 on 06-09-200606:44 AM

  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    233

    0

    Posted June 9th, 2006 14:00

    ajw798,

    Where are the screenshots? Have you tried other games?


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • njchris

    4 Posts

    233

    0

    Posted June 9th, 2006 20:00

    I thought I read the banding in WoW was due to the game itself and not the display.  That a recent patch had introduced it into the game.

    Can anyone else comment, esp since I didnt think the 2005xx monitors had banding issues.

  • Venthos

    7 Posts

    233

    0

    Posted June 10th, 2006 00:00

    The "banding" in WoW (At least in reference to the sky materials) is part of the game itself.

    I confirmed this by taking an in-game screenshot (not a camera photo) of the problem and asking a friend with a CRT to view it. He reported the banding was there for him as well.

    I'd encourage everyone to do the same if they suspect banding, take a screenshot (not a photo with your camera) and show it to a friend with a CRT. If they still see the graphics anomaly, then it's part of the game or your game's settings. If they see no banding, the fault lies with your display/monitor.
  • ajw798

    2 Posts

    233

    0

    Posted June 10th, 2006 09:00

    Well that's good to know. I generally very disappointed with the monitor mostly for it's highly ununiform luminosity but I wanted to make sure about the banding specifically in WOW so not to complain about something which has nothing to do with the monitor in the epic "You will refund me" letter I'm in the process of writing.
     
    I'm having a run of bad luck with computers at the moment. I recently bought (not from DELL) a $4000+ machine in parts and have had nothing but problems (first time I've bought anything from another vendor - I'm responsable for 10+ DELL purchases so I would consider myself a "good customer" ). I managed to get a full refund and was considering a XPS Platinum but then this monitor issue popped up so it's in DELL interest to refund me quickly.
     
    Could someone point me to an URL where I should see no banding in order for me to test this as WOW doesn't seem like a good benchmark after all?
     
    Cheers
     
    Anthony

    Message Edited by ajw798 on 06-10-200605:21 AM