UNSOLVED

FatMonk

updated

15 years ago

F

FatMonk

21 Posts

0

35227

January 27th, 2012 08:00

XPS15z Audio crackling/stuttering - Wired Ethernet related

There seems to be a number of problems with the audio on the XPS15z and in numerous forums posts the multiple issues are getting confused.

I have started this thread to seperate out one of those specific audio issues so that we can try to avoid some of the confusion.

** Please only post to this thread if you have confirmed that your audio issue is related to the Atheros WIRED ethernet adapter (See below for a method to test this) **

(This thread IS NOT for those whose audio problems are due to the WiFi / Wireless adapter or the audio card or any other part of the machine. Atheros WIRED ethernet related problem only here please)

If you do have the problem and can solve it by disabling the WIRED ethernet adapter, then please post here to confirm that you are another user affected by this. I have seen at least half a dozen users who have confirmed this, and we need to gather all of those people in one place to be able to prove to Dell that this problem is real and needs to be fixed.

HOW TO CHECK IF YOURS IS THE WIRED PROBLEM:

It's really very simple, but this process will prove it one way or another.

1. Power up your XPS15z.

2. Make sure your WIRED ethernet adapter is enabled.

3. Disconnect your ethernet cable if it is connected (this is to remove an network traffic on the wired port.

4. Disable Wireless networking.

5. Turn UP your sound.

6. Make sure you have a Windows startup sound selected (the longer the better - the default works for me) and that it plays.

7. Reboot your XPS15z into Windows 7.

When Windows starts listen for any distortion, crackling or stuttering in the Windows startup sound.

If you do hear the crackling then proceed to step 8.

If you do not hear the crackling then open a locally stored music file and try playing that a few times.

8. Disable your WIRED ethernet adapter.

9. Reboot into Windows 7 again.

If you do NOT hear the crackling then it looks like you have the same issue that I have. Please post to this thread to let Dell know. You may want to confirm with a longer test so try playing local audio files again.

If you DO hear the crackling then your audio issue may be one of the other problems with this machine - there are other threads for these other issues.

The reason for disabling all networking and playing audio only files is so that network traffic and video decoding cannot be blamed for the stuttering. A number of people have noticed spikes on their CPUs or their network adapters which would potentially cause the audio to stutter. However the problem that I have with my machine - and it would seems a number of others have - happens with no network load and no other (significant) applications running.

I can actually reproduce this fault simply by playing an audio file with the thernet adapter enabled -> disabling the ethernet adapter (crackling stops) -> enabling the adapter (crackling starts) ->disabling the adapter ... etc etc. For some people the problem seems slightly more intermittent, but it is real.

WHAT WE KNOW SO FAR:

- No Dell provided drivers have fixed this yet (as of 27/1/2012).

- There is a later Lenovo driver for the Atheros ethernet adapter that has possibly fixed this problem for some (not me unfortunately!)

- This issue appears NOT to be hardware related. This was proven by installing Linux (Ubuntu 11.10) where the audio crackling is never present. (See warning below)

- Currently everything points to a dodgy driver for this ethernet adapter. However it is possible tha it could be something interacting with that - we obviously need Dell to look at this properly.

WHAT DELL HAVE DONE SO FAR:

There are a number of reports of people having had motherboards, audio cards and wireless cards replaced to try to resolve this issue. I have not come across any posts wher ethis has fixed the issue for anyone.

WARNING re Linux

When I contacted Dell regarding another issue I am having with the XPS15z (Sudden, total power loss) they at first refused to support the system under warranty as I had installed Ubuntu as a dual boot. They said that this was a system modification and so I would have to pay for support. After further discussion they are going to support the machine (and why shouldn't they - installing software, especially that doesn't touch the pre-installed OS(!), should not affect warranty status of a computer). I mention this so that if you do decide to install a second OS you know that Dell may not be overly happy. You could always run Linux off a Live CD if you wanted to test the audio anyway - no need to actually install it.

-FM

  • cmespinoza

    34 Posts

    1320

    0

    Posted January 27th, 2012 09:00

    Very complete summary, thanks for creating the post and outlining the walkthrough as well.  

    I had the same issue and I can't for the life of me know exactly what "resolved" the issue.  I've installed/uninstalled so many versions of different drivers that I don't know what worked.  I'm currently plugged and streaming music from the ethernet, with wireless on (though not connected to any network) and without noticeable issues.  At times if I listen carefully I can probably minor crackling/popping sounds, but it's a far cry from the aggravating cacophony I had a few months ago.

    If there's a way for me to print out all my drivers and versions, perhaps I can post them here so all can compare and maybe get to the point I'm at.  I'll point out that I am running with the updated Lenovo Atheros driver.  Good luck.

  • cmespinoza

    34 Posts

    1320

    0

    Posted January 30th, 2012 09:00

    Below are my current network drivers that may have corrected the Atheros sound crackling issue.  I used a free tool called DevManView to export.  I hope this helps.

    ==================================================

    Device Name       : Atheros AR8151 PCI-E Gigabit Ethernet Controller (NDIS 6.20)

    Manufacturer      : Atheros

    Service           : L1C

    Device Type Code  : Net

    Device Type Name  : Network adapters

    Device Instance ID: PCI\VEN_1969&DEV_1083&SUBSYS_04461028&REV_C0\4&2b33c337&0&00E5

    Location          : @system32\drivers\pci.sys,#65536;PCI bus %1, device %2, function %3;(6,0,0)

    Capabilities      : 0x00000000

    Config Flags      : 0x00000000

    Disabled          : No

    Connected         : Yes

    Device Registry Time 1: 1/27/2012 3:17:17 PM

    Device Registry Time 2: 1/27/2012 3:17:17 PM

    Drive Letter      :

    Driver Description: Atheros AR8151 PCI-E Gigabit Ethernet Controller (NDIS 6.20)

    Driver Version    : 1.0.2.43

    .inf File         : oem15.inf

    .inf Section      : L1D2.ndi

    Driver Date       : 3/22/2011

    Driver Registry Time: 1/3/2012 6:05:10 PM

    ==================================================

    ==================================================

    Device Name       : Intel(R) Centrino(R) Advanced-N 6230

    Manufacturer      : Intel Corporation

    Service           : NETwNs64

    Device Type Code  : Net

    Device Type Name  : Network adapters

    Device Instance ID: PCI\VEN_8086&DEV_0091&SUBSYS_52218086&REV_34\4&26c31eff&0&00E1

    Location          : @system32\drivers\pci.sys,#65536;PCI bus %1, device %2, function %3;(3,0,0)

    Capabilities      : 0x00000000

    Config Flags      : 0x00000000

    Disabled          : No

    Connected         : Yes

    Device Registry Time 1: 1/27/2012 3:17:17 PM

    Device Registry Time 2: 1/27/2012 3:17:17 PM

    Drive Letter      :

    Driver Description: Intel(R) Centrino(R) Advanced-N 6230

    Driver Version    : 14.2.1.1

    .inf File         : oem66.inf

    .inf Section      : Install_MPCIEX_Dell_6230_AGN_2x2_HMC_WIN7_64_MOW

    Driver Date       : 9/15/2011

    Driver Registry Time: 12/14/2011 3:14:08 PM

    ==================================================

  • dwyejj

    1 Message

    1320

    0

    Posted February 3rd, 2012 06:00

    Confirmed.  I have the same audio problem on my XPS 15z, core i7 sandy bridge processor.  Machine was delivered in mid Jan. 2012.

    Thanks for the organized post.

    JD

  • cmespinoza

    34 Posts

    1320

    0

    Posted February 3rd, 2012 08:00

    This is worth a try.  I remember updating this driver around the time my audio / network issues cleared up.

  • IanEvs79

    20 Posts

    1320

    0

    Posted February 3rd, 2012 08:00

    Have you tried installing the newest Intel Rapid Storage Technology driver? That has helped with a similar issue on many peoples machines.

  • 1320

    0

    Posted February 17th, 2012 12:00

    This has something to do with Wireless Driver, as soon as I plug in my wired, crackling stops....

  • cmespinoza

    34 Posts

    1320

    0

    Posted February 17th, 2012 12:00

    Also, try turning off "Enable Dell Extended Battery Life" in the Battery Meter window.  My CPU usage and performance goes hayware whenever it's enabled, and I heard some stutter.

  • FatMonk

    21 Posts

    1320

    0

    Posted March 22nd, 2012 11:00

    A quick update on my latest with this issue...

    I had my machine replaced a month or so ago due to a hardware fault (I've described the fault elsewhere, but essentially the machine would instantly lose power for no apparent reason!). The repair was with second hand parts and the case got damaged. The replacement case parts were also second hand and as the machine had never worked properly from new I argues my case with Dell and got a brand new machine.

    The new machine had exactly this same problem out of the box on day 1 before I tried restoring my system backups..

    I disabled the WIRED ethernet driver and the problem went away.

    I've tried disabling the Wireless card but the problem persists. I have all the latest drivers installed including the Rapid Storage driver but the problem persists. I've disabled and removed McAfee but the problem persists.

    The only way of getting rid of the crackling/stuttering is to disable the Atheros ethernet driver as a number of others have found.

    As I've said in the first post in this thread, reading aroudn the forums there seems to be a few different problems causing similar symptoms, but I find it odd that a brand new replacement machine has exactly the same problem, solved in exactly the same way for me.

    What's more, the new machine has had a number of components upgraded by way of compensation for the problems I'd been having with the old machine (i5->i7, 4GB->8GB, nVidia 512MB -> nVidia 1GB, HDD 500GB -> 750GB), so it's not even identical hardware causing an identical problem.

    I still haven;t had a chance to check my driver versions against cmespinoza's versions, and I haven't tried the Extended battery life settings either, but I believe I've tried everything else suggested on the forums and by Dell themselves.

    -FM

  • 1320

    0

    Posted July 2nd, 2012 23:00

    After searching the whole computer settings....ahhh what a relief. Now the errrr sound which used to come is gone  

    Here is the solution for it...!

    1. click on start.

    2. type msconfig in the search box and open it.

    3. click on the boot tab.

    4. click on the "Advanced Option" button.

    5. Clear the "Number of Processors" checkbox and also the maximum memory checkbox.

    6. Click on "OK"

    7.  Click on Ok

    8. Click on Restart now.

    Please let me know if it helped you. Cause it really helped me. The dpc latency bars go red, but the audio doesn't crackle.