UNSOLVED

jmfsms

updated

17 years ago

J

jmfsms

3 Posts

1

112271

February 18th, 2010 00:00

XPS M2010 Black Screen Of Death

Several times I have had my M2010 screen freeze and then not come up at all on a reboot.

The machine is under warranty and typically they send a tech out with a motherboard which does not fix the problem.  Then the tech who pretty much knows its the video card has them send a new video card which does fix the problem and the machine works beautifully again.

However, several months later the card blows again and I have to do the whole process again which knocks out my computer usually when I need it most.  Now I keep all my data externally with expections of it breaking down (not how I expected it to work).  I am also afraid of the $200 cost of a new video card when my service contract runs out.

I have bought Dell computers throughout the years and have never had a redundant problem like this and hope that perhaps if enough people can get together to show them the need to address this problem they will.  I love the M2010 laptop and fixing this problem would make it the machine of my dreams.

So, if you have this problem I can almost guarantee a new video card will fix it but please reply to this message so that we may build a list of machines with the same problem and ask dell to address it.

I hope this helps and in addition to my posting here suggesting that everyone with this problem get together I am going to e-mail dell and post any responses here.

  • belboy3

    263 Posts

    1526

    0

    Posted February 19th, 2010 08:00

    jmfsms,

      You bring an interesting and I'm sure on going point about the video card in the M2010.

    I can tell you that I have had my card replaced twice last year. The first time my unit was shipped back to the "depot" to be fixed as it would not turn on at all. Replaced the video card and bluetooth module. Two weeks later, it started again. Tech support wanted me to reinstall my OS but I refused and convinced them to replace the video card again which they did. Haven't had a problem since to this date.

    I recently upgraded to Win7 64 bit and am running better than ever, including a new 320gb HDD. The thing I will tell you is that Dell is going to do nothing as they have not and will not release any new drivers for Win 7 support to help people with these legacy machines. I upgraded only because of the many other diligent minds around the globe who persued the upgrade inspite of Dell.

      I feel we are on our own to keep our computers running especially when our warranties run out. They only care about the new machines they are selling and don't care about all the different legacy computers out there, some hardly over a year old. Look at the forums and you'll see all the problems people are having upgrading because there is no support and very few computers are listed  as compatible on Dell's support website. If yours isn't there, then you are on your own.

    Good luck with this.

  • jmfsms

    3 Posts

    1526

    0

    Posted February 19th, 2010 13:00

    I have sent the following e-mail to Dell Tech Support and I will keep everyone posted as to their response:

    I am currently having my Dell M2010 serviced again for a video card that does not work.  As usual a tech has already replaced the motherboard and now I have to ship it back to Dell.

    Long story short, this is a known issue (can find examples all over the web) and I would like to know if dell knows the cause of the card blowing or is looking into this issue as I believe that there is a flaw.

    Secondly, I am curious why Dell is not supporting system 7 upgrades for this machine which is more than capable of running this os.

    Finally, I would like to know a contact (e-mail) at Dell who can explain these issues to me and what is being done to correct them.

    Thank You For Your Time -Jay M. Foster

  • tknofrank

    1 Message

    1526

    0

    Posted September 22nd, 2010 12:00

    My story is exactly the same as your, now i'm out of the hell warranty so it made tree video cards i change myself..thing that i do bether than any hell tech..

    they also said to me that if a problem that hapened many times under waranty was going to apear out of warranty,they will considere it to be factory defect and still honore the waranty...

    no need to tell you that was all lies..they told me to buy $400 around warranty for extra years..or nothing from them..

    i talked ,i waited, i yelled at them ,..but i just realised that the problem is too heavy and widespreaded for them to resolve it and they just stopped manifacturing the product.

    all this for a stuppid video card overheating problem.. 

    the machine of my dreams took one year to turn into a nightmare machine, now it works verry whell ...i bought a HP laptop and use this $5000 dream machine to hold my HP laptop a little higher on the desk ,a wonderfull dock station, and some days when i feel brave i turn it on few moment ,do the windows updates and then power off and duck it under my always working HP ...

     

    I remember when i bought it, they still offer choice between 128 meg and 256meg vidéo card..i badly regret the choice i maide then..

     

    Hell XPS M2010

    Intel centrino duo  CPU

    T7400 @ 2.16 ghz 2.17ghz

    ATI Mobility Radeon X1800

    4GB Mem

    BIOS A06

    Win XP 32

  • crc2

    92 Posts

    1526

    0

    Posted September 23rd, 2010 12:00

    Hi guys,

    Sorry to learn of your experiences but maybe you might benefit from knowing you are not alone. The M2010 hit all the right 'good looks' button, but what laid beneath in the motherboard are design issues waiting to go off. The black screen of death plagued purchasers, calling for one motherboard after another, and graphics card, is but one example of a poorly balanced assembly. I suspect voltage issues are partly to blame. 

    The most infamous issue however, has been the odd bluetooth assembly calling for three different sets of programming to force it to work. From my experience this is  fact. That is to say Toshiba's bluetooth stack, the CRS chip driver, and Bell's own belt and braces of a driver was a doomed collaberation waiting like a time bomb. Boot into the DOS start up screen never a problem. But when Windows took over! The latter often called for another mobo and as these are usually handed out by engineers second hand, it was only a matter of time before lifting the phone up again.

    And if either of these popular breakdowns didn't get you, the forums are alive with other issues.

    Switching from Vista to Win7 fixed the bluetooth bug, but did not or apparently could not fix all underlying incompatabilities. In my case the first 18 months produced a regular call for help but the M2010 managed to limp along as I chewed wasps every other month. After that it was down hill having seen 5 mobos, 4 graphic cards, replacement RAM and CPU; I finally let off steam and Dell offered to buy the M2010 back providing I paid at least £1,200 to buy a replacement system. Which I did at the equivalent price of £2,500. Now two months on I am planning to replace the mobo because I really need more outputs than the mini mobo supplied can provide, but in any case I want a retail mobo with manfacturer's gaurantee, not a cobbled one from an assembler.

    I also need more power than Dell provide in their low value PSU (against ATI recommendations for an HD5770 graphics card), and I need SATAIII and USB3 which Dell are either shy of promoting or haven't yet fathomed out how they can cut corners on the next PC generation in order to hold prices for sake of added profit.

    I am sure you can see where I am coming from. Power supply issues? Incompatibility? Cut backs? Poor designs?

    Good luck and best wishes,

    CRC2

     

     

      

     

       

  • jlouton

    1 Message

    1526

    0

    Posted October 15th, 2010 23:00

     

     

  • Bijilo

    4 Posts

    1526

    0

    Posted October 16th, 2010 11:00

    Nice one mate!

    I'm in the UK and am unable to acess dell support and am using this friendly forum to help me out with my problem.

    My mext one won't be Dell though!

     

  • Jason51482

    16 Posts

    1526

    0

    Posted November 11th, 2010 07:00

    Are you guys getting the same thing I'm getting?


    When you open up the laptop, press the power button.  Watch the blue lights go across the DVD/RW drive.  On the far left the power light will be on or it will be a little dimmed and the Working/Hard drive light will come on for a brief time then you are left with nothing but a power light and you can hear the fans spinning?

  • belboy3

    263 Posts

    1536

    0

    Posted November 11th, 2010 08:00

    JASON51482,

      Sorry about your troubles. I have had the same experience multiple times since new in 2007 and it's usually the video card has failed. Dell always wants to replace the mobo to fix this but they always end up replacing the video card as well. Hope your still under warranty.

    I know this is not what you want to hear but good luck.

  • crc2

    92 Posts

    1536

    0

    Posted November 11th, 2010 09:00

    Hi Jason51482,

    Just to confer with bellboy3, it's not good news and we don't help telling you it's really the norm for Dell. We all learn the hard way so either get Dell to do the usual if you can, and plan forward, so that next time you don't end up in a straight jacket. CRC2

  • G33kG1rl

    30 Posts

    933

    0

    Posted November 13th, 2010 10:00

    Same problem for me. 3 times in 3 months. Today is the 3rd time and Im livid. Ive had everything replaced twice. I love this machine. But this is ridiculous.