
UNSOLVED
Closed
A
ArchStudent
25 Posts
0
17089
December 5th, 2003 15:00
Thanks Rollie! (for the video upgrade thread and some hope)
Hey everyone,
I just wanted to say thanks to the Dell moderator Rollie for giving us some hope :)
Even if we can't get the upgrades we want right now, at least in the future there is a good possibility that it will happen. Here is one thing though, I don't think that it would be possible to upgrade older models with video cards (like a Dell Inspiron 4000 series) just because it would be a waste of time to try and make something work with older technology...
trying to make an older (a few years at least) notebook accept a new graphics card might be like trying to put a ATI 9800 XT video card into a Pentium 233MHz desktop, where the video card isn't being used to its full potential.
Just my take on it, and please remember to keep any discussions off topic in the video card upgrade thread (Which is just a "yes I would like Dell to make video card upgrades possible in notebooks") out of the thread!
It is annoying to see that some people are going off topic and discussing other things (Video card comparisons, and people commenting on other peoples' threads) instead of just saying "yeas I would love it if Dell offered video card upgrades".
Thanks again Rollie!
Responses (14)
Solutions (0)
ArchStudent
25 Posts
1518
0
Posted December 5th, 2003 21:00
You are correct about those points, there are a lot of factors to consider.
Also, I don't think Dell would want any of their clients to end up with a new component that would give unforseen problems that might affect their system related to heat or power consumption. Also, with the way that technology is changing it is impossible to keep up with the latest innovations, unless you have a money bin like Scrooge McDuck... I think that in 6 months there will be a new video card that everyone is going to want in their notebooks.
Had I waited until now, I would have bought the Inspiron 8600 for the ATI 9600, but instead I bought a Inspiron 600m. I'm sure there are many people who keep waiting, and waiting for something to come along, and once they have boughten it, something even newer and better comes along... that is the way things are. You can not please everyone, but the majority do seem pleased and that is what counts.
Eventually when upgrades are planned into notebook designs (just like desktop/tower systems) there will be a whole new market to cater to. I know that current and existing notebooks may not be able to have upgraded video cards (except for a few) but I think that in the future, newer Dell notebooks will allow for various video card upgrades. I think that the sales would be there if there were effective marketing, and by word of mouth (which is still the best and fastest way to draw in new clients in my opinion).
There is one final thing Rollie, and I was wondering when you hear something from your superiors or co-workers about the video card upgrade thread you started (provided you have enough people voicing their opinions for this option), perhaps you wouldn't mind letting us know what the feedback you received was?
Thanks again :)
VanDraegon
16 Posts
1518
0
Posted December 5th, 2003 22:00
Realistically, how long can we expect to wait before some sort of official word is given on whether or no those of us with newer laptops will be allowed a supported upgrade? Be it self upgraded or sent in.
In my case i had been shopping for months and months for a laptop and had always wanted a Inspiron, i just wanted a 128 MB video card. When the i8600 was announced i ordered within 1 week of seeing them on the website.
One week later the nVidia/Half-Life 2 fiasco broke. ATI had further cemented their lead. Not only was this depressing for a GeForce enthusiast, but to find out just how poorly the nVidia cards compare to the ATI ones in Dx9. Very depressing news for a gamer. Now i have had my 8600 about 2.5 months and the ATI card is out.
Oy Vey.
I sure hope Dell gives us some love.
ArchStudent
25 Posts
1589
0
Posted December 7th, 2003 20:00
just saying thanks to Rollie...
sheesh, sometimes i wonder about some of the people posting that are too lazy to read what is being said, or misunderstand
ArchStudent
25 Posts
1589
0
Posted December 7th, 2003 21:00
ooooh, that hurt... boo hoo...
- Sheesh, sometimes i wonder about some of the people posting that just like to complain to much. To make them shelf feel better then everyone else. I was commenting with my feellings and if you need on comment on this you have issues. Thank all at dell and rollie
What's even sadder....the person posting doesn't even have removable video....kinda hard to upgrade what is physically impossible to. HAd he a removable one, he'd have some grounds to argue, but then he'd have misplaced his argument in this post lol.
Either way, i guess some people just like to senselessly complain -g-
---
VanDraegon
16 Posts
1589
0
Posted December 8th, 2003 02:00
Could this not turn into a flame fest? I am actually curious to know when/if Dell will make some announcement on this asap.Message Edited by VanDraegon on 12-08-2003 04:28 PM
All,
The long thread on video upgrades has been seen by others at Dell. The only response so far has been that older systems are unlikely to get upgrades because of heat and power problems. Beyond that there has been no official response
Please understand that there is little that I can do, except to monitor the thread, and to make sure that others at Dell see it. I am not in a position where I will have any input into the decision making process.

Rollie_R
2 Intern
•
2248 Posts
1518
0
Posted December 5th, 2003 19:00
ArchStudent,
Thank you for using the Dell Community Forum.
There are several things that work against older systems getting supported video upgrades.
First, there is the expense of producing and testing cards. Each card that was offered as an upgrade would have to produced in a form factor for each system, and then tested to ensure that it would operate correctly. This expense would exist for all systems, but would be worse for older, out of production systems.
Second, there are heat and power problems. Each generation of video cards produces more heat, and some require more power than older cards. Some older systems will not have enough power, or heat dissipation for the new cards.
Third, there is the sales consideration. Will Dell be able to sell enough upgrades to pay the expense of my first point.
All of these are questions for which I have no answers.