UNSOLVED

principalj

updated

22 years ago

Closed

P

principalj

97 Posts

0

17675

January 7th, 2005 03:00

Inspiron 9200 and Firewire Static Sound

I just recently purchased an Edirol Firewire audio capture box to make some professional recordings with my new 9200 laptop. I was disappointed however when I tried to make recordings because I had static/clicking noises during the recording or playback of the music.
 
I tried to isolate the problem - at first suspecting the Firewire device - but it worked fine in my friend's Prostar laptop. I checked all the usual suspects and posted questions on other forums related to the music industry and contacted Edirol tech support.
 
It looked like IRQ's were a likely culprit. Checking in Device Manager showed that many devices on the 9200 use IRQ ll - video, firewire, USB ports (all 4), the cardbus controller and the Broadcom Ethernet controller! My friend's Prostar had these devices evenly split between IRQ 10 & 11.
 
I noticed however that the noise went away when I connected the laptop in my computer room. Now I suspected a power problem. The noise existed everywhere else in the house except there. But when I brought it back in the noise was also there until I plugged in the USB mouse! That explains why it worked fine at my computer desk - I always plugged the mouse in there.
 
I wanted to use the laptop on the road without a mouse, but it seems like plugging something into the USB ports stops the 9200 from doing something when the ports are not used and causing the static noises that ruin the firewire recordings.
 
I tried disabling everything possible on IRQ 11 in the device manager without change (only the video and the Firewire were left). The static/clicking noise remained the same until I enabled at least one USB port and plugged something into it.
 
What gives with this? Anyone have any wisdom to shed on where the noise comes from? Is it possible a BIOS update could fix this? (Or something else - a driver update maybe?)
 
Right now the workaround appears to be to use a Firewire device with something plugged into the USB port. There were stories of people with problems with Dell laptops and Firewire devices - maybe my experience is not unique and there is a possibly simple fix for this issue.
 
 
  • principalj

    97 Posts

    275

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 00:00

    Well, I've done some more research. After going through my MSCONFIG and running processes - I was able to delete/disable about 50 Mb's of running processes that either didn't apply to this laptop, or were unnecessary.

    I still have the interruptions on the firewire output however.

    I noticed that when I disable the network interfaces (the wireless, the Ethernet and the 1394 net adaptor) I don't get any interruption in the sound.

    As soon as I enable the wireless network adaptor, I get an interruption in the sound every 60 seconds. There is a spike in the processor load to 24% once every minute but only when the wireless card is enabled. Is that normal or is there something I can enable/disable to stop that? (Besides disabling the adaptor completely).

  • principalj

    97 Posts

    275

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2005 01:00

    Well, with a new install and using all the proper drivers from the Dell website, I've completely reloaded onto a new 60 Gbyte, 7200 RPM drive.

    I still have the intermittent interruption in the sound with my Firewire audio once every 60 seconds when the Wireless card is enabled. Anyone care to venture a reason for this?

    The wireless card I have is a Dell 1450. Does anyone have any experience with the equivalent Intel wireless card? Should I make a change? Or is the interruption inherent in the way wireless Ethernet devices operate?

     

  • Junkymagi

    23 Posts

    281

    0

    Posted February 7th, 2005 01:00

    hmm, check the connections on the wireless card
    there are 2 wires that clip to the card inside the access panel under the computer
    make sure they are tight
    might want to make sure they aren't shorting out by putting a spot of tape on each one
    maybe static buildup??

    shooting into the breeze here
  • principalj

    97 Posts

    275

    0

    Posted February 7th, 2005 01:00

    Still on the trail of the problem. I tried shutting off my wireless router while the Dell wireless card was enabled, but I still have the once every 60 second dropouts.

    I disabled the card and connected a Linksys USB wireless adaptor. Installation went without a hitch and there are no more dropouts. I'm typing this while using the Firewire adaptor without problem.

    So, it appears that something about the internal wireless card interacts with the system to cause a dropout every 60 seconds. Is this a feature or a problem?

    Can anyone shed any light on this? Could the forum moderators pass on my troubleshooting path to a technical person who might be able to help?

    Some guesses I might have are that the card is functioning as it should and there is a check for something every 60 seconds (contact with a network, power saving options, interaction with another program, etc.). If that is not other people's experience I'd sure like to hear from them,...

    Any solutions would be greatly appreciated of course
  • principalj

    97 Posts

    281

    0

    Posted February 7th, 2005 10:00

    Will look into that - although I don't understand how static could cause a dropout every 60 seconds exactly. I've timed it with a stopwatch - and it's always right on the money.
  • alan112

    4 Posts

    281

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2005 03:00

    I am having the same problem.  Didn't realize it even though I've had the system for awhile now.  Started trying to capture some DV and the static started.  Have you found the solution to this problem????  I have tried plugging something into one of the USB ports but it didn't help.  Please let me know if you have found a fix.

     

    Thanks

  • principalj

    97 Posts

    281

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2005 10:00

    Yes I have. Follow the thread all the way through to the end of the messages. 2 of us with similar problems have both found ways to solve it. Email me again if you need a little more help.
  • alan112

    4 Posts

    281

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2005 13:00

    Okay if I read this correctly it seems the only way to solve this problem is to completely disable the internal wireless card and go back to using an external one, is this correct?  I haven't checked the wires on the card as of yet, was this also a fix?  Any help would be great.  Also has a tech bothered getting back to you on this?

     

    Thanks for the help.

  • principalj

    97 Posts

    281

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2005 22:00

    I just disable it on the desktop - it only takes a second, and I re-enable it when I want to use the wireless. I right click on "My Network Places", then select "Properties". Right click over the "wireless adaptor" and select disable. That's what I did until I replaced the Dell wireless card with the Intel wireless card. The Intel card doesn't seem to have this problem.

    The static I had stopped as long as I had something plugged into the USB ports (I use my wireless mouse). When nothing was plugged into the USB ports I had static noise when I used the Firewire.

    You don't have to disconnect anything.

  • alan112

    4 Posts

    156

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2005 23:00

    Thanks for the help, I'll give it a try.