UNSOLVED

sLaShEr_PsI

updated

22 years ago

Closed

S

sLaShEr_PsI

62 Posts

0

11386

April 27th, 2005 01:00

Dell 8500/8600 Video Upgrade Question(s)

Hi,
I'm looking into buying and inspiron 8500 or 8600 and I was wondering if I could use one of the 8600's 128mb GF FX 5650 Go or ATI Radeon 9600 Pro Turbo to upgrade an 8500. Do you recomend the 8500 or 8600 as a base model (basicaly p4m vs pm).
I'm looking to do 3d gaming (ravenshield, battlefield 1942, C&C Generals)
Thanks for any info, Slasher_Psi
  • sLaShEr_PsI

    62 Posts

    422

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2005 03:00

    Do you have any idea about wheather I can upgrade an I8500 with the I8600's 128mb video cards? Also does the mig with the sigmatel card work with online steam because mine never worked on the maistro 3 on my I8000. It's not one of those headsets with the external sound card vai usb is it?

    Message Edited by sLaShEr_PsI on 04-27-2005 12:59 AM

  • Nashidar

    9 Posts

    422

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2005 03:00

    Hey bro,
     
    Well, I can tell you first hand experience on this one. I recently (well ... 3 months ago) purchased an Inspiron 8600 with an eye to use it as a desktop replacement for gaming and I can tell you it's pretty darn good.
     
    Important Specs:
    Intel Pentium M 745 (1.8GHz) Processor
    15.4" Wide Screen SXGA display (@1680x1050 resolution)
    1 GIG RAM
    128MB ATI Mobility Radeon 9600 Pro Turbo (currently using Dell's drivers)
    40GB Ultra ATA HDD (only 5400rpm disk ... looking to upgrade this)
     
    Additionally, I bought a Logitech MX 310 mouse - its great for gaming. I disabled the touchpad altogether (through the bios settings) so only the external mouse is registered.
     
    Even though it is there - I don't use the internal mic that came with the laptop. According to my clanmates it makes me sound like I am "on the toilet" :p. So instead I bought myself a decent headset (seinnheiser thing that cost me like $100+ or something stupid). It works really well and I recommend using a headset when you play any online FPS game anyway as it gives you better situational awareness.
     
    With the above spec's I manage to play Counter Strike: Source quite well (I am in a clan for it too). Mind you, when I play online, I pretty much push all the graphics to low so the game runs as smooth as possible. I can, however, play Half Life 2 (single player) at medium graphics setting quiet easily.
     
    I also play C&C Generals, SW: KOTOR, and Enemy Territory. I can quite easily be connected to irc (using mIRC), running steam, running ventrilo (voice chat program) and be playing online with CS:S with no issues at all. Sure the thing gets a little warm - but it doesn't overheat or anything and hasn't crashed on me.
     
    The only crashing I get is with KOTOR and that's because the video card drivers need to be updated so I will be trying out Omega ones pretty soon.
     
    Hope this helps.
  • sLaShEr_PsI

    62 Posts

    422

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2005 05:00

    Actualy I am talking about the online voice chat through Counter-Strike (HL1) but I asume they both use the same system. I have had it work on vent until it sudenly cracks the whole vent server with my terrible hissing. Anyways... I have seen that there are more than one card that work in the 8500 and the 8600 alike, and given their similarities i dont see why it wouldn't work. With all luck the descusion is accademic and I will get an 8600 with the radeon 9600 Pro Turbo 128mb. I have looked into the 8500 some more and it apears the 9600 pro turbo has some overheating problems in it. Would the GeForce 5650 128mb have the same overheating problems?

    Message Edited by sLaShEr_PsI on 04-27-2005 02:42 AM

  • Nashidar

    9 Posts

    422

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2005 05:00

    Not sure if you can upgrade the 8500 video card to the one in the 8600 - BUT I don't see why not considering both are AGP based cards (not PCIe cards). You are best to actually call Dell technical support on this rather than email Dell. It could take them a while to respond to the email IF they actually choose to respond to it. Plus if you call Dell - the onus is on the person you speak to. They have to make sure they are giving you the right information otherwise it would mean bad things (for them .. probably mean you get some compensation or something like a usb memory key :P).
     
    My headset is not one of those usb ones with external sound card or anything. It's a standard headset (i.e. headphone and mic) but its a really good one. It just plugs into the Mic and Headphone/Spk socket on your notebook (or PC for that matter) - which most notebooks should have as they come standard on sound cards.
     
    Now I have a question here - what do you mean when you say "online steam". Are talking about using the in-game voice chat in counter strike: source? If so, I THINK it did work fine. I'm not sure because I am not at home at the moment to test this out (at work at the moment). Once I get home I'll give it a try and post back here.
  • warmonger

    179 Posts

    422

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2005 12:00

    You will still have to MOD with the 5650FxGo as well as the 9600 turbo on the 8500 due to heat issues...but the mod is pretty simple as posted in the forum, only issue is being able to get the video cards from dell, you generally have to call several times before they will eventually send you one,unless you have luck on Ebay, price range is around 240.00, good luck....my 5650FxGo in my 8600 1.7 handles Doom 3 , Half Life 2, Far Cry, Ect.Ect,with relative ease........

    Specs 8600 1.7, 128Nvidia 5650FxGo, 768Mb 333DDR, 60 Gig Hd, 15.4 WSXGA+, 1300 Wireless, 4X DVDR+RW   

  • sLaShEr_PsI

    62 Posts

    422

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2005 13:00

    Would y'all recomomend that I do the mod even if I have an 8600? Also would a P4m I8500 or a Pm 8600 be better? Mic thing please dude...
  • Nashidar

    9 Posts

    422

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2005 22:00

    Heya,
     
    Well I tested out the mic with in-game in CS:S. Let's just say ... it works ... but it is nothing brilliant. Maybe I had to fine tune it a bit or something as when I tested (using the test under the Voice tab in CS:S options) the sound was ok (I would rate it as Barely Passable) - but it does sound like you are in an open area (i.e. "toilet" like). Nothing beats a headset so I advise getting a headset anyway. No problems with hissing or anything like that though. Tested with ventrillo and CS in-game voice and never got any hissing. Whether these results are also affected by the version of CS or ventrilo being used (amongts other things) - no idea.
     
    On heating problems - I was aware of people reporting heating problems but I've never had any (8600 with ati 9600 pro turbo). I can play CS (with all those other apps running) for upwards of about 4hrs and not get any overheating issues. It can also handle HL2 on high-ish settings as well - but seems to perform best (i.e. decent graphics quality, no sluggish feel in "intense" areas) when putting everything on Medium.
     
    I do advise getting the 8600 with the 9600 pro turbo card. Even though it may not the "Best Gaming Laptop" out there - it does a pretty good job for the price you pay for it.
     
    Just a note - I am in Australia (sydney to be exact) so if the times I am posting seem awkward you know why. :) I was going to post after I tested it out last night but I had a friend come over and we ended up having a few beers - before I knew it, it was 1am and I had to work the next day. :P
  • sLaShEr_PsI

    62 Posts

    422

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2005 23:00

    I'm a high school stuedent in California, that's worse. Any other info from other ppl will be apressiated. Also, thanks for the mic info, mine has a hardware problems. Gues sigmatel audio fixed that.