UNSOLVED

Allochthonous

updated

20 years ago

0

27615

December 17th, 2006 11:00

Video card uprgade for 4550 discussion revisited

I am resurrecting this thread, as I am back in the hunt for a video card upgrade:
 
 
Is the concensus still that the nVidia 6600 GT is my best bet for performance (mid range gaming) and cost (sub $100 - used)? 
 
And are you still assuring me that the stock 250 watt PSU can handle it without a problem?
 
The 6600 GT is still a bit pricey (for me) new.  What other options do I have in case I can't get ahold of one used in my price range?  I am open to ATI cards as well.
 
I just don't game that much, so I can't spend too much, but there are even some "older" games now that I can't, or can barely, play.  I am into RTS and FPS mainly. I would like to be able to play Age of Empires 3, maybe Rise of Legends,.
 
I am looking to get 2 or 3 more years out of this system, and I think with some RAM and a video card, I can do it.  Do you all agree?  Or should I save my money and just think about a new system sooner?
 
 
 
Specs again:
 
pretty much stock Dimension 4550
P4 2.4 ghz/533 mhz FSB
512 MB RAM
64 MB GeForce4 MX 420
1 CDRW drive (for now)
possibly a firewire card sometime maybe
 
250 watt PSU
 
 
 
Thanks
 
PK
  • SR45

    2 Intern

    •

    12138 Posts

    388

    0

    Posted December 17th, 2006 12:00

    Dell rates its power supplies to read only the mean average, to be on the safe side (Being more conservative), and the peak power is much higher to handle better cards that suggest a more powerful power supply. The card manufacture only suggests a more powerful power supply, so if you install additional optical drives, and memory, it can handle the overload, or, they are just being more liberal.

    This question is asked on a daily basis, and for a number of years. Many have upgraded their systems with a better video card that suggests a more powerful p/s, and they are doing just fine with their stock set up.
     
    I personally had the 6600 GT AGP card for over a year with my stock 250 watter.  I only had one hard drive, two optical drives and one gb of memory.  I kept the pci slot next to the card empty for better cooling as well.  Hope this helps a little.
     
    Don't go overboard with a better video card, and start saving for a new system.  The 6600 GT card should be enough.  Now its rated about mid to lower level, but still a good card to have
  • The pro

    2 Intern

    •

    685 Posts

    388

    0

    Posted December 18th, 2006 06:00

    I have a spare D4500
     
    P4 1.8Ghz
    2x Western digital 80GB HDD's
    Floppy drive
    Card reader (next to the floppy drive)
    DVD RW
    DVD ROM
    6600GT
    Ethernet card
    Sound card (SB 2 ZS)
    Extra PCI card for more USB ports.
     
    And the stock dell 250W PSU.
     
     
    I agree that you should save for a better computer.
    It is a waste if you want to upgrade beacuse you can't really play any of the new games coming out (and some that are already out)

    Message Edited by The pro on 12-18-200602:22 AM

  • 388

    0

    Posted December 19th, 2006 00:00

    SR45, thank you for the reply. I apologize for asking a question that is so frequently asked.  I guess I am just frustrated at both Dell and the video card companies for making the information so ambiguous that the avergae consumer has to "guess" or "hope" or settle for a lower end card that meets the presented requirements.
     
    I want to be sure (as sure as possible) that the card will work before I spend $70-100 on it and then it either does not work or messes something up.
     

    The Pro: I am not really into playing the cutting edge games, as I cannot afford them, nor do I have the time. Ideally, I am always a couple of years behind anyway, so I guess I am thinking that a $70 upgrade in video so I can play 1-2 year old games wouldn't be too bad.
     
    I can't really do much more than this card, anyway, due to the 4x AGP port and the PSU, right?
     
    PK
  • SR45

    2 Intern

    •

    12138 Posts

    388

    0

    Posted December 19th, 2006 12:00

    Many have reported installing the 7600 GS or GT version card and their stock 250 watt power supply.  Some also have reported issues with compatability with the older Dell system with these cards.  Go figure.  But the two mentioned cards should work on your system with the stock p/s.  They are better than the 6600 or 6600 GT cards that you are thinking of.  You can go even better, as I did, but really not worth it for our aging systems.    Good luck Allochthonous
     
    Dim 4400
    2.6 Ghz 400 FSB
    1 Gb 2100 DDR memory
    Windows XP Home
    120 Gb Seargate 7,200 drive
    24 inch 2407 WFP
    XFX 7800 GS O/C AGP
    16x DVD-R
    Symantec Internet Security 2007
    410 watt ( PcPower&Cooling )
  • Dale Nihiser

    2 Intern

    •

    2030 Posts

    388

    0

    Posted December 20th, 2006 20:00



    Allochthonous wrote:
    SR45, thank you for the reply. I apologize for asking a question that is so frequently asked.  I guess I am just frustrated at both Dell and the video card companies for making the information so ambiguous that the avergae consumer has to "guess" or "hope" or settle for a lower end card that meets the presented requirements.
     
    I want to be sure (as sure as possible) that the card will work before I spend $70-100 on it and then it either does not work or messes something up.
     

    The Pro: I am not really into playing the cutting edge games, as I cannot afford them, nor do I have the time. Ideally, I am always a couple of years behind anyway, so I guess I am thinking that a $70 upgrade in video so I can play 1-2 year old games wouldn't be too bad.
     
    I can't really do much more than this card, anyway, due to the 4x AGP port and the PSU, right?
     
    PK


    If your bread is really tight and you're only playing games from a couple of years ago then try the old venerable 9800pro.
     
     
    About 2 ~ 3 years ago, this card was king of the hill and sold for $299.00. 
     
    Agp cards like the 6600, 6600gt, x800 series seem to be drying up.  Another card to consider is the 6800xt:
     
     
    Good LucK
     
    Dale
     
    Cool Master Centurion 5 CAC-T05 Mid tower case
    AMD Athlon 64 3700+--->AMD Athlon 64 4000+ San Diego
    MSI K8N Neo4-F Socket 939 ATX motherboard
    1GB Cosair ValueSelect PC 3200 DDR 400 SDRAM
    EVGA GeForce 6800GS 256Mb GDDR3 PCI Express
    Maxtor DiamondMax 10 200Gb 7200rpm SATA 150 HD
    Plextor 708A 8x burner
    OCz GameXstream 700 watt psu
    Logitech Optical Mouse MX310
    Logitech Wingman Rumblepad
    Altec-Lansing headphones w/mic
    Viewsonic G90fb-2 19"
    Windows XP Home Sp2(all updates)
    D-Link 524 Wireless Ethernet Broadband Router
  • 388

    0

    Posted December 20th, 2006 20:00

    And either of these will work with the stock 250 watt PSU?
     
     
    pk
  • The pro

    2 Intern

    •

    685 Posts

    388

    0

    Posted December 21st, 2006 07:00

    Yes they will.
  • 388

    0

    Posted January 5th, 2007 12:00

    Hey, it's me again.
     
    I was just wondering if any brands (BFG, eVGA, XFX, etc) of the above cards (esp the 6600 GT)  are more compatible or better than others?  Or are they all pretty much the same?
     
    PK
  • The pro

    2 Intern

    •

    685 Posts

    388

    0

    Posted January 5th, 2007 18:00

    They are all the same.
     
    But I would start saving for a new computer now instead of getting upgrades for your 4550
  • 385

    0

    Posted January 5th, 2007 23:00

    Well, considering it will be a while before I can afford a new machine, wouldn't you say that if i can pick one up for $80 or so on ebay, it would be worth that to tide me over?
     
    PK