UNSOLVED

Mankycat

updated

18 years ago

M

Mankycat

11 Posts

0

11764

June 30th, 2008 14:00

Questions about the XPS 730 and CrossfireX

After I found that I couldn't uninstall Sim City Societies using either windows control panel or the game uninstaller I decided to do a clean install of windows Vista on my dual HD3870x2 equipped XPS 730. Everything went fine until I installed the graphics drivers using the latest Catalyst Suite from ATI (8.6) after which there was no option to enable CrossfireX in the Catalyst Control Centre. Now this isn't the first time that this has happened to me and you can read all about it in this topic XPS 730, Does anyone Have a Working One?

 

After several complete reinstalls of Vista I have finally got it working again, however there are a few issues I would like clarified.

 

1. The User Guide for the HD3870x2 implies that there should be diagnostic information under the CrossfireX tab in the Catalyst Control Centre and the option to select which card will be the master GPU. I have, and have never had, any information at all there, just an empty box.

 

 

 

Does anyone with an XPS 730 have diagnostic information there? Does anyone with a properly working Crossfire setup on any pc have diagnostic information there?

 

2. Why is the XPS 730 offered in a dual HD3870x2 crossfire configuration when the NVIDIA nForce 790i Ultra SLI chipset is not certified as CrossfireX compatible by ATI?

 

3. If this is the case and it is truly not compatible, have Dell fudged the ATI drivers that are available from their website in order to overcome this problem? This would neatly explain why a clean Vista install using the latest ATI drivers doesn't work, but a clean Vista install using the Dell supplied drivers does. Upgrading from the Dell drivers works, but if I uninstall them in order to have a clean driver install, I lose crossfire again.

Am I now tied into using only the drivers available from Dell, which are at least 2 updates behind those of ATI? What if I want to upgrade to Vista 64, where can I get drivers for that?

 

I'm beginning to think that Dell have pushed out a poorly tested machine, using incompatible components in order to keep it below the price point of their high end Alienware rigs. I spent a lot of money on buying what I thought would be a cutting edge gaming pc, and now I'm unconvinced that even when the Enable CrossfireX option is available and ticked, that it is working correctly. So I would appreciate some answers from Dell regarding these issues as soon as possible before I have to take the matter further

Message Edited by Mankycat on 06-30-2008 10:59 AM
Message Edited by Mankycat on 06-30-2008 11:01 AM
Message Edited by Mankycat on 06-30-2008 11:04 AM
  • snr666

    85 Posts

    421

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2008 00:00

    i sometimes get the crossfire option and then other times i lose it on my 730. one tool i have installed from guru3d, is ati tools tray. that allows you to play with the crossfire. its free and seems to work fine.
  • snr666

    85 Posts

    421

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2008 07:00

    what dell will do about it, well i am currently waiting for a dell tech to turn up and change my motherboard and 2 graphic cards. they seem to think all my issues will go away. really.

     

    to get the dual ati to work, they want you to:

     

    - remove all ati drivers

    - remove a graphics cards

    - install drivers for the remaining cards

    - make sure that works

    - install the other graphics card

    - which will auto install drivers

     

    and all sholud work. i go exactly the same as before. infact the dell tech on the phone wanted me to pull the graphics cards out, when it did not want to come. he had no idea there is a catch locking the card in, or that part of the cooling unit cover the graphic cards and needs to be removed. so if you ever do that, beware, its not easy.

     

    the benefit of the dual cards is shown in the 3dMark06 results:

     

    - just one card; 3dMark06 score = 12455

    - before cards in; 3dMark06 = 18561

     

    but still my computer shows 2 of the GPUs in device manager with warnings. but they are clearly working.

     

    i wanted the nvidia cards, but dell say no. so lets see what this dell tech does when he turns up.

     

    Intel(R) Core(TM)2 Extreme CPU X9650 @ 3.5GHz

    Dual ATI Radeon HD 3870 X2

    4096MB 1333 Mhz DDR3

    1.0Tb Raid 0 (2x500Gb)

    Soundblaster X-Fi Extreme

    Windows XP 32 Bit

  • Mankycat

    11 Posts

    421

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2008 07:00

    Thanks snr I was thinking of taking a look at the ATI Tool Tray as CCC is said to be a bit of a memory hog, I'll definitely go check it out now.

     

    I suppose what I really want to know is whether this is a problem with my XPS, in which case fine I can go and spend the next week trying to get a solution from tech support, or if it's because of poor design.

     

    If it's the latter then I need to know what Dell is going to do about it. Not only because I would be a little bit cross if they had sold me a bodged up bundle of bits rather than a well thought out and fully compatible rig, but because it's going to be a major problem for me in the near future if I am unable to upgrade to Vista 64.

     

    I've also posted over at the ATI forums to see what they have to say about the nForce 790i Ultra SLI and CrossfireX.

     

    Manky

     

    Intel(R) Core(TM)2 Extreme CPU X9650 @ 3.5GHz

    Dual ATI Radeon HD 3870 X2

    4096MB 1333 Mhz DDR3

    1.5T Raid 0 (2x750Gb)

    128Mb Ageia PhysX Card

    Soundblaster X-Fi Extreme

    Windows Vista Home Premium 32 Bit

  • snr666

    85 Posts

    421

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2008 13:00

    here's some news for you. a dell tech just phoned (3pm) saying the dell engineer coming with the new motherboard and 2 new dual ati graphic cards, is not coming today. so another waste of a day, thanks DELL, i only tiedup my room and have been waiting since 8am. but he then stated, the problem had been sent to the R&D dept at Dell for analysis over these problems with ati cards, as Dell has had many issues from customers over them. so they seem to be slowly identifying there is a problem with these ati cards and the 730. in fact, if they could not resolve them, they may have to change to nvidia cards. excellant i said, i want nvidia evalute cards (9800gx2). but its not that easy, the R&D dept has to authorise this.

     

    so an engineer is now booked for next monday to come out and do what, i dont know and exchange what, i dont know.

     

    Dell really have to do much better than this.

  • Mankycat

    11 Posts

    421

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2008 15:00

    Thanks for letting me know that. It looks like Dell might be getting around to admitting they have made a mistake.

     

    Here is my answer from the admins at AMD Game Forums, now that looks fairly clear cut to me. I'm going to try and raise the issue with the AMD tech support people now, and maybe over at NVidia too.

     

     

     

    Manky

    Message Edited by Mankycat on 07-01-2008 11:59 AM