UNSOLVED

ronzee

updated

19 years ago

R

ronzee

4 Posts

0

12875

February 15th, 2008 17:00

Precision 670 Fan Noise

I see there are LOTS of posts about fan noise. My Precision 670 fan gets cranked up and stays on medium high even though there is little processor activity. It is Noisy! I've had the motherboard, cpu, heatsink, powersupply, fan replaced twice under warranty. Some items replaced 3 times.

I booted Windows PE from a CD, ran defrag and the fan speed stayed low through the entire process. That tells me that it is my Windows XP OS doing it. My Windows XP is updated with all Windows patches and I re-installed Dell's chipset drivers.

The on-site tech mentioned that he knew of someone else who had a similar problem where it was caused by a windows update. He removed that particular update an it worked properly. He could have been refering to a Dell driver which makes more sense.

Does anyone know anything about Windows XP OS updates or Dell drivers that control the fan speed?

Ron
  • x_lab rat

    1976 Posts

    128

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2008 17:00

    Hi, Ron.  I supported 670 briefly, not long enough to know every possible detail, and any one platform can vary from convention.  As a rule, Dells of that era controlled the fan entirely in hardware, even blocking fan and temperature software from reading or altering parameters.

     

    Sony desktops do load a factory fan-control driver under Windows.  This could also be the case with 670, and although as above that would go against convention, the 670 is not exactly a conventional desktop.

     

    All the fan-noise issues I encountered resulted from a manufacturing defect in the heatsink (99%) or the CPU (1%).  Your observation that it will run quietly from a boot CD rather negates that observation.  But you can verify that the replacement heatsinks you were sent do not have the defect.  While the fan is running fast, feel the base of the heatsink and then the tubes.  If the base is hot and the tubes are cold, the defect is present.

     

    On OS and driver updates, if the system is working right it is unadvisable to update unless there is a specific feature or security patch that you know you want/need.  A little late for that now.  There can be a disagreement between WXP updates and drivers installed under them, but sorry, I don't have knowledge of the specifics of those interactions in the 670 so I'll have to leave that to someone else.

  • oopsltd

    25 Posts

    128

    0

    Posted February 20th, 2008 18:00

    Hi ronzee,

     

    I've been having the most horrific trouble with my new T7400 and the so-called Dell Precision Workstation Technical Support whom I wouldn't trust to diagnose a fault in my toaster.

     

    They have sent an engineer with a screwdriver out to me twice to pointlessly replace fans.  This is without even advising me what they were going to do in the first place.  Had they done so, I'd have refused the visit as it was pointless waste of time and money.  The engineer had told me and Dell Technical Support that there was a clear problem with the fans spinning up to full speed and then not throttling back and advised a change of motherboard.  Dell denied that he said this.  Either they leaned on him to change is story or are just plain lying to me.  By implication they are calling me a liar by insisting that the engineer did not say this.

     

    They are now refusing point blank to honour their responsibilities under the Sale of Goods Act 1979 never mind the extended 5 year warranty I've paid good money for.  It's the most shocking display of Customer Disservice I've experienced since the last time I dealt with Dell.  Why did I buy from them again I hear you ask?  Well, the issues I had were eventually resolved to my satisfaction so I gave them the benefit of the doubt again and I was hoping for third time lucky.

     

    Anyway, here is my thread: http://www.dellcommunity.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=Desktops_Workstation_Optiplex&message.id=5125&query.id=128288#M5125

     

    I'm working on a letter of complaint direct to the senoir management of Dell.  I can't be bothered spending hours and days of my time beating up Customer Services.

     

    Cheers,

     

    Jim