
UNSOLVED
W
waughhouse
8 Posts
0
8303
May 28th, 2002 12:00
Do I want to do this?
If only I had waited...
I bought a Dell 8100 about 18 months ago with Windows ME. Now I am discovering that (inspite of this computer's muscular appearance) there is a limit on RAM and functionality with WIN ME. I am bumping up against those limitations.. with screen locks and manual shutdowns. I have contacted Dell, but once I start talking about XP, I get the 'not my problem' syndrome.
Of course, Dell will sell me Windows XP, but they will not support it. I have been in this situation with Gateway once before, and had all kinds of headaches in that they also would not support an upgrade from Windows 95 to Windows 98... if you had not purchased the Windows 98 from them. I think Gateway had a better idea about this than Dell - even though I have a new Windows SE edition still in the box that I purchased just to get the support. The last thing I want is to be dependant upon Microsoft for support.
How great a problem am I looking at to change over to Windows XP with my configuration? Will I regret this when, and surely if, I have problems with XP down the road? I don't want to be a stepchild. Suggestions please! Thanks!
Karen
- Dimension 8100
- P-4/1.4GHz/ Win ME
- Intel 82801 BA
- Intel 86 compatible with SSE2
- 768 MB PC800 RDRAM
- 40G Ultra ATA / 7200 RPM
- ACPI BIOS 3.15.00.11.02
- 19" P991 FD Trinitron
- 250MB Iomega Zip
- 64 MB DDR nVidia Ge2 Ultra w/DVI 4x AGP
- 16 x DVD ROM / NEC DV-5800A
- CED 8120B CD-RW
- Altec Lansing ACS-340 w/subwoofer
- Microsoft Natural USB Keyboard
- TB Santa Cruz DSP
- Epson Color 980
- HP Scanjet 6300C
- 3Com 3C90 Ethernet (3C905C-TX compatible)
- RoadRunner
-
I bought a Dell 8100 about 18 months ago with Windows ME. Now I am discovering that (inspite of this computer's muscular appearance) there is a limit on RAM and functionality with WIN ME. I am bumping up against those limitations.. with screen locks and manual shutdowns. I have contacted Dell, but once I start talking about XP, I get the 'not my problem' syndrome.
Of course, Dell will sell me Windows XP, but they will not support it. I have been in this situation with Gateway once before, and had all kinds of headaches in that they also would not support an upgrade from Windows 95 to Windows 98... if you had not purchased the Windows 98 from them. I think Gateway had a better idea about this than Dell - even though I have a new Windows SE edition still in the box that I purchased just to get the support. The last thing I want is to be dependant upon Microsoft for support.
How great a problem am I looking at to change over to Windows XP with my configuration? Will I regret this when, and surely if, I have problems with XP down the road? I don't want to be a stepchild. Suggestions please! Thanks!
Karen
- Dimension 8100
- P-4/1.4GHz/ Win ME
- Intel 82801 BA
- Intel 86 compatible with SSE2
- 768 MB PC800 RDRAM
- 40G Ultra ATA / 7200 RPM
- ACPI BIOS 3.15.00.11.02
- 19" P991 FD Trinitron
- 250MB Iomega Zip
- 64 MB DDR nVidia Ge2 Ultra w/DVI 4x AGP
- 16 x DVD ROM / NEC DV-5800A
- CED 8120B CD-RW
- Altec Lansing ACS-340 w/subwoofer
- Microsoft Natural USB Keyboard
- TB Santa Cruz DSP
- Epson Color 980
- HP Scanjet 6300C
- 3Com 3C90 Ethernet (3C905C-TX compatible)
- RoadRunner
-
Responses (6)
Solutions (0)
- I agree with Denny. Despite all the Microsoft bashing that goes on, XP is a very good OS. Not perfect, but then what is. It's much better than Win 98. Don't know about ME. I would advise you to buy the Boxed Retail Upgrade version of XP. NOT the OEM version. The reason for this is MS doesn't provide support for the OEM version. They will for the box. Decide whether or not you need the extra capabilities of Pro. Go here http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/pro/ for the XP Pro site. Here for XP Home http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/default.asp I've seen XP Home go for as little as $90 at Fry's Electronics ( upgrade version ). Just make sure you do a clean install of XP. http://www.winsupersite.com/showcase/windowsxp_sg.asp There have been a lot of posts about the problems people will have with an upgrade as opposed to a clean install. Part of your reluctance to upgrade, I'm sure is related to the fact that you're familar with ME and are reluctant to change. That's just human nature. Given all the problems that have been posted concerning ME, I think it would be a mistake NOT to upgrade. I'm not being a shill for MS, this is just my opinion, nothing more.
Dimension 4400
1.8A GHZ
768 MB DDR
Maxtor D740X / 80GB
NEC 5800 DVD ROM
GE 8160B CDRW
Geforce3 Ti200
Soundblaster 5.1
NEC FE700+ 17" monitor
XP Home
Roxio Platinum
Zone Alarm Pro
AdSubtract Pro
Adaware
Sandra 2002
Belarc Advisor waughhouse
8 Posts
353
0
Posted May 28th, 2002 14:00
>>Part of your reluctance to upgrade, I'm sure is related to the fact that you're familar with ME and are reluctant to change. That's just human nature. Given all the problems that have been posted concerning ME, I think it would be a mistake NOT to upgrade.<<
It's not that I am reluctant to upgrade, I DO want to VERY much. But I am reluctant to go 'naked' without support from Dell... which is probably dumb, as the Dell support, though always there, has been greatly inconsistent. You seldom get the same advice from different techs, which has always bothered me. God forbid that your problem requires more than one phone call! Here, one might expect to get different opinions based on personal experience of forum members. You'd think the Dell guys would all go by the Dell 'playbook'. :-)
Thanks for the excellent pointers and links! :-o I AM going to upgrade, I just depend on this computer too much to have downtime that I can't readily fix or locate help for... :-/
- Dimension 8100
- P-4/1.4GHz/ Win ME
- Intel 82801 BA
- Intel 86 compatible with SSE2
- 768 MB PC800 RDRAM
- 40G Ultra ATA / 7200 RPM
- ACPI BIOS 3.15.00.11.02
- 19" P991 FD Trinitron
- 250MB Iomega Zip
- 64 MB DDR nVidia Ge2 Ultra w/DVI 4x AGP
- 16 x DVD ROM / NEC DV-5800A
- CED 8120B CD-RW
- Altec Lansing ACS-340 w/subwoofer
- Microsoft Natural USB Keyboard
- TB Santa Cruz DSP
- Epson Color 980
- HP Scanjet 6300C
- 3Com 3C90 Ethernet (3C905C-TX compatible)
- RoadRunner
-
Message Edited on 05/28/02 10:57AM by waughhouse- You are absolutely dead on about Dell's erratic quality of support. The last time I called with an OS problem, they wanted me to pay!! NOT!! Because my system was more than 30 days old. Evidently they don't do OS support past this 30 days point. That's why I suggested the box retail version of XP. At least MS will give you some support. They are a lot of good XP books out there, you just have to find one that you are comfortable with. That, and DellTalk will end up being your real support.
Dimension 4400
1.8A GHZ
768 MB DDR
Maxtor D740X / 80GB
NEC 5800 DVD ROM
GE 8160B CDRW
Geforce3 Ti200
Soundblaster 5.1
NEC FE700+ 17" monitor
XP Home
Roxio Platinum
Zone Alarm Pro
AdSubtract Pro
Adaware
Sandra 2002
Belarc Advisor - As for the XP upgrade, as long as you do it carefully and correctly, you will not have any problems. Make sure you detach any printers, scanners ect from the back of the system before installing. Also, check the Dell site and get any XP drivers you may need.You will still be supported by Dell for the drivers you get from the site and all hardware that came in your system.
In regards to Dells fee-based support. The only time you must pay for support is when you have problems with specific software. Their technical support will not walk you through MS Office to fix errors, ect. If you were sent to the fee-based support, your problem was not a typical OS issue was was either specific to a program or was beyond their realm of typical support.

Denny Denham
2 Intern
•
18798 Posts
353
0
Posted May 28th, 2002 13:00
If you peruse the Windows XP conference you will find many users with 8100s and much older systems who have happily made the transition to XP. You may find that one or two of your peripherals won't be supported by XP drivers (you can determine this by running the Upgrade Advisor, available here